Before he went on to play Tarzan, Judas, Tony and Donkey — the latter from “West Side Story” and “Shrek” — David Toole had the role of lead singer in the Pittsburgh alt-rock band Identity X.

It formed in 2003 while Toole and guitarist Darin DiNapoli were attending Robert Morris University and debuted in 2009 with an album, “Perception Is Reality,” that promised a “new genre of music” — one very much aligned with the previous work of explosive grunge/metal bands like Incubus and Funeral for a Friend.

In the wake of that release, Identity X did regular gigs, created IDXFest and got played on The X, but didn’t get around to the follow-up album.

“The typical local band stuff: lineup changes and guys moving away and starting families and getting jobs and having a life,” Toole says.

Advertise with us

IDENTITY X

With: Horus Maze, Color Me Blind and HOA.

Where: Jergel’s, Marshall.

When: 7 p.m. Sunday

Tickets: $10-$15; ticketfly.com.

Advertise with us

For the singer, that included a life in the theater, starring in more than a dozen Pittsburgh Musical Theater productions, most recently “Newsies” and “We Will Rock You,” and working out of town as well. Last year, he won best actor in a musical in the BroadwayWorld Raleigh Awards for playing the Glen Hansard character in “Once” at Theatre Raleigh.

Along with doing voice lessons, he had enough work onstage to quit his day job in 2016. With all that happening, Identity X took a backseat, but this week it returns in loud fashion with that long-awaited second album, “Wounds of Our History.”

Fans of his work in PMT productions just dropping in might be a little surprised by the aggressive metalcore approach and impressed by Toole’s menacing vocals and ear-piercing, octave-leaping range.

“I’m able to transition a lot of that vocal range and theatricality of the vocals of musical theater to the way we write our music now,” he says. “When I first started doing the musical theater stuff, it moved from the direction of the band to the stage, where I was bringing that rock style and a little bit edgier vocals, taking vocal liberties with octave changes and riffs that you wouldn't normally do in musical theater.

“Working with musical theater and working with voice coaches — some really talented music directors — I’ve kind of honed a better understanding of just the clarity of the voice and the importance of punching certain words, using the voice to drive those moments a little harder.”

Advertise with us

One of the more impassioned vocals comes on “Lifetime Frozen,” a song with particular meaning for Toole and DiNapoli. It’s about the 2012 murder of East McKeesport armored car driver Michael Haines by his partner, who ran off with $2 million before he was captured.

“Mike was a close friend of ours and actually helped name the band,” Toole says. “He was Darin’s roommate in college, just a great dude. Whenever he got killed that was one of the biggest blows I’ve ever experienced. Hearing that news, that thought popped up in my head, ‘I feel like my lifetime is frozen and all I can think about it this one thing.’ And it ties into his life. His whole lifetime was frozen, in that one moment, in this selfish act. Trying to deal with that loss, writing a song about it, was important. It gave Darin and I a chance to channel our grief in a positive way and in a way that Mike would have appreciated.”

The album was recorded in Long Island, N.Y., with producer/drummer James Miller, whom they met more than a decade ago when his former band Blameshift did its first out-of-town show with Identity X in Pittsburgh.

Identity X rolls the album out with a lineup that also includes bassist Roman Prokopenko, drummer David Ardale and guitarist Albert Park. They promise that some videos are coming from the DiNapoli’s studio, DNAPPS Productions.

Meanwhile, Toole is part of a new musical being workshopped for Broadway called “Clicquot: A Revolutionary Musical” (by Lisette Glodowski and Richard Walter), and he’ll play Emcee in the CLO production of “Once” in July.

Advertise with us

Has his theater work been frustrating for his longtime bandmate?

“He’s been super supportive of it, surprisingly,” Toole says, “because I kind of expected that, but he’s been starting this video production business. With the new album release we’re hoping to play a lot more often and keep that momentum going again.”

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.