Just for kicks, Kansas should do a song called “The Ship of Theseus.”

As you may know, the term pertains to an ancient philosophical argument of the nature of a object. Namely, if you gradually replace all the planks and pieces of a ship, does it retain its identity as the original ship?

In this case, is Kansas these days Kansas? Or 4/6ths of a tribute band?

It has just two original members in drummer Phil Ehart and Rich Williams, the rhythm guitarist now playing some of the leads, so a lot of the main instrumentation is being handled by other planks.

Advertise with us

The good thing is, “The Ship of Theseus” or any other song they would choose to do, still sounds like Kansas, and that was enough to get the band’s hardcore fans jumping to their feet Saturday night at Heinz Hall numerous times in appreciation.

Say what you want about Kansas — not everyone’s a fan, understandably — but there aren’t many bands left that deliver that style and intensity of progressive-rock jam. In fact, probably none, because Kansas was always unique in the way it crossed keyboard-drenched British prog with fiddle-driven Midwest boogie.

Personally, they had me, in 1976, from the first five seconds of “Carry On Wayward Son.” As I told Williams in a recent interview, I literally remember where I was standing (on the front steps of my house on Brintell Street in Stanton Heights) with a yellow Panasonic transistor radio in hand when I first heard it. And the thrill hasn’t gone.

I also remember going to The Listening Post in Shadyside to buy “Point of Know Return,” the follow-up to “Leftoverture,” the day it came out and rushing home to put it on the turntable.

Kansas’ focus Saturday was celebrating the 40th anniversary of the 1977 album — a year late because the 40th Anniversary “Leftoverture” Tour was more popular than they expected and kept going and going.

Advertise with us

The album climaxed a two-and-half hour show that began with five of the gents seated at center stage for a five-song acoustic set that included power ballad “Hold On,” the new song “Refugee” and a beloved deep track from the debut album, “Lonely Wind.”

“We haven’t done this in a lot of years. We want to thank Steve Walsh for writing this song,” said bassist Billy Greer, a plank since 1985.

More than anything, the acoustic set, which had a rich, full-bodied sound, highlighted just how much new singer Ronnie Platt is a vocal match for Walsh, who left the band in 2014 by his own accord (unlike several other singers from that era whose bands have carried on). Platt is distractingly tall for the role, but we can deal with that.

The acoustic set also emphasized the fiddle work of David Ragsdale, on board since 1991. We already knew of his ridiculous virtuosity, in a central and demanding role in the band.

At the end of “Lonely Wind,” Ehart sneaked into position and surprised us with a crushing hit on the drums. At 68, he is still a powerhouse, and kudos as well to the brilliant sound engineer -- what a task he has -- for making his drums kick so hard.

Advertise with us

Ehart launched a middle set that packed in a handful of Kansas’ most furious jams: the anthemic “Song for America,” the “Leftoverture” standout “Miracles Out of Nowhere” and wild “Masque” rocker “Mysteries and Mayhem,” a rare chance for Williams and Zak Rizvi to play some dirty riffs.

Throughout the night, the vocals and backing vocals were nearly studio perfect, but if there’s one place where the newfangled Kansas falls short it’s that Greer actually sounds more like Walsh (and Platt) than Robby Steinhardt, so Kansas is missing that rough, gritty voice, and it’s most noticeable on a song like “Mysteries and Mayhem.”

“Two Cents Worth,” the blues boogie song from “Masque,” was another nice addition and, of course, “The Wall” was grand, but they could have trimmed about three songs from lesser albums in that set, particularly “Wheels,” which had the guy in front of me holding up a thumbs down and loudly declaring “terrible!”

Greer said, “It’s a good problem to have, so many albums to choose from.”

Yeah, maybe, but a lot of us were thinking, “How long till the ‘Point of Know Return’” (sorry, had to).

Advertise with us

Anyway, back to The Listening Post. When I got home that day, I remember liking “Point of Know Return,” even if it didn’t have a “Carry On” on it. All these years later, it holds its own.

Under the gun to follow that breakout album, Kansas delivered with one that gave fans punchy singles like the title track and “Portrait (He Knew),” a couple thoughtful grandiose prog pieces in “Closet Chronicles” and “Hopelessly Human,” a bluesy metal song in “Lightning’s Hand” and, love it or hate it, “Dust in the Wind.”

It also came with the dizzying instrumental “Spider,” played to perfection like everything else, thanks in part to keyboardist David Manion. The only track that seemed expendable was “Sparks of the Tempest.”

When they wrapped it up the album, with those Christmas bells, a stream of people, who are clearly nuts, headed to the aisles ... maybe to get out of the lot faster?

They missed the finale of “Carry On” that, even if you were there just to hear that, was worth the two and a half hour wait.

Advertise with us

One of the things about the rebuilt ship is that you love and admire it as an entity, without necessarily relating to all the individual pieces. Sometimes that’s enough.

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.

KANSAS SETLIST

Acoustic:

People of the South Wind

Advertise with us

Hope Once Again

Hold On

Refugee

Lonely Wind

Electric:

Advertise with us

Cold Grey Morning

Two Cents Worth

Mysteries and Mayhem / Lamplight Symphony

The Wall

Song for America

Advertise with us

Wheels

Summer

Musicatto

Taking in the View

Miracles Out of Nowhere

Advertise with us

Point of Know Return

Point of Know Return

Paradox

The Spider

Portrait (He Knew)

Advertise with us

Closet Chronicles

Lightning's Hand

Dust in the Wind

Sparks of the Tempest

Nobody's Home

Advertise with us

Hopelessly Human

Encore:

Carry On Wayward Son