HAMBURG, Germany — Seating at the Elbphilharmonie in Hamburg goes fully around the stage. So when the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra finished its Thursday performance, applause rose to a roar from behind the players when conductor Manfred Honeck turned the ensemble around to acknowledge the listeners in the rear of the auditorium.
The hall seats about 2,000, nearly 800 fewer than Heinz Hall in Pittsburgh. And it was quite full. Backstage is all soft white and clean lines. It’s a welcoming, warm space. After the concert, Honeck welcomed guests from home and abroad in high spirits, packing people into his dressing room for photos and basking in the glow of another successful tour concert.

It’s become a familiar scene in the last week.
“I played the encore for you,” Honeck joked to French cellist Gautier Capucon, who earlier in the evening played Dvorak’s Cello Concerto with the orchestra.
“It was arranged by Debussy, have you heard of him?,” he joked.
Capucon is one of several soloists dipping in and out of the tour to appear with the Pittsburgh Symphony in different halls around Germany. His Dvorak was Romantic with a capital “R,” stretching time often and luxuriating in the famous melodies.
Read More
“We cook this music together, the music director and orchestra and I,” Capucon said in a chat before the concert in his own dressing room. “There must by trust and dialogue.”
Even after years playing the same work, soloists will experiment on the fly with different ways of playing certain passages, taking liberties in the moment to exaggerate effects and emotions. This is part of the thrill and energy of live performance. It can be overdone, however.
While his Dvorak was powerful, Capucon tended to play a bit ahead of the orchestra, as though pulling them along to a slightly faster tempo. This was slightly distracting to my ears.
The ensemble opened the evening with “Five Pieces” by Erwin Schulhoff, a composer blacklisted by the Nazis who died in a concentration camp. Honeck arranged the pieces, originally for string quartet, himself for full orchestra, exploring various combinations of instruments with simple, bitingly angular melodies and harmonies.
I wasn’t thrilled by the work in Heinz Hall, but in the Elbphilharmonie, the acoustic allowed for far more nuance and detail in timbre. There was less reverberation, meaning individual instruments could be heard more clearly. It’s quirky, diverting music, pensive and cerebral.
The finale was a suite from the Strauss opera “Elektra,” a collection of music from the work grafted into a winding orchestral tone poem. It proved an excellent vehicle for the orchestra to demonstrate its skill and passion, a winning contrast with the Schulhoff. The orchestra whispered, roared and gnashed appropriately, conjuring sensations of foreboding and victory. Low brass were particularly menacing.
This is appropriate — the Greek tragedy the opera is based on explores death and and justice and comeuppance.
For those interested in other opinions on the orchestra, Susan Apthorp wrote about Wednesday’s performance for slippedisc.com: “In Mahler’s first symphony, Pittsburgh showed that it can be at least Viennese as it is American. ... His Mahler, attentive to the score’s many tempo indications, has both velvet delicacy and sledge-hammer violence...” This is in addition, of course, to repeated enormous ovations in recent days and numerous other reviews of PSO recordings from around the world praising the orchestra’s playing.
World-famous indeed. Onward to Essen and Dusseldorf.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.