In February 1972, the Post-Gazette ran a syndicated gossip column in which a reader from Bath, N.Y., questioned the creative divisions of pop’s reigning music duo.

“I hear Paul Simon is coming out with an album of his own. Tell us — was it Simon or Art Garfunkel who was the really strong talent in this twosome?”

In her Newsmakers column, Robin Adams Sloan responded, “Art was the one who got the publicity particularly after he started appearing in movies like ‘Catch 22’ and ‘Carnal Knowledge.’ However, behind the scenes in the music world, it was known that Simon did most of the writing as well as playing the guitar and singing, while Art was more into the vocals. The LP that Simon is doing with its hot single, ‘Mother and Child Reunion,’ may set the record straight.”

That it did.

Advertise with us

Mr. Simon, who plays PPG Paints Arena Monday on his farewell tour, went on to do quite well for himself, find new ways to blend his beautiful poetry and most tender of vocals with a whole wide world of rhythm. He would sell tens of millions of solo albums, win 12 Grammys and be one of the few artists to crack Rolling Stone’s list of both 100 Greatest Guitarists and 100 Greatest Songwriters of All Time.

Paul Simon

Where: PPG Paints Arena, Uptown.

When: 8 p.m. Monday.

Tickets: $47-$152; ticketmaster.com.

Advertise with us

It all began decades earlier with one of pop’s great origin stories, the two friends growing up together in Queens, forming the Everly Brothers-style duo Tom and Jerry as teenagers and scoring a hit with “Hey Schoolgirl” in 1957, just a year or two after the birth of rock ’n’ roll. Then came a split for college and a reunion as Simon & Garfunkel.

Their 1964 Columbia debut, “Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M.,” was a bust, but Columbia producer Tom Wilson refused to leave it at that. Inspired by the new folk-rock sound of the Byrds and Dylan, and unbeknownst to the duo, he recut “The Sound of Silence” as a flowing rock song.

When it was released on Sept. 13, 1965, the duo had already split and Mr. Simon was playing clubs in Denmark. Although he was “horrified” by the remix, when the song hit the Hot 100, Simon & Garfunkel regrouped and made their Pittsburgh debut on the KQV Christmas Shower of Stars at Civic Arena on Dec. 28 with The Four Seasons, Chuck Berry, the Yardbirds (with Jeff Beck), Little Anthony & Imperials, Sam The Sham, Lou Christie and Mitch Ryder & Detroit Wheels.

A few weeks later, “The Sound of Silence” soared to No. 1 on the charts, creating the need for a sudden second album, “Sounds of Silence,” that was rushed but also flush with future classics “Kathy’s Song,” “April Come She Will” and “I Am a Rock.”

In October 1966, they followed that “Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme” — poetic, timeless and groovy, and targeted, like their tours, to college hipsters. The PG alerted readers that the “red-hot Simon & Garfunkel” would be playing the Pitt Homecoming Concert at the Penn Theatre on Nov. 19, 1966 with comedian Dick Gregory. It was their first year touring with a backup band, called The Cyrkle. They also played Washington & Jefferson College.

Advertise with us

In 1967, they channeled their energy into the soundtrack to “The Graduate,” highlighted by one of the iconic songs of that generation, “Mrs. Robinson,” the first rock ’n’ roll song to win the record of the year Grammy. They played the Syria Mosque on Feb. 10, 1968 — a month after release of the single “Fakin’ It” and two months prior to fourth album, “Bookends” — in what would be their last performance here of that era.

It was a long time before we’d see either one of them again. In fact, through three solo albums in the ’70s — “Paul Simon,” “There Goes Rhymin’ Simon” and “Still Crazy After All These Years” — all supported with tours, he played here one fewer time during that decade than Van Morrison: in other words, none.

He made up for that on Oct. 14, 1980 at the former Stanley Theater on the “One Trick Pony” tour, backed by that top-notch band of session players that included guitarist Eric Gale, keyboardist Richard Tee and drummer Steve Gadd. It was the first opportunity to hear the Simon and S&G catalogs combined and, late in the evening, he was joined by the Jesse Dixon to take those gospel-tinged songs to church.

“One Trick Pony” was a more, shall we say, quiet success, so he went big in September 1981 with the The Concert in Central Park, where a reunited Simon & Garfunkel played before 500,000 people in New York City. Two years later, amid growing tension between the duo, they played to 41,000 at Three Rivers Stadium on July 29, 1983, doing a two-hour set of classics, assorted solo material and a handful of new songs from a forthcoming reunion album, to be called “Think Too Much,” that had everyone excited — except, ultimately, Paul, who realized that the material was too personal to be tread upon by Art’s voice.

“The truth is,” he told the Sarasota Herald-Tribune in August 1983, “I had a very hard time emotionally turning it over to make it a Simon & Garfunkel album. … I didn’t write for Artie’s voice.”

Advertise with us

When “Hearts and Bones” was released in November 1983, Mr. Garfunkel’s vocals were wiped from the album, and Mr. Simon essentially hit the off button on the duo’s volatile on-and-off relationship.

Despite having its many beautiful, heartfelt moments, “Hearts and Bones” bombed, but he didn’t stay down for long. He returned in 1986 with his tour de force, “Graceland,” for which he broke the cultural boycott against working in South Africa, to the chagrin of many, to incorporate the infectious sounds of mbaqanga, along with zydeco. “Graceland” sold 16 million copies worldwide, won the Grammy for album of the year and is widely considered among the greatest albums of all time. The tour, showcasing a large ensemble of South African musicians, including Ladysmith Black Mambazo, was magnificent and, to the great frustration of local fans, a no-show in Pittsburgh.

The patience of Pittsburgh fans were rewarded on March 10, 1991 at the Civic Arena with the Born at the Right Time Tour, supporting “Rhythm of the Saints,” the brooding “Graceland” follow-up that, inspired by his work with Youssou N’Dour and Milton Nascimento, was a mesmerizing blend of West African guitar with the candomble- and macumba-style rhythms of Brazil.

“I’m not just sorting through remnants of other cultures,” he told the Pittsburgh Press in the lone Pittsburgh interview he’s done. “I’m also roaming around through the generations that I lived through and was influenced by.”

With the backing of a 17-piece ensemble that included guitarist Ray Phiri and sax great Michael Brecker, music never sounded better in the Civic Arena than it did that night. It topped Neil Young’s unforgettable gig with Sonic Youth and Social Distortion a month prior as the PG’s best concert of the year.

Advertise with us

The ’90s, during which he married Edie Brickell and started a new family, was a lost decade, artistically, for Mr. Simon with his only other output being the disastrous Broadway production “Songs from the Capeman.”

He closed out the century with a bang, however, teaming with one of the few songwriters better than him, Bob Dylan, for a co-headlining summer tour. At the Star Lake Amphitheater on July 18, 1999, he was in typical fine form fronting an 11-piece band that included Pittsburgh trombonist Jay Ashby, dwarfing the headlining set by Dylan, whose voice was starting to feel with wear and tear of his Never-Ending Tour.

Together, they were one of the all-time great vocal mismatches. The PG review noted that “Me, you and Julio could have sounded just as good.” (Full disclosure: that was me, and I think maybe we could have sounded better.)

When he was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame as a solo artist in 2000, he said of Mr. Garfunkel, “I regret the ending of our friendship, and I hope that one day before I die we will make peace with each other.” As the crowd applauded, Mr. Simon glibly added, “No rush.”

First, he had business with a Beach Boy, who, despite being a fellow ’60s icons, he had never crossed paths with. He met Brian Wilson when he was being honored as the MusicCares Person of the Year prior to the Grammys. Unlike the previous tour, when they played Star Lake on July 8, 2001, the two legends did not share the stage together.

Advertise with us

In February 2003, 50 years after they met, Simon & Garfunkel opened the Grammy Awards show in New York with “The Sound of Silence” and received a well-deserved Lifetime Achievement Award.

“Everyone knows [that] as friends, we haven't always been the best of friends,” Mr. Simon said. “Because actually we’re family. That’s forever.”

What transpired was another reunion, the Old Friends Tour, which found them in Pittsburgh, at the Civic Arena, for the first time in 21 years on June 16, 2004. In a highly nostalgic mood, they put fresh twists on old songs and brought out their their boyhood idols, Don and Phil Everly, for a mid-show mini-set, plus a foursome on “Bye Bye Love.”

Since then, it’s been another dry spell here, as he’s bypassed Pittsburgh on the Sting + Simon tour in 2014 and trips backing three new albums, on which he’s continued to explore new sounds, including his first venture with Brian Eno on “Surprise.” This trip coincides with “In the Blue Light,” exquisite reinventions of some lesser-known songs with a cast that includes Wynton Marsalis, Bill Frisell, Jack DeJohnette, Gadd and New York-based chamber ensemble sextet yMusic.

In February, a few months after turning 76, he released this statement:

Advertise with us

“I’ve often wondered what it would feel like to reach the point where I’d consider bringing my performing career to a natural end. Now I know: it feels a little unsettling, a touch exhilarating, and something of a relief.

“I love making music, my voice is still strong, and my band is a tight, extraordinary group of gifted musicians. I think about music constantly. Sadly, we lost our lead guitarist and my friend of 30 years, Vincent N’guini, who died last December. His loss is not the only reason I’ve decided to stop touring, but it is a contributing factor. Mostly, though, I feel the travel and time away from my wife and family takes a toll that detracts from the joy of playing. I’d like to leave with a big Thank You to the many folks around the world who’ve come out to watch me play over the last 50 years.

“After this coming tour, I anticipate doing the occasional performance in a (hopefully) acoustically pristine hall, and to donate those earnings to various philanthropic organizations, particularly those whose objective is to save the planet, ecologically.

“Once again, I am very grateful for a fulfilling career and, of course, most of all to the audiences who heard something in my music that touched their hearts.”

Around that time, Jason Isbell, one of this generation’s finest songwriters, retweeted a call from someone asking for suggestions of Paul Simon’s greatest lyric, adding, “Losing love is like a window in your heart. Everybody sees you’re blown apart. Everybody feels the wind blow.”

Advertise with us

As the posts piled up, one lyric more insightful, clever and confessional than the next, people admitted to getting misty-eyed and choked-up reading through them

Speaking for Paul Simon fans, we’re the ones who feel grateful.

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.