David Crosby was a difficult, cantankerous character who got booted from The Byrds for his ego and wasn’t on speaking terms with his other Rock and Roll Hall of Fame bandmates, Stephen Stills, Graham Nash and Neil Young.
But, man, could he sing!
Crosby, who died Wednesday at 81, handled the middle harmonies in the incomparable Crosby, Stills & Nash, a trio considered the gold standard in the realm of folk-rock, a genre replete with breathtaking vocal combinations.
While all but written off for dead in the ’80s, the ‘60s icon not only thrived in his sixth decade of music-making, he somehow maintained his bold tenor as many of his peers were getting raspier with age.
In a 2016 interview, I asked him how that could be possible.
“I don’t know,” he replied. “I am completely baffled. I have no [expletive] idea. I’m singing as well or better than I ever have. God knows I did everything wrong, and I’ve only been taking care of myself for the last 20 years of my 75. Before that, I just abused the [expletive] out of myself. So, it’s pretty strange, but it’s good. I sang really well last night. I sang “Guinnevere” maybe as well as I’ve ever sung it in my life, so I don’t know what to do except be grateful and revel in it.”
In recent years, Pittsburgh fans were fortunate to spend a handful of intimate evenings with Crosby at the Carnegie of Homestead Music Hall where he would mix classic material from the ’60s and ’70s with songs from the rush of five albums he released in the last decade of his life.
Flashing back, his Pittsburgh debut was as a 24-year-old on the biggest stage in town, the Civic Arena, as a member of the Byrds. It was a stacked holiday bill in November 1965 with The Rolling Stones, Bo Diddley, Paul Revere & the Raiders, The Vibrations and We Five.
That June, the Byrds had pioneered folk-rock with a jangly cover of Bob Dylan’s “Mr. Tambourine Man” that went to No. 1 on the charts. A month before the arena show, they returned to the top of the charts with an equally bright cover of Pete Seeger’s “Turn! Turn! Turn!” They hit the road hailed as America’s answer to the Beatles, though audiences would discover that the LA quintet, while blazing a new trail, had nowhere near the charisma of the Fab Four.
(As an aside, being a fly on the wall with the hard-headed, cape-wearing Crosby interacting with the Stones and Bo Diddley backstage would have been priceless.)
The next time he returned, Crosby, who was ousted from the Byrds in 1967, had a new group of friends as a member of the supergroup Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. They famously played their second-ever gig at Woodstock in August 1969, following the release of the beloved self-titled Crosby, Stills & Nash debut album that May. In an era when the Grammys were laughably out of touch, they knew enough to award CSN as Best New Artist for that stunning collection, on which Crosby contributed the delicate “Guinnevere” and edgy “Long Time Gone.”
The Pittsburgh CSN&Y debut was in December 1969 at the Civic Arena, four months before the quartet issued “Deja Vu,” which included Crosby’s dizzying title track and scorching anthem “Almost Cut My Hair.”
Over the next three decades, CSN were arena staples here, fueled in part by the worthy followup albums “CSN” (1977) and “Daylight Again” (1982), filled with such gems as “Southern Cross,” “Dark Star” and “Wasted on the Way.”
They even made their way here in 1985 and 1987, years that bookended Crosby’s stint in a Texas prison on drug and weapons charges. During those years, it wasn’t uncommon for Crosby to mysteriously disappear from the stage for short stretches. At the 1985 arena show, Crosby was missing for 45 minutes while Stills and Nash carried the show, taking turns backstage trying to get him to finish the show, which he eventually did.
In an interview prior to the concert, Nash said of his 45-year-old partner, “We are trying to sway him from the dark side of life.”
Rich Engler, founder of promoter DiCesare-Engler Productions, vividly remembers the backstage scene.
Stills and Nash did their separate solo songs and when it was time to bring Crosby back, they found the singer half-asleep in his dressing room.
While Stills extended his portion, “Graham grabbed a glass of ice water and poured it on David’s head,” Engler says. “You wanna talk about a rude awakening. David wakes up, ‘Wha? Wha? What?’ Graham goes, ‘Get up, get a towel and get the hell out there. And he did.”
In brighter days, their biggest Pittsburgh show was on July 8, 1990, opening for the Grateful Dead at Three Rivers Stadium before 46,000 fans.
Their best Pittsburgh show, without a doubt, was on March 18, 2000 when a reunited Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young blew into the Civic Arena like a hurricane. The unforgettable moments included Young letting loose with Crosby on the Byrds classic “Eight Miles High,” Crosby’s fiery reading of “Almost Cut My Hair” and a Stills-Young climactic guitar showdown for the ages.
The quartet was back again in 2002 and one last time in 2006, at Star Lake on the Freedom of Speech Tour, in fierce protest of the Bush administration and the Iraq War.
The final, unheralded CSN tour in 2015, following a band rift over Crosby’s disparaging comments about Young’s divorce, did not stop in Pittsburgh.
Since then, Crosby has appeared here solo as the old sage during this last, productive stretch of his career.
“I got out of CSN and three records happened in a row: “Croz” and then “Lighthouse” and “Sky Trails,” he told me in 2017. “And the reason for this trifecta, part of it is me feeling a release, a freedom of getting back on my own and not being in a situation where I was unhappy.
“I think we were all unhappy. I’m not trying to slag those guys. They weren’t any happier with me than I was with them. But it wasn’t happy and it wasn’t producing good music. So it’s time to go. I think there was a head of steam built up, a lot of pent-up creative juice there.”
It served Crosby well as both a recording artist in his 70s and spiky, outspoken character on social media.
“I like communicating with people,” he told me. “They fascinate me. Yes, there’s some dumb questions. The 99th time they ask you “What was it really like at Woodstock?’ it’s dumb. But mostly, it’s really fun, it’s fascinating. People are interesting as hell.”
Crosby himself was interesting till the end. What hurts today, for millions of fans around world, is that those treasured harmonies have passed away with him...long time gone.
“What a great loss,” Engler says. “No more Crosby, Stills & Nash, no more Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. No more David Crosby, in general. So that in itself is gonna be truly missed by all the fans they gathered over the years.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.