There’s a tendency in classical music to adhere to the printed page with almost cult-like fanaticism. After all, the composers — the patron saints of classical music — know best, right?

Well, here’s the historical rub: in Beethoven’s day, the “text” of the music was far less sacred than it is today. There are tales of Beethoven leaving entire pages of music blank when he performed with orchestras so he could invent and embellish on the spot, dazzling listeners with his ingenuity. Performers improvised often in showcases of skill and even musical “duels.”

Imagine a symphony concert where, instead of hearing an orchestra play the same concerto with a new soloist for the dozenth time and hanging on slight differences of interpretation to differentiate performances, conductors and soloists revisited the tradition of time past and made the music more their own. That sounds exciting, to me. Such concerts might reinterpret a much-needed element of spontaneity and uniqueness to performances of older repertoire.

Onward to Friday’s concert, when violinist Gil Shaham played Beethoven’s exalted violin concerto with the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra in Heinz Hall. In the third movement, Shaham indeed took liberties with the music toying with the tempo and even working with the orchestra to add in a brief passage to reintroduce the main theme. Like or dislike his interpretation, it was certainly fresh.

Advertise with us

Would that more soloists took a page out of that book.

The concerto’s historical significance is undeniable. In his dressing room after Friday’s rehearsal, Shaham waxed poetic about the fact that this was the first work of such scale and emotional scope. He’s right, of course. This is the concerto that vaulted the violin onward to works with greater depths of expression and nuance and range. That doesn’t mean it’s universally beloved, however. Personally, I find the first movement’s straightforward themes and frequent repetition and pauses for solo passagework to give the music a choppy, static quality at times.

On Friday, Shaham and the orchestra started at a brisker, lighter pace than is typically heard that allowed the tunes to breathe and sing more naturally. Shaham explained to me that there were similarities between the concerto’s tunes and a roughly concurrent sonata he’d written that suggested the concerto should be played faster, and that this was corroborated by tempo markings on a historic piano score of the concerto. I was convinced, but old habits die hard. The orchestra, particularly the winds, dragged often, slowing back to a more trudging pace despite Shaham dancing ahead. And dance he did, literally and musically, throughout the concerto. Shaham is one of the top violinists performing today, and his discography is worth a deep dive on any streaming platform. Friday’s performance was utterly exquisite, regardless of whether one agreed with his creative decisions.

Now, the conductor: Russian conductor Dima Slobodeniouk opened the concert with a touching performance of Kyiv-born composer Valentin Silvestrov’s “Prayer for Ukraine,” a soft, shimmering paean. Following the concert, the orchestra launched into an unconvincing Prokofiev’s Symphony No. 5. Like in the Beethoven, the work seemed to lose edge and energy often — Slobodeniouk needed to snap the metaphorical reigns. The second movement, for example, has a driving accompaniment that propels a sneering tune in the winds and strings. It was blurry and lacked attitude  on Friday. Shorter note lengths and a quicker tempo could add some bite. The final two movements two seemed to have all of the vigor polished and buffed right out, bleaching the music of its vitality and excitement. A surprising change for such a high-octane ensemble.

This concert repeats Sunday at 2:30 p.m. Tickets begin at $20 at pittsburghsymphony.org.

Advertise with us

Gil Shaham also performs Saturday in Heinz Hall at 8 p.m. in a PSO360 performance where the audience sits onstage alongside the musicians for a more intimate experience. Those tickets are $95 at pittsburghsymphony.org.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; Twitter @Reynolds_PG. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.