How important is music for a sense of national identity? Ask the protestors in Hong Kong, who in August adopted an unofficial and hummable “protest anthem” to create a sense of identity and solidarity for the movement.
Historically, national anthems became popular in the 19th century, often based on patriotic songs, marches or fanfares of hymns or in the case of the “Star Spangled Banner,” a drinking tune. They are generally musical eulogies to their respective countries, epitomizing a shared history and struggle and a fear of losing identity.
In 2016, Pulitzer Prize-winning composer David Lang wrote a sort of international meta anthem, a work for chorus and string quartet work born of intensive studies of the national anthems of the world’s different countries. He wrote about the project on his website: “I didn’t want to make a piece that was aggressive, or angry, or ironic. … Maybe an anthem is a memory informing a kind of prayer, a heartfelt plea: There was a time when we were forced to live in chains. Please don’t make us live in chains again.”
On Saturday, Resonance Works, a small, versatile Pittsburgh performance company presented Mr. Lang’s work alongside other music for choir and string quartet written by composers of a range of nationalities at Heinz Memorial Chapel in Oakland. A tour of the Nationality Rooms at the University of Pittsburgh’s Cathedral of Learning preceded the concert.
The performance was evidence of a consistent issue for some of the city’s smaller organizations: A strong concept, somewhat lacking in its execution. Mr. Lang’s music is fragmentary, little snippets of ascending vocal melody balanced against sustained tones in other voices or strings. The effect is meditative, more prayer-like than a rallying cry. But there’s still plenty of room for nuance.
Resonance Works founder and conductor Maria Sensi Sellner directed the performance, which came off cold and homogenous. Perhaps the echoing acoustics of the chapel contributed to this effect, but there was little contrast in the phrases, and the pacing and energy level remained flat throughout.
This was belied later in the performance during “Bogoroditse Djevo” by Estonian composer Arvo Part, a bright, sparkling affair that showed the dynamic range of the ensemble to better effect. And soprano soloist Charlene Canty distinguished herself with a warm, clarion tone.
The works for string quartet alone “Musica de Feria” by Silvestre Revueltas, “Groung” by Mary Kouyoumdjian and “Negro Folk Songs in Counterpoint” by Florence Price, were unintelligible in the chapel’s acoustics. The concert opener for harp and flute, “Tocar,” by Kaija Saariaho, suffered the same fate.
The choir wasn’t quite in sync in Vivian Fung’s “Kecak Attack!,” a spirited tune with lots of hard consonants based on an Indonesian monkey dance, but this was an isolated issue — the ensemble was generally tight and together throughout. Still, a lack of nuance and detail caused many of the pieces to blur into each other, unfortunate considering their disparate origins.
Perhaps a shorter second half would have eased this effect, or possibly a drier hall would have allowed more of the musicians’ passion and subtlety to shade the performance. But these variables are controllable and shouldn’t interfere with what was otherwise a creative, interesting program.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.