It doesn’t matter that they’re all past 70. A Crosby, Stills & Nash tour would be a huge hit right now and downright earth-shaking if they could lure in Neil Young.

But, to mix band metaphors, hell might have to freeze over (again) for that.

A cold war still lingers between David Crosby and his famed partners Graham Nash and Stephen Stills, who played their last show together on Dec. 3, 2015.

It’s been a volatile union, on and off, for decades, intensified the past several years with Mr. Crosby’s remark about occasional fourth member Mr. Young’s then-girlfriend, now-wife Daryl Hannah as a “predator” and by Mr. Nash’s revealing memoir, “Wild Tales: A Rock & Roll Life.”

Advertise with us

So, 2019 commences with another round of solo tours, starting with Mr. Nash in town on Friday and Mr. Crosby following in June — unfortunate given the magic they are able to produce even as a duo.

GRAHAM NASH

Where: Carnegie of Homestead Music Hall, Munhall.

When: 8 p.m. Friday, March 15.

Tickets: $36.75; ticketfly.com.

Advertise with us

Both have seen to it that it’s more than a greatest hits show. In 2016, Mr. Nash, working with former Bruce Springsteen sideman Shane Fontayne, released “This Path Tonight,” his first solo album in 14 years. He’ll be blending those songs in with the classics that appear on 2018’s “Over the Years,” a 15-song best-of collection with an additional 15 unearthed demos.

Earlier this month, the 77-year-old British singer-songwriter who is in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame as a member of both CSN and The Hollies talked to us to preview the show.

What was the experience like of putting together “Over the Years” and listening back to the material?

I realized there had never been one of those greatest hits albums of MY music. There had been greatest hits of The Hollies, greatest hits of CSN, greatest hits of CSNY, etc., but never my music, so when I found out the 15 songs that my fans seemed to really like of mine, I thought they probably bought all this music in several formats over the years, from cassettes to CDs to DVDS, etc., and so how can I make the album a little more interesting? So, I went into my archive and chose 15 demos that I did in those early years, and it seems to be quite popular with people. They are an insight into the creative process of songwriting.

When you listen back to your hits are you generally happy with the way they were recorded, or do you think about changes?

Advertise with us

No, there’s a point at which you have to let go. You can’t go into everyone’s house and fix the album. You just have to let it go, and of course, there are things that I would change, but it’s out there and God bless it.

“Marrakesh Express” was kind of a turning point, right? It was supposed to be a Hollies song. What was the story behind that?

I had written a song years ago called “King Midas in Reverse,” and although it was a strange song, I thought we made a good record of it, but it only got into the Top 30. And The Hollies were used to getting into the Top 5, of course. It was after that I sensed that they didn’t trust my musical push, my direction. So, I made a demo of “Marrakesh Express,” and they actually tried to record it. There’s a track of it in the bowels of EMI at Abbey Road of The Hollies doing “Marrakesh,” but to me it needed the energy of a train in there, which is what Stephen did so brilliantly with his overdubbed guitars on the actual record. But, yeah, they just weren’t interested really.

How did your writing change just by being around David and Stephen? Was it a more hospitable environment for you?

It was. In late ’64, early ’65, The Hollies had done a song called “Too Many People” about the population explosion. So, I was starting to get into writing more serious words, and when I came to join David and Stephen, and living with Joni [Mitchell], of course, and Neil, I began to realize if I could take what I learned in The Hollies, which was to be able to write a melody that maybe you couldn’t forget if you heard it a couple times, if I was to put better words to them, then I would have better songs. And my songwriting changed when I came to America. David and Stephen and Neil and Joni were writing about reality, were writing about real issues that faced humanity, and I wanted to be a part of that, and so my songwriting changed dramatically.

Advertise with us

“Immigration Man.” What were the circumstances of writing that and how is that song hitting people now?

I’m an immigrant. Let’s face it. I’m the English one in the band, so I’m an immigrant, and I realized the power of new thinking, new brains, new energy into this country. This country was founded basically on immigrants, and they built this entire country, practically. What happened was CSNY had done a show in Vancouver, British Columbia, in the early ’70s, and they let Crosby in and they let Stephen in and they let Neil back into the country, but not me, because something was wrong with my visa. And so this guy at immigration gave me a couple hours of run-around. It was very … I mean, I don’t like to be left out, of anything, and to see David and Stephen on the other side of this imaginary line, laughing at me, was not pleasant. By the time I got off the plane to my home in San Francisco, I’d already written 90 percent of “Immigration Man.”

Does it take on new meaning now when you play it live?

No, it’s the same damn meaning. Unfortunately, it’s still incredibly relevant even today, and so is “Chicago” — “we can change the world” — and so is “Military Madness.” I mean, I wrote those songs 50 years ago. We don’t seem to have learned much, did we?

You had gone more than a decade without a solo album before doing “This Path Tonight.” What made those songs come out of you when they did?

Advertise with us

It was actually about 14 years. In that 14 years, I made 16 CDs. I did the CSNY stadium tour four-CD boxed set. I did my boxed set, I did Crosby’s boxed set. I did the demos record of CSN. I was a busy boy, but then my life changed dramatically when I divorced my wife after 38 years and moved to New York. And those emotional changes are the basis of what “Myself at Last” is.

There’s a line where you say you feel like you have to “fight the past.” What did you mean?

I meant that I’m not just part of CSN. I’m not just a part of CSNY. I’m not just a part of The Hollies. I am Graham Nash, an individual, and that’s what I meant by that.

David said in January that he would love to get the four of you back together …

I’m sure he would.

Advertise with us

Is there any discussion?

No, there’s none at all, and there won’t be. And the truth is, none of us are speaking to David. Not me, not Stephen, not Neil. And that’s the way it is. We have to like and love each other to be able to make great music. And I understand the financial implications. I understand the need for CSNY to raise their voices, particularly in this political climate today, but we have to like each other. And we don’t want to do it if we don’t like each other.

People think, “They’re mature men, they’re in their 70s, and by now you’d think things would mellow out.”

One would think. It is crazy, though. We made it through Nixon. And we made it through Bush. But this Trump guy is something else.

There really isn’t that much political music right now that’s risen to the surface.

Advertise with us

The people who own the world’s media you could count on two hands, and the last thing they want on their radio and their television and their magazines is people bitching about what’s really going on. They just want sheep. They just want people to lay down and shut the [expletive] up while we rob you. And that’s what is going on in this world. If you go to somewhere like Neil Young’s “Living With War” website, you’ll find about 3,000 protest songs on there, but the people who control the media don’t want them on the radio.

So, you don’t think “Ohio” would happen today?

It depends. It depends if it was a hit record. If it was a hit record and distributed mainly it would be great, but it would have to be a hit. “Ohio” is a great record regardless of what it’s about. Musically, it’s a fantastic record, and what it says, of course, is most important.

What was it like for you to be part of the 75th birthday tribute to Joni Mitchell in November?

It was a fabulous couple of nights. You know, I’ve been in constant contact with Joni, and, quite frankly, we’re very grateful that she is alive and that her brain is back and she’s learning to walk again and all those basic things after being found unconscious on her kitchen floor for two or three days before anybody found her. But the night was beautiful. There was a lot of love and honor to Joan. I sang the only song that night that was not written by Joan. I did “Our House,” which, of course, I wrote about Joni. And it was really lovely to see her, and I asked her, “Any ideas coming for songs or paintings?” And she looked at me and said, “No, not yet.” Not “yet,” and I took that as great encouragement.

Advertise with us

We’re at the 50th anniversary of Woodstock, and it’s amazing to me that that culture is still important to people …

Woodstock was a very interesting experience. It was the beginning and the end of things. It was the end of people getting together in a garage and trying to make music. As soon as the powers that be that sell you Coca Colas and Nike sneakers realized, “Wait, 300-, 400,000 kids, we can sell them anything?” That was the beginning of corporate intrusion into music. But we did the 25th anniversary, and that seemed like a long time ago, and now it’s 50 years, yikes. There were other attempts to re-create it, and they tried to sell water to people for $12 a bottle. It just became too much. And I’ve been invited to play the 50th, but I’m not inclined to do it.

Are you hopeful about the future politically?

I am. I am. I question whether we’re putting too much faith in [Robert] Mueller, but when you look at everyone around Trump and all the people that have pled guilty and were sentenced, there’s no way it can’t go all the way to the top, and once his taxes are made available, I believe that entire house of cards is going to come tumbling down.

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com. 

Correction, posted March 11, 2019: In an earlier version of this story, the date of Graham Nash’s concert was incorrect.