Wagner’s “Ride of the Valkyries” is one of those bits of classical music that has completely permeated pop culture, but the complete opera, “The Valkyrie,” is fully worth exploration. It’s a tale of epic heroism and clashing immortals wrapped in a glorious musical score and seasoned with a truly icky bit of incest between twins.

(You can thank HBO’s “Game of Thrones” for bringing that idea into the public consciousness lately, too.)

This summer, Pittsburgh Festival Opera has staged “Valkyrie” at the Winchester Thurston School. This version of the opera, directed by the company’s artistic director, Jonathan Eaton, uses an English translation by Andrew Porter and has been trimmed down to about three hours and calls for only about a 40-piece orchestra thanks to an ingenious arrangement by Jonathan Dove. Scene and costume design by Danila Korogodsky evoked a primitive, crueler time for humanity.

The production is unbalanced and puts all of its eggs into a single basket: namely, the singers.

Advertise with us

And, indeed, the vocal talent is first-rate. On Sunday, Elisabeth Rosenberg as Sieglinde conjured a feeling of violent desperation thanks to impressive dynamic and emotive range. William Joyner as Siegmund proved similarly forceful, filling the intimate hall and giving a larger-than-life feel to the performance. Melanie Henley Heyn as Brunnhilde was the dramatic standout, with surpassing presence and delivery. Bass Andrew Potter as Hunding and bass-baritone Jeremy Galyon each seemed to deliver with gusto their rumbling, earth-shaking lines, although Galyon could have perhaps been a touch more lyrical and connected. The remainder of the cast, including Leah Heater as Fricka and the chorus of Valkyries, was simply excellent.

But, alas, the orchestra. Directed by Walter Morales, the ensemble was consistently quite out of tune. Note beginnings and endings were often imprecise, and balances were wildly inconsistent, with the brass occasionally blaring over even the singers. This is a hideously difficult score, true, and likely even more difficult given the reduction in instruments. (The original opera orchestration calls for more than double that number.) But the orchestra proved distractingly problematic throughout the performance.

The stage direction was also a misfire, particularly the famous “Ride of the Valkyries” scene, with its chorus of heroic warrior women spinning and clacking spears gawkily. In this production, Wagner’s “Ring Cycle” is an epic saga, and allowing the vocal and orchestral phrases to breathe without cluttering them with unnecessary movement would have better suited the minimalist sets. And as it was, the small stage didn’t allow for full, energetic motion and caused much of the steps and twirls to feel careful and awkward, with the exception of an excellent fight scene between Siegmund and Hunding choreographed by Randy Kovitz. Otherwise, emotional and dramatic high points were punctured by cumbersome gestures.

For information about the remainder of Pittsburgh Festival Opera’s season visit pittsburghfestivalopera.org.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.