The one comedy show I attended this year was Louis CK — don’t @ me, I was covering it — and CK being the great comic talent that he is, he had the Improv crowd in stitches.
Thursday night at Carnegie Lecture Hall in Oakland, Jeff Tweedy was funnier. And there was no two-drink minimum. Plus, he played songs.
The Wilco frontman, on tour supporting his new solo album, “Warm,” came out all scruffy-looking with a vintage Martin guitar doing quiet versions of the album’s opening tracks, “Bombs Above” and “Some Birds,” employing that comfy, aching, world-weary voice we’ve known and loved for 30-some years, dating back to Uncle Tupelo.
He stood in the pit of the Lecture Hall stage with the worst lighting I’ve ever seen at a concert: two white spots casting bad Tweedy shadows on the stark white wall behind him. They have better lighting at middle school talent shows, construction sites and interrogation rooms.

It was serious music in a serious setting — to the point of being unintentionally hilarious.
“Are you guys freaked out?” he said, breaking the ice. “This is the most I’ve ever been able to see people. It’s freaky. I don’t like it. You people are just sitting there like [makes a blank face]. I didn’t know what you were supposed to do, but I didn’t know this is what you did.
“We’re gonna get through this together,” he said, half-reassuringly.
At that point, everyone loosened up, almost too much, having been empowered to provide their input on the show and the setlist. He would later joke that when he encouraged us, “I realized right away I made a mistake.”
Jeff Tweedy solo. Finally 🙌🏻 @wilco #iamanamericanaquariumdrinker #Pittsburgh pic.twitter.com/nhubZiV5SF
— toby atticus fraley (@tobyfraley) April 5, 2019
For the most part, the fans left him alone during the songs, and they were rewarded with essential Tweedy. He’s great with the awesome force of Wilco behind him. You could argue he’s even better with the songs stripped naked to the way he wrote them, with just guitar and vocals, where you could savor nuance, every strange, surreal lyrical twist.
A song like “I Am Trying to Break Your Heart,” so commanding with Wilco’s tense atmospherics, was even more emotive in its raw form. Listening to “Remember the Mountain Bed,” taken from the Billy Bragg/Woody Guthrie “Mermaid Avenue” project, it was hard to not to think of early Dylan.
Every time he sort of opened the door for requests, it became hilarious. When someone shouted “Hate it Here,” he said it was “one of the hardest songs to play rhythmically by myself because of my stupid fingers,” but admitted, “It’s a lot harder to say no when I can see you.” Somewhere in there he joked about his concerns of people saying, “Can you play side two of ‘2112’? That’s what I imagine you guys wanna hear.”
“Hate it Here,” a little heartbreaker from Wilco’s “Sky Blue Sky,” turned out to be an inspired request, challenging Mr. Tweedy, who’s a good player but hardly a virtuoso, to fudge his way nicely through the song’s tempo changes and Nels Cline’s heavy riffing. Once again, minus the full rock treatment, he cut right to the heart of the song.
Same with “You and I,” which doesn’t quite reflect its sentimental title, proposing a little distance in a romance with “I don't need to know everything about you...and you don't need to know that much about me.”
When someone shouted that it was his wedding song, he shot back, “Oh yeah, what was your wife’s?”
Speaking of which, on “Guaranteed,” a jarringly blunt but pretty new song written for longtime spouse Sue Miller, he sang, “I’m a piece of work/And you’re no walk in the park.”
“Hummingbird” and “The Ruling Class” beautifully showcased one of his rarely heard talents. “I don’t think I’ve ever put the two whistling songs back to back before,” he said. “Let’s remember this night.” He added in jest, “You know who’s really bad at whistling? Andrew Bird.”
He continued to play on the awkwardness of the setting and his precarious situation therein, noting that most performers come out shouting, “How are you doing?! … I’m one of the only performers where people feel the need to tell ME I’m doing OK. … It’s the reverse David Lee Roth.” And it’s going to make “Tweedy on Broadway,” should that ever happen, a classic.
When he teased playing an Uncle Tupelo song, someone had the misfortune of shouting out “Passenger Side,” to the derision of the Lecture Hall mob. He got to “Passenger Side,” one of the better alt-country DUI songs (from the Wilco debut), but first he gave us a joyful “New Madrid” from UT’s classic swansong “Anodyne,” followed later by “Acuff Rose,” requiring his finest picking, on a western guitar.
(Note: I totally wanted to yell out a Jay Farrar song, but I don’t yell things at concerts — or anywhere else, for that matter — and I’m not really there to participate, right?)
“We’re getting close to the end,” he said, to a collective “Awww,” to which he snapped, “Or we could just end it now — that always worked with my kids.”
Before he exited, he delivered late-set gems including “Jesus, Etc.”; “Let’s Go Rain,” a playful new singalong with a funny reference to Scott McCaughey (of Young Fresh Fellows, Minus 5, Baseball Project fame); and the much-loved “California Stars.”
We had gotten small tastes of Tweedy solo, like when he did the Three Rivers Arts Festival in 2014 with the side band Tweedy and also during the last Wilco tour. Now we know how enjoyable the full two hours can be, bad lighting and all.
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.
JEFF TWEEDY SETLIST
Bombs Above
Some Birds
Remember the Mountain Bed
I Am Trying to Break Your Heart
I Know What It's Like
Cars Can’t Escape
Hate it Here
Family Ghost
You and I
Hummingbird
The Ruling Class
Guaranteed
Tell Me No lies
New Madrid
Evergreen
Jesus, Etc
Let’s Go Rain
Passenger Side
The Late Greats
Encore:
Having Been is No Way to Be
Don’t Forget
California Stars
Acuff Rose





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.