In a 2012 interview with Classic Rock Magazine, Geddy Lee talks about seeing “a strange double bill” in April 1973 at Massey Hall in Toronto.

It was Genesis opening for Lou Reed. The Rush frontman, at 19, was so blown away by the opener, he left partway through the Velvet Underground legend’s set.

What was an upstart British prog band doing with an NYC proto-punk icon?

Good question.

Advertise with us

Rich Engler knows the answer, because that same bill happened one other time, in Pittsburgh — Swissvale, to be more exact — four days later, on April 13.

Engler, later of DiCesare-Engler Productions, had just started promoting concerts in 1969, and as soon as he heard that Reed was going out with “Transformer,” he says, “I was all over it.” He booked the Alpine Ice Arena and looked to pair Reed with an opening act before tickets went on sale.

“I didn't think I needed much,” Engler says, “because I thought Lou would sell out. The agent said, ‘I want to put Genesis on there.’ They shared an agent. I go, ‘Well, I don't know much about ‘em.’ He goes, ‘Well, nobody does. They're really different and good. You're going to like it.’ ”

Genesis, formed in Godalming, Surrey, in 1967, debuted in ’69 with “From Genesis to Revelation,” an album bearing a strong flavor of The Moody Blues. Over the next few years — with the release of “Trespass,” “Nursery Cryme” and “Foxtrot” — they began to chart their own path as a far-out, genre-bending progressive-rock band.

“Nursery Cryme,” with its graphic croquet cover, had opened with the bizarre, 10-minute fairy tale “The Musical Box,” and side two of new album “Foxtrot” was a 23-minute epic fantasy called “Supper’s Ready.” Despite building a cult following in Europe with these musical flights, none of the albums made much of a dent in the States. But Genesis was coming here to make its introductions nonetheless.

Advertise with us

“Foxtrot” coincided with frontman Peter Gabriel beginning to experiment with stagecraft, starting in September 1972 in a Dublin stadium, where — inspired by Ziggy Stardust and other glammy things — he surprised the band by exiting the stage during "The Musical Box" and reappearing in rather shocking attire.

"It was to copy the painting on the cover of our new album, Foxtrot, with a fox in a red dress," he would tell Mark Blake. "I had already bought a fox's head, and then I nicked a red dress from my wife's wardrobe. … There was real shock when I walked onstage. But also from the band, because I didn't tell them I was doing it. But it got us on the front of the Melody Maker."

The costume phase would only escalate from there.

Peter Gabriel, of Genesis, at the Alpine Ice Arena in 1973. (courtesy of Rich Engler)

“They show up at the Alpine Ice Arena, and I go to get them on stage,” Engler says, “and Peter Gabriel has this big daisy flower on his head. It was quite remarkable.

“The audience didn't know what to expect at first because they thought it was a joke. Once they started it was like, ‘Wow, this is serious.’ ”

Advertise with us

One of the impressionable teenagers there was Steve Sciulli, who would go on to become, and remains, one of Pittsburgh’s most adventurous musicians, first in Carsickness and then in Ploughman’s Lunch, Life in Balance, Standing Wave, etc.

“Back then,” he says, “I would just go to see anything in concert, for like $2. I remember to this day — I still get goosebumps thinking about it — the lights were down, and in the total blackness, you can see two dots on the stage under the black lights, and as the mellotron was kicking in and the drums and bass were creating this pulsating rhythm, the lights were rising and you noticed that it was Gabriel's eyes that were glowing.”

With unique precision, Genesis was navigating the heavy pieces from those albums — “"Watcher of the Skies,” "The Musical Box," "Supper's Ready,” "The Return of the Giant Hogweed" and "The Knife” — Gabriel being the only man standing, literally. It was unthinkable, given the Beatles/Stones model of the British rock band.

“I remember being really impressed that the guitar players all sat down,” Sciulli says, “because back then it was all about big hair and showmanship — the guitar players, figuratively, standing on top of the mountain with the wind in their hair. And so here you got these guys that look like they were buddies of mine over at Central Catholic, who would be in study hall, as opposed to on a rock ’n’ roll stage. In a way, it was kind of punk nerd-ish, because if they could do it, anyone could do it.”

Sort of, given the music’s intricacies, abrupt time-signature and mind-blowing genre shifts ranging from classical touches to renaissance folk to majestic metal.

Advertise with us

“It was hard to go back home to my little Bloomfield world after that, where my buddies would be sitting around arguing about which Led Zeppelin or Black Sabbath song they loved,” Sciulli says. “I’d seen another world.”

Secret society

That night, Genesis, which performs at PPG Paints Arena on Dec. 13, would become one of Engler’s favorite bands, which would account, in part, for them being such frequent visitors. Genesis rarely, if ever, missed a tour stop in Pittsburgh.

Before playing another ice rink in Pittsburgh — the Civic Arena — Genesis did three theater shows at the Syria Mosque, two of them in 1974, supporting “Selling England by the Pound” (May) and “Lamb Lies Down on Broadway” (November).

Between the Alpine show and radio play from free-form station WYDD, Genesis nurtured its own little cult following here — a “secret society,” as Sciulli calls it.

Advertise with us

“If you saw someone carrying a Genesis record, you would immediately go up and start talking to them and would become close friends. When Genesis came into town, it was a moment for people to dress up, put on face paint, wear their top hats and big-lapel jackets — similar to going to see Bowie at that time. People would kind of make fun of us, because we were listening to a band who is singing about gardens in the moonlight and, uh, harlequins.”

The May show was the first for Steve Acri, a Pittsburgh music fan and former record-store manager who has documented his concert experiences in exquisite detail.

“I had never seen a band integrate theatrics with the music before,” he says, “and although I read about Gabriel's costumes, nothing could have prepared me for the flower, batwing, or glowing headpieces. I was absolutely blown away.

“So when they returned on Nov. 30 of that same year, I expected more of the same. Wrong! ‘The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway’ took their performance to a whole other level, starting with the ‘libretto’ — inside text from the LP gatefold — that was left on each seat at the mosque where we were able to learn a little about Rael. Mind you, the album had not yet been out for more than two weeks, although WYDD was playing several tracks.”

In staging the rock opera, Genesis was equipped with three backdrop screens and eight projectors displaying nearly 1,500 slides, lasers and costumes ranging from Gabriel as the punk Rael in a black leather jacket and jeans to the grotesque and profane Slippermen suit, which the rest of the band hated. Phil Collins would refer to the tour as “inspiration for Spinal Tap.”

Advertise with us

Unbeknownst to the crowd, just a few days before the November Mosque show, Gabriel had informed the band in Cleveland that he was leaving Genesis after the conclusion of the tour, which ran through May 1975.

The public was alerted in August 1975 via a letter from Gabriel to Melody Maker titled “Out, Angels Out,” in which he noted, “I believe the use of sound and visual images can be developed to do much more than we have done. But on a large scale, it needs one clear and coherent direction, which our pseudo-democratic committee system could not provide. … As an artist, I need to absorb a wide variety of experiences.”

Next man up

How do you replace a singer like Peter Gabriel, with such a rare blend of beauty and roughness to his voice and such a commanding presence on stage?

The drummer?

Advertise with us

“Tony Smith, their manager, told me, ‘It looks like Peter may be leaving. How do you feel about that?’ ” Engler says. “I go, ‘Who's gonna sing?’ and he goes. ‘Phil.’ I said, ‘Wow.’ I didn't have much of a response because I was flabbergasted.”

To that point, Collins, a former child actor who had joined Genesis for its third album, had sung on a handful of that band’s songs, including “For Absent Friends” and “Counting Out Time.” No one was prepared for him to sound so much like Gabriel or for the band to continue to be so dynamic on “A Trick of the Tail,” which was released in February 1976.

When Genesis returned to the Syria Mosque that April, the fans came back, too, in part because the band had enlisted Bill Bruford from King Crimson to play drums. (The show was recorded and aired on WDVE, where you could hear Collins say, ‘Good evening … Baltimore.”)

“We all wanted to be supportive,” Sciulli says. “We all wanted it to continue. And I remember Phil Collins had a far more of a sense of humor than Gabriel could ever have on stage. So, that kind of saved it. It was more accessible, obviously.”

And how.

Advertise with us

In fact, everybody lived happily ever after.

Gabriel got to weird out in a dark, introspective manner on his early solo albums and then top the charts with hits like “Sledgehammer” and “In Your Eyes,” along with pursuing his humanitarian efforts.

With the success of “Wind and Wuthering” — led by “Your Own Special Way,” the band’s first Top 100 single in the U.S. (No. 62) — Genesis made its jump to the Civic Arena in 1977. It was the last time Pittsburghers would see Genesis with guitarist Steve Hackett, ushering the “And Then There Were Three” era of Collins, Mike Rutherford, Tony Banks that, over the next few albums, shed the prog on such pop-rock singles as “Follow You Follow Me,” “Misunderstanding,” “No Reply At All” and “Illegal Alien.”

As a new generation of fans poured in, some of the originals were out, like Gabriel.

“I saw Genesis for the last time on the “And Then There Were Three’ tour stop on July 23, 1978, and was bored silly,” Acri says. “That's where they lost me.”

Advertise with us

Simultaneously, Collins was having even bigger success as a solo artist with everything from the thunderous “In the Air Tonight” to the pop/R&B of “You Can’t Hurry Love” and “Easy Lover” (with Philip Bailey). Collins was so ubiquitous he even took a Concorde to play both sides of the Atlantic during the Live Aid in 1985.

“I was always happy doing 12,000 to 15,000 with them at the arena,” Engler says, “but then I got a call from their agent, who said, ‘Rich, what do you think of taking them to Three Rivers Stadium?’ I said, ‘Wow, that's a real big jump. They don't even have the product out yet.’ He said, ‘I'll tell you what. I'm going to send you the new single.’ So, he sent it to me, and it was ‘Tonight, Tonight, Tonight.’ Whoa, I was beyond blown away. I said, ‘You’re on. What date?’ ”

By the time tickets went on sale, the single was peaking, setting the stage for a packed stadium show in May 1987 on the “The Invisible Touch” Tour, a feat they would repeat in May 1992 with “We Can’t Dance.”

The closest they came to a reunion of the early ‘70s band was in 2006 when they talked about touring “Lamb” again. In the end, Gabriel bailed, leaving the three to reunite for the first time in 14 years for the 2007 Turn it On Again Tour.

That was to be the end of Genesis, as Collins wrote in his 2016 biography “Not Dead Yet.” Since that tour, he has been unable to play drums because of vertebrae and nerve ailments. For his solo tour, which stopped at PPG Paints Arena in 2019, he took the stage with a cane and sang in a chair, while his teenage son Nic played drums.

Advertise with us

They do the same now on The Last Domino? Tour, which finds them with Banks, Rutherford and longtime guitarist Daryl Stuermer playing a 23-song set that reaches all the way back to the early ’70s.

Sciulli doesn’t plan to go but loves that Genesis lives on.

“It's beautiful, because we look at these guys as being legendary and now we see how feeble they are, and yet they’re still eternal,” Sciulli says. “And they're still role models for people who grew up with them to show, look, you can still be functional, you can still be legendary and you can still mean the world to people.

“I'm happy to be living in a modern golden age of music, but also that the past golden age of music is still here. It’s almost like a transparency over everything that's happening now. It's wonderful to have been able to see Genesis back in 1973 and know that they're still out there.”

The concert is at 8 p.m. Dec. 13. Tickets are $75; ticketmaster.com.

Advertise with us

____________

Genesis in Pittsburgh

April 13, 1973: Foxtrot Tour, Alpine Ice Arena

May 3, 1974: Selling England by the Pound Tour, Syria Mosque

Nov. 30, 1974: Lamb Lies Down on Broadway Tour, Syria Mosque

Advertise with us

April 13, 1976: A Trick of the Tail Tour, Syria Mosque

March 10, 1977: Wind and Wuthering Tour, Civic Arena

July 22, 1978: And Then There Were Three Tour, Civic Arena

June 13, 1980: Duke Tour, Stanley Theatre

Nov. 19, 1981: Abacab Tour, Civic Arena

Advertise with us

Dec. 7, 1983: Mama Tour, Civic Arena

May 24, 1987: Invisible Touch Tour, Three Rivers Stadium

May 26, 1992: We Can’t Dance Tour, Three Rivers Stadium

Sept. 9, 2007: Turn it On Again, Mellon Arena

Dec. 13, 2021: The Last Domino? Tour, PPG Paints Arena