In a sense, “Aloha” can mean hello or goodbye in Hawaiian. For Nate Walker, it was the latter.
The West Mifflin singer — who had made an inspiring comeback to qualify for the “American Idol” solo showcase on the island of Oahu — was sent home on Sunday’s episode.
“It’s hurtful,” Mr. Walker said. “I had all this hope I was going to get a ‘yes.’ ”
It had been quite a ride for Mr. Walker. He was shown overcoming illness in last week’s episode, which was shot months ago. For this week’s performance, he sang The Commodores’ “Still” as twilight approached the beach at Disney’s resort in Ko Olina.
“American Idol” thrives on drama, which led to the interview portion with judges Katy Perry, Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. Mr Walker’s decision was featured a half-hour into the three-hour show.
And although all three were enthusiastic about his singing in early rounds, and gave him a second shot when sickness reduced Mr. Walker’s voice to a rasp, he was told it was the end of the line.
Read More
Mr. Walker, 19 and a 2018 graduate of West Mifflin Area High School, was attempting to embellish the local legacy of singers on the show. He is a longtime friend of “Idol” finalist Gabby Barrett, who sang with him in Mr. Walker’s church choir when they were younger.
He made a bold choice to sing “Still,” given it was Mr. Richie’s song back in the day: “It’s really risky, so I’m going to have to push myself.”
Although his voice was fine, the judges said they felt he didn’t connect with the concert crowd the previous night.
“There’s an audience of people dying to feel you, and you have to feel them,” Mr. Richie said. “We had to make a decision: did the crowd feel you? Or did you feel you? You won’t make our top 20. I love you, we love you.”
“You’re 19 and man, so much promise,” added Mr. Bryan. “Chin up.”
Mr. Walker said he understood but it was still difficult to process the results. “That was a dream of mine. Not only to get to the top 20, but to win.
Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or @MariaSciulloPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.