Is Beethoven the best tonic for someone struggling with illness, grief or isolation? Monique Mead thinks so. For just $100, you can personally sponsor her performance of Beethoven’s Violin Concerto for a friend or loved one.
Ms. Mead, the director of music entrepreneurship studies at Carnegie Mellon University, kicked off a project she’s calls Beethoven in the Face of Adversity in March. She aimed to perform the violin concerto 50 times in 250 days. On Monday, she concluded her 50-concert tour with a free performance at Carnegie Music Hall in Oakland with the volunteer Edgewood Symphony Orchestra.
The concerto can be performed with a full orchestra or just piano accompaniment, and she’s visited hospitals, mental health facilities, senior care centers, refugee centers and individuals to gift performances. While Monday’s performance was intended to cap the project, an enthusiastic response and growing waiting list of requests has indicated a need for more.
While Beethoven was working on the concerto, he realized he was losing his hearing. Yet it’s a work of overwhelming positivity, particularly the tender second movement and the jocular finale.
On Monday, Ms. Mead and the orchestra delivered a stalwart performance, a sense of optimism complementing the ethos of the evening. With community-focused concerts such as this, it’s less about being note-perfect than allowing listeners to understand and appreciate the thinking behind the performance.
The music takes on its own meaning and when framed as a balm to help overcome adversity, becomes a personal, musical message of good will. Echoing that idea, some of the beneficiaries of Ms. Mead’s playing were quoted in posters set up in the concert hall lobby. I would have loved to hear from some of them at the concert.
The concert finished with the Bruderhof Community Choir singing another Beethoven favorite, “Ode to Joy” from the Symphony No. 9, before a traditional mariachi band (Mariachi Internacional de Pittsburgh) led audiences to celebratory cupcakes with a traditional Mexican birthday tune.
Chamber Orchestra Pittsburgh
The Chamber Orchestra of Pittsburgh, now in its third season, delivered a lackluster performance on Friday at First Unitarian Church in Shadyside. Conductor Edward Leonard led the strings-only ensemble in an eclectic program of Boccherini, Grieg, Bartok, Samuel Coleridge-Taylor and Jennifer Higdon.
Each work on the program was compelling in its own right, but didn’t seem to fit together. Ms. Higdon’s “Soliloquy for Cello and Strings” has a sultry, languorous feel, while Boccherini’s Cello Concerto in B-flat is a pluckier, more straight-ahead tune. Contrast in programming can be effective, but I couldn’t discern the connection.
The soloist, Kathleen Melucci, principal cello of the orchestra as well as the Pittsburgh Opera orchestra, gave a spirited performance that was sometimes out of tune. Ms. Melucci didn’t sound confident in her entrances in the “Soliloquy.”
The second half of the concert was stronger, particularly Grieg’s “Holberg Suite,” which evidenced more creative, nuanced phrasing. And Bartok’s “Romanian Folk Dances” allowed for excellent solos from concertmaster Anne Moskal.
I’ve heard this ensemble give strong concerts, but Friday’s did not stack up. Perhaps a shorter program would ensure a higher standard. In fact, I’d encourage smaller ensembles to consider programming shorter, as many of the programs I’ve heard this season have sounded bloated and underrehearsed. I’m absolutely certain they are capable of stronger playing.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.