The Victorian Era has a reputation for being stuffy, but tell that to notorious 19th century rapscallion Boy Jones, who at the age of 14 sneaked into Buckingham Palace, stole Queen Victoria’s underwear and was later caught with the bloomers stuffed down his trousers.

Legendary, in its own creepy way.

To mark Queen Victoria’s bicentennial (May 24, 2019), The Mendelssohn Choir of Pittsburgh presented a program May 18 and 19 titled “Victoria’s Secret: A Life in Music,” a program that explores the queen’s history and impact through music and historically informed narration. A few weeks ago, I commented that the concert would not be a lingerie show set to choir music, and a bevy of readers and friends suggested that they’d be more likely to attend if it actually had been such a show.

After Sunday’s concert in Westminster Presbyterian Church in Upper St. Clair, I can report that the concert needed no such support, even if Boy Jones is rolling in his unmarked Australian grave at the lack of Victorian undergarments.

Advertise with us

In a nod to the acclaimed British television series “Victoria,” the concert opened with the show’s “Coronation Theme” by Martin Phipps, a simple, noble tune with chilling solos by soprano Stephanie Sue Curtice. The rest of program largely featured music popular during the queen’s days, with contributions from Wagner, Mendelssohn, Prince Albert, Arthur Sullivan, Elgar and others.

Although the 140-member choir appeared cramped on the small church stage, its sound was not diminished. Music director Matthew Mehaffey coaxed warm, clean lines from one of Pittsburgh’s best musical ensembles, balancing his forces with an ear for lushness and clarity. Handel’s “Zadok the Priest” coronation anthem and Mendelssohn’s “And Then Shall Your Light Break Forth” from the oratorio “Elijah” were particular highlights, showcasing the ensemble’s dynamic and emotive range.

The small orchestra playing was lovely but often overpowered by either trumpet or choir. Works with solo voice, including Prince Albert’s own composition, “Trauerlied,” with bass E. Skip Napier, fared best in the church’s acoustics.

The script itself — narrated by Bradley Greenwald and Lisa Ann Goldsmith — could have benefited from more detailed historical context, as the program felt only loosely cobbled together in places. Inserting the Christmas tune “O Tannenbaum,” for example, would have carried more resonance if the script made clear that Prince Albert brought the tune with him to England. (Perhaps this was included and I didn’t hear it?) This information could also have been presented in the program notes, if the goal was to keep the narration more character-driven.

A brief mention of the Irish Famine, a consistent source of historical critique against the queen, felt rushed, although the Irish folk song “Revenge for Skibbereen” with soprano Amelia Baisley D’Arcy was another standout moment. The concert closed with Elgar’s rousing arrangement of “God Save the Queen.”

Advertise with us

The Mendelssohn Choir of Pittsburgh is primarily known for its collaborations with the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, but under the helm of music director Matthew Mehaffey, it has been striking out on its own in interesting ways that explore history with a musical lens. Last year, the choir performed an oratorio of Bob Dylan music; earlier this year, it presented a program titled “Let My People Go: A Spiritual Journey Along the Underground Railroad” in the historic Ebenezer Baptist Church.

Stay tuned for future creativity.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.