In its savage review of “August and Everything After,” Entertainment Weekly wrote of Counting Crows’ debut that the band seems “as if they’d risen out of a marketing meeting at Geffen Records.” It added that, “It’s bad enough that such blatant calculation has gone into the band’s look. Even worse is the album itself.”

Fortunately for the band, enough music fans disagreed with that assessment, and 25 years later, not only is the seven-times platinum “August and Everything After” considered a ’90s classic, but songs like “Mr. Jones,” “Round Here” and “Rain King” continue to draw in new fans and drive the band’s summer touring schedule.

Counting Crows, which formed in San Francisco in 1991, is marking the anniversary of its debut with the 25 Years and Counting Tour, which stops at KeyBank Pavilion on Thursday with opener Live, the York, Pa., band that broke out around the same time with its second album “Throwing Copper.”

A common approach to such a milestone is to play the breakthrough album in its entirety, but Counting Crows frontman Adam Duritz, known for his blunt emotional honesty, has no desire to do that. In fact, he can’t even be counted on to play “Mr. Jones” every night.

Advertise with us

Instead, Counting Crows, which went against the grunge grain of the early ’90s by recalling The Band, Bob Dylan, Van Morrison and R.E.M., is sampling songs from its six proper studio albums, including its most recent, 2014’s “Somewhere Under Wonderland.”

There are pieces of songs in the works for a long-awaited follow-up, but there isn’t much urgency at the moment to get new music to the fans.

Earlier this week, Mr. Duritz talked about Counting Crows at 25.

It seems like you’ve been coming here pretty regularly. Are you guys touring more than you did in the earlier days?

We were almost always touring, except the years we were makings records. Maybe since we've been making less records, we’ve been touring more. We’ll just play festivals next year. I don’t think we’ll do a regular tour in America, I don’t think.

Advertise with us

Congrats on 25 years. What strikes you when you think about that number?

I don’t have a take on it, maybe just because we were here every day, the whole time, and didn’t really notice it happening. When I think about it intellectually, it’s pretty amazing. I’m a musician and I have a lot of friends who are musicians. I know how hard it is to keep a band together for 25 years because no one else seems to do it. Just to keep it together, let alone have success with it. I’m pretty proud of that, but I’ve been proud of that every year we’ve done it. I don’t know that 25 years made that much of an impression on me. We’ve been together a little longer than that, actually. That’s just 25 years since people noticed us.

You guys started in the middle of this grunge, Lollapalooza era. Was there a feeling that a rootsier sound might not work in that environment?

No, not really. I think with every band, you’re not sure it’s going to work. No one thinks of themselves as surefire successes because success in music is so small that you better concentrate on things like making good music, because the rest of it, who the hell knows? I think the labels were all excited about it because of the songs, and whether you’re us or Nirvana, that’s the gold standard, to have songs. The same guy who signed us signed Nirvana and he saw the same thing in both bands. The music might have been different, but the thing about both bands is that they had songs.

What was it like experiencing that first album blowing up the way it did? How did you guys handle it?

Advertise with us

Um, poorly, I think. It was a little overwhelming for me, especially. I was pretty shy and you don’t think about how much value anonymity has until it’s gone. Suddenly, there are people camped out on your lawn, and everywhere you go it’s an issue — positive and negative, but an issue. I had to leave Berkeley and move, because people were camped out on my lawn and I couldn't go anywhere. I didn’t enjoy that part of it. I was happy we were successful — as a concept. I always say that fame isn’t something you do, it’s something other people do to you. Also, quite often, fame has nothing to do with any particular work you did and everything to do with just like a fever catching people. They get excited about fame because you’re famous; it’s sort of a self-fulfilling prophecy, and it has nothing to do with your art. People would get excited about people that are famous, and you sort of see the things that you do that have value kind of lose value in a way because it’s now about the fever rather than, “I really love this song.” In the beginning, everybody that loves you had to seek you out, so it was about, “I really love that song.” It’s a weird, uncomfortable thing, and I had a hard time with that.

Your music was intimate, and then you're quickly playing to thousands of people. Was it hard adjusting to that?

No, that was always the point, you know. I liked the large venues because it’s easy in a small club to do something intimate, but to have 60,000 people at a festival in Holland or some large venue and still be able to express musical intimacy, that I always thought was really cool, and harder.

Were there any gigs or moments where you were like, “I can’t believe we’re doing this right now”?

Well, the first time we opened for the Stones, it was on my 30th birthday [Aug. 1, 1994]. It was RFK Stadium in DC and there were 60,000 or 70,000 and that was really cool. Not just the crowd but hanging around backstage with the Stones for a few weeks while we were on tour, that was really, that was really shocking.

Advertise with us

On this tour, was there any thought to celebrating the anniversary by playing “August and Everything After” straight through?

Not by me. By everybody else. But not by me. I never even considered doing that, really. We did that show with that album once, and also, to me, I’m not celebrating 25 years of that record, I’m celebrating 25 years that we made music, all kinds of music. I understand that that record was important, because it’s the one that sold the most. I like it too, but I’m not doing ANYTHING every night. That’s not true, there are some things I don’t mind playing every night, but not off that record.

We’ve all noticed that you don’t play “Mr. Jones” every night. What is the thinking behind that?

COUNTING CROWS

With: Live.

Where: KeyBank Pavilion, Burgettstown.

When: 6:30 p.m. Thursday.

Tickets: $18-$128; ticketmaster.com.

There are some songs where I just don’t play them on the nights I don’t want to play them. It’s really as simple as that. I love that song, but I don’t want to use that song, so I don’t want to play it unless I want to play it. To me, singles have never been all that important because often they’re just songs the record company picked because they were short enough to go on the radio. I’m interested in playing songs from all over the catalog. I understand that people would like us to just play a group of songs every night, but I think it’s more important that we be really good every night, and I don’t want to start phoning it in. I’m just not one of those guys who could just play the list of songs everybody else wants every night. I would get really bored. I mean, I know I would get really bored. I would rather play really well than play the set everybody wants.

In terms of what’s coming, do you feel less pressure now to keep producing new material?

Advertise with us

I don't think I ever felt pressure about it. I always liked making records. Lately, I’m more concerned about how to do it. I just don’t know how to put out music anymore. I don’t know how to put it out without having it just disappear.

I’m sure you feel fortunate to have come out at a time when people were still excited about buying records.

It was a mixed bag because you had record companies to deal with and that kind of [messed] everything up. You still had people interested in buying music, which was really great. So it was a mixed bag. Now, it’s great for bands because it’s so much less expensive to record, especially for young bands.

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.