What’s the future of classical concerts?
During the pandemic, it seemed to be virtual concerts, the best of the best streamed all around the world directly into listeners’ homes as musical organizations leapt to purchase better equipment. Now, however, most organizations have gone back to business as usual, many with tighter budgets.
Even before Covid, a Pittsburgh organization has been toying with futurism, however. The Pittsburgh New Music Ensemble, which claims to be the “oldest continually running new music ensemble” in the country, opened its final summer season (remember, budgets are tight post-pandemic) on Friday at City Theater in the South Side by putting all of its several dozen listeners in headphones.
The quality of musicianship for this small chamber group is higher here than any locally based new music ensemble, but the headphones leap out as a sticking point.
The first work on the program, a piece by University of Boulder professor Carter Pann for clarinet, violin, cello, and piano, proved a delightful diversion, a tuneful, tonal exploration of different blends of instrumental sounds and passionate gestures.
PNME uses a “binaural microphone” to process its concerts, which allows the sound techs to make the sound seem like it’s coming from different directions and blend it in real time. In headphones, the sound was rich and vibrant, with a touch more reverberation than the dry theater would typically allow. I’m unconvinced it was more enjoyable than listening sans headphones, however.
Read More
Without the ear cans, the sound had more “ring” thanks to the way each instrument's overtones interacted directly with the space and listeners’ ears. This natural sound is special — I’m not sure it’s a good tradeoff for the pros of using the binaural technology.
(Later in the season, on July 21 and 22, PNME will perform music written with the binaural tech specifically in mind to take full advantage. This may work brilliantly. Time will tell.)
The remainder of the program, conducted by artistic director Kevin Noe, featured Western Michigan University professor James Mobberly’s “Words of Love,” which calls for a female soprano. Lindsay Kesselman, PNME’s resident singer, was superb. Here, the binaural tech allowed for a richer blend of instruments and voice, obviating any balance issues. Finally, the evening concluded with “Night Music” by Pennsylvania-born composer Thomas Albert. Seven movements evoked the stillness of the dark (with one notable section referencing the night’s terrors), though once again, I was unsure of the value added by the binaural technology.
This organization gets much right in terms of public appeal. Subtle lighting changes, a brief, one-hour program, approachable music, post-concert receptions to discuss the experience, and a warm, intimate atmosphere.
Alas, this summer is the organization’s swan song in its current space, as diminishing funding forces it to evolve into a small, year-round company rather than continue in its current summer festival mode. Summers are normally a time for brand new music, but this summer is a tour of recent favorites by the musicians as they prepare to record the music. The future is murky.
But while they’re here, the concerts are still compelling opportunities for engagement for the artistically curious.
PNME’s summer programs continue on Fridays and Saturdays for the next three weeks. See pnme.org for more details.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.