What’s the difference between in and out of tune?

In most Western music, harmonies are built using just 12 notes that vibrate sympathetically, but this is somewhat arbitrary. There’s no real limit to the number of possible tuning systems. Performers at Pittsburgh’s third Beyond 2020 Microtonal Music Festival showcased numerous systems over the course of the festival, with scales featuring 16 notes, 24 notes, 72 notes — pick a number.

What do these different systems sound like? When performed well, they sounded uncanny and haunting at times, poignant and spicy at others. When performed badly, it just sounded flat out of tune, or worse, like indiscriminate, random noise. The fest featured both in a weekend that was sublime in its best moments, but frustrating for its grab-bag of programming.

(A quick note: Noise can be effective in creating evocative, emotional musical compositions. I’m not impugning all noise music.)

Advertise with us

The term microtonal means that the music uses pitches that aren’t confined to the regular 12 notes of a Western scale. Many other cultures have done this for centuries and contemporary music often bends notes to add zest. So the term microtonal doesn’t denote a genre so much as a technique. Also, other cultures wouldn’t think of their music as microtonal; that’s our own cultural filters coming into play. Festival directors are aware of this, but it’s still the easiest term to identify this sort of music.

The festival ran from Friday to Sunday at the New Hazlett Theater, the Andy Warhol Museum and the Frick Fine Arts Auditorium and is co-produced by the new music series Music on the Edge at the University of Pittsburgh and the Andy Warhol Museum.

Highlights included the appearance of guitarist John Schneider, the Del Sol String Quartet and the MikroEnsemble from Finland. On Friday, Mr. Schneider, a microtonal institution based in Los Angeles, delivered a throbbing, melancholic set that blended spoken word with adjusted tuning systems in music by Lou Harrison, Harry Partch and Mr. Schneider.

The Del Sol quartet’s performance of Ben Johnston’s String Quartet on Sunday proved captivating, blending familiar classical forms with modified tuning that expanded the music’s expressive possibilities. The quartet, also based in Los Angeles, played with fire and clarity throughout their set. Composer Michael Harrison’s “Mureed” proved a captivating experience as well.

Other performers — the Ray-Kallay piano duo, the FretX guitar duo and the Brightwork ensemble and numerous local musicians — delivered a more mixed bag. There were gems, like Brightwork’s performance of festival co-director Mathew Rosenblum’s “Falling,” which musically imagines the thoughts of a flight attendant as she falls to her death, or the MikroEnsemble’s performance of the folk-infused “Microdancetudes” by member and accordionist Veli Kujala. Unfortunately, however, moments such as these were the exception rather than the rule overall.

Advertise with us

Many of the compositions, a mix of late 20th-century and more recent music, sounded like a lurching, hyper-intellectual exploration of the possibilities of different pitch systems, juxtaposing unfamiliar sound frequencies together to see what the harmonic effects might be. This was often neither pleasant nor particularly interesting after the first few minutes of drones or fragmentary gestures. I’d have favored far shorter programs of different highlights from microtonal repertoire rather than an exhaustive dive.

At the Saturday marathon concert at the Frick, there were some excellent performances by Pittsburgh freelance musicians (quick shoutout to WOLFTRAP for the excellent concert closer “I will tear them out”), but technical issues and logistic problems undermined the experience. This year’s festival also paired works by Pittsburgh visual artists with a few of the musical selections. Much of this felt mismatched or experimentally tacked on and unnecessary.

More selective curation would have benefited the festival, which seemed geared toward a small subset of Pittsburghers already interested in unusual music.  Given the foundation funding the Microtonal Festival receives, I’d like to see a more listener-friendly iteration in the future, as I spoke with several attendees who said they found the music impenetrable. This is a wonderfully rich musical niche, but a more guided tour would be far more rewarding to those who haven’t already drunk the Kool-Aid.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.