There’s a difference between hearing and listening.

Anyone can sit in a concert hall and let a concert of wash over their ears, ordered pitches and harmonies caressing the senses. But to listen actively can transform that experience from a passive, pleasant experience to an engaging mental exercise.

It’s not a necessary practice to enjoy a concert, and there’s no right or wrong way to do this.

Take Beethoven's first piano concerto, which begins with a simple, stately tune in the strings. Its phrases, sort of like musical sentences, are clear and declarative. I tend to focus on the piece’s harmonic changes, the surprising chord and key changes, the extraordinary moments. I reflect on the character of the music, what feeling it evokes and then ponder how it does this. Or doesn’t.

Advertise with us

When the Chamber Orchestra of Pittsburgh began its recent all-Beethoven concert with that tune, it wasn’t quite in sync. This gave the piece a timid, hesitant feel that clashed with the pomp and circumstance of the music at Rodef Shalom Congregation in Shadyside. The orchestra soon locked in and course corrected.

Then, when soloist Awadagin Pratt entered, the piano seemed to sing under his fingers. His playing was arresting, with finessed passagework, quick dynamic changes from loud to soft and accents in places that caught my ear by surprise, a delightful sensation.

A chamber orchestra is simply a smaller symphonic orchestra — about 30 players compared to the Pittsburgh Symphony’s 90 or so. Pratt, a Pittsburgh native and sought-after pianist and conductor currently teaching at the University of Cincinnati, conducted the orchestra from his seat, giving the concert a more intimate vibe that one finds in Heinz Hall.

Back to the music: Pratt’s enthusiasm and aplomb and spontaneity carried a Beethoven work that perhaps lacks the melodic inspiration of his later works. Making the straightforwardness of some of the earlier works pop takes whimsy, and Pratt was more than up to the task. In the last movement especially, he tucked in with voracity, playing with the timing just enough to make each repetition of the opening tune unique. One couldn’t help but smile.

The orchestra was not as successful, muddying many of its entrances and dulling the concerto’s effect. Pratt’s conducting from the piano bench might have contributed to this. In the second half of the concert, Beethoven’s “Coriolan” Overture and Symphony No. 8, the players were noticeably more together under Pratt’s baton.

Advertise with us

The eighth symphony showcased the ensemble’s strengths and weaknesses best. Strings were excellent throughout, and the ensemble showed flickers of inspiration under Pratt’s direction, particularly in the faster movements, which zipped along with energy. But there was some weak playing in the winds and brass, and the slower-paced material meandered. Music is about more than just about hitting the right notes at the right time. It’s tricky to listen for character when these fundamentals aren’t clean.

Overall, the ensemble captured the joy of the music well.

The Chamber Orchestra of Pittsburgh’s next concert is a program of tango music on March 5-6.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.