September 2018 will mark the 40th anniversary of the Sugarhill Gang’s “Rapper’s Delight,” the first hip-hop song to break out and cross over into the mainstream.
This week in Pittsburgh underscored the fact that 39 years later, we’re still arguing about the merits of the music, which, combined with R&B, has become the industry’s most consumed genre (it leads rock by 31.2 percent to 23.1 percent, according to Nielsen’s mid-year report).
On Tuesday, WYEP (91.3 FM), which has a format focused largely on indie-rock, Americana and blues, took to Facebook with the question, “What kind of hip-hop do you want to hear on WYEP?”
It actually took a whole seven posts for the discussion to become heated, when a woman’s suggestion of “No hip-hop, just trip-hop: Portishead, Massive Attack, Morcheeba, Everything But the Girl” was translated by another poster as “Only white people music please.”
WYEP does play music by black artists, but it’s more likely to be in the roots vein of Leon Bridges, Gary Clark Jr. and Charles Bradley. It has DJ Selecta’s R&B/hip-hop show “Grand Groove Radio” on Friday evenings and Michael Canton’s long-running “The Soul Show” on Saturday afternoons.
Rock is far and away the dominant radio format in Pittsburgh. The top three stations WWSW (94.5 FM) (with a 9.4 share of the market), WDVE (102.5 FM) (8.5 share) and WRRK (96.9 FM) (7.1 share) play mostly classic rock. WYEP has a 1.4 share of the market, and WAMO (100.1 FM), the only devoted hip-hop station, doesn’t appear in the rankings.
If it’s any indicator, the two major hip-hop shows here this summer, Khalifa and Kendrick Lamar, were among the most-attended concerts at KeyBank Pavilion.
Along with suggestions for WYEP of Lamar and classic alt-hip-hop artists like Digable Planets, A Tribe Called Quest and Atmosphere, there were comments like “That will be my final click onto 91.3” and “Don’t ruin wyep with hip hop.”
“Honestly, I'm not sure we knew what to expect,” WYEP general manager Abby Goldstein said Friday. “Our intention here was to engage our social media community in discussions about music. We're open to all thoughts and feedback.”
That situation was mild compared to the one at Arsenal Bowl. On Sunday, Peter Guellard, a member of the band Venus in Furs who DJ’ed at the Lawrenceville bowling alley on Saturday afternoons, went to Facebook with a notice posted to the staff: “ATTN: DJ's Do NOT play RAP/HIP-HOP (this includes requests) – Mgmt.”
Hip-hop really isn’t his thing, and the only hip-hop record he could remember playing was the famed 1986 Aerosmith/Run-DMC hookup on “Walk This Way.”
But it didn’t take long for the sign to spread like wildfire through social media, generating a fierce backlash against Arsenal Bowl.
“I let other people draw their own conclusions,” he says. “I was just the whistleblower. It had no commentary.”
For that, Mr. Guellard was told via another DJ that he was fired from his gig there.
“Remember this picture that I posted today?” he posted. “Well, I got fired because of it. Apparently, the management didn’t like your comments (mind you: ‘your’ comments, not mine as I only posted the photo without any commentary). I personally don’t give a single f--k about this gig but other DJs who spin there might. I have been warned to take down this photo. Let me think, why would a private business not want a rap/hip-hop warning note to DJs be publicized? Are they afraid of something? What could it possibly be? I certainly know that you guys know what to do…”
On Monday, Arsenal Bowl attempted to smooth things over with this statement on Facebook:
On Wednesday, it returned with another post:
The reaction to that post has ranged from “There are ‘clean’ versions of hip-hop songs that can be played” to “It’s their business. They can play whatever music they want if people don’t like it they can bowl some where else.” to “WE SHOULD WORRY MORE about the REAL PROBLEMS.. LIKE TRUMP ANS (sic) HIS POLITICS...THATS THE REAL PROBLEM NOT a bowling alley.”
After the story was covered by WPXI, Arsenal Bowl issued another statement and also posted it on its door:
“Arsenal Bowl has been a beloved Pittsburgh establishment since 1938. We operate a safe, healthy, and harassment-free workplace that values diversity. Our goal is to create a warm and welcoming environment for all customers, and we have zero tolerance for discrimination of any kind. On Sunday, a sign was posted (specifying music not to be played) that has upset members of our community. It shouldn’t have been created and it shouldn’t have been posted. It was wrong, and we are sorry for unintentionally offending some members of our community with this sign. We take full responsibility for it and are taking action to ensure something like this never happens again.”
Asked if bowlers will be hearing hip-hop there in the future, an Arsenal Bowl spokesperson said in an email Friday, “Absolutely. It has always been and will continue to be part of our music mix. All genres of music are welcome and played at Arsenal. During the afternoons on weekends we advise our DJs to not play music that contains explicit or inappropriate lyrics, because we generally have customers who are children and minors during that time.”
The Facebook posts will slowly recede, but the flurry of one-star reviews that appeared this week on Arsenal Bowl’s Yelp page highlighting the sign and accusing the management of racism are likely to hang around for a while.
As for Guellard, he isn’t looking to get his DJ job back, in the unlikely event it’s offered to him.
“Even if they did, I wouldn’t take it back,” he says. “I would recommend a friend of mine who is an excellent DJ who is African-American.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.