DUSSELDORF, Germany — There are faces made for radio. There are concert halls made for photography.
Despite a forbidding exterior, the inside Tonhalle (“tone-hall”) in Dusseldorf, Germany, is visually stunning, with its symmetry and royal blue details and warm natural wood finish. Built as the world’s largest planetarium in 1926, it was converted into the city’s concert hall in the 1970s.

On Saturday, it hosted the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra with music director Manfred Honeck in a program of Schumann and Mahler, another stunning installment on its already-lauded international tour.
The hall’s acoustics, however, left something to be desired. Given its origin, it shouldn’t be surprising to learn that it’s a completely round room with a terribly high ceiling. (Perhaps a removable acoustic shell could help?) The orchestra’s sound was unfocused and evaporated quickly. There was a little warmth and blend, but no “ring” — this made the orchestra sound a bit small in all but its most powerful moments, as in the climax of the first movement of Mahler’s Symphony No. 1, an explosion of color and sound, all militant brass and celebratory strings.
Acoustics aside, the Tonhalle was also far from full. At about 2,500 seats, it perhaps faces the same problem as the 2,800-seat Heinz Hall in Pittsburgh: It’s simply too large to fill consistently.
Then again, the concert was also competing with another Dusseldorf mainstay, the “Gourmet Festival,” expected to draw about 100,000 people to the city’s streets among and restaurants this week.
Read More
Partygoers included numerous roving gangs of German bachelor parties clad in tuxedo T-shirts, out for a good night’s carousing. Curiously, the T-shirts were different colors (I spotted black, purple and green parties), perhaps to keep things straight after the first few rounds.
“It’s the biggest open-air food festival in all of Europe, people demonstrating their culinary specialties,” said Dusseldorf’s mayor, Stephan Keller, in a conversation during intermission.
“We are an international city, and we always like to have international people here,” he added. “To have the symphony orchestra of Pittsburgh is a great pleasure to us.”
The consul general for Dusseldorf, Pauline Kao, was also present, and both were able to squeeze in a grip and grin with conductor Manfred Honeck after the concert. It’s common for dignitaries and statesmen to catch the symphony when it’s abroad, apparently.

“Music is a universal language. … It absolutely does everything for diplomacy, and of course there’s a trade and commercial aspect,” Kao said.
Back to the concert. Pianist Helen Grimaud joined the orchestra once more for a stunning, scintillating performance of Schumann’s Piano Concerto in A Minor. In the second half, the Mahler captivated in its soulful moments. There’s a soft passage in the fourth and final movement that Honeck and the orchestra delivered with prayerful reverence. Each performance on tour, a different moment in the symphony stands out as special.
Though the hall wasn’t packed, listeners still gave the orchestra a full-throated ovation, demanding a pair of encores before retiring to the cool evening, perhaps to join the nearby festival in its revelries.
The Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra next performs Tuesday in Essen, Germany.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; Twitter @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds’ work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.