People who walked into that Chicago concert cold — perhaps as compensation for the Jimmy Buffett kerfuffle — may have thought they stepped into “The Twilight Zone.”

For the first hour of its set at the KeyBank Pavilion, it wasn’t the typical Saturday in the park.

Chicago, despite hitting the 50-year milestone in 2017 and having to replace three members this year -- hey, it happens when there’s 10 guys -- has boldly decided not to just coast on the hits. On this package with fellow Illinois band REO Speedwagon, Chicago is performing the full 1970 double-LP “Chicago,” aka “Chicago II.”

It was Grammy nominated, it has three hits and there are enough of them in circulation that a copy could be had for $1 at the recent Vinyl-Palooza, but fans who like Chicago for the greatest hits or, worse yet, just the Peter Cetera ballads, aren’t going to know “Fancy Colours,” the “Ballet for a Girl in Buchannon” suite or much of the material.

Advertise with us
Robert Lamm (Scott Mervis / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Partway through, singer-keyboardist Robert Lamm, one of three original members, acknowledged these were likely “songs you’ve never heard before, adding, “We wrote them about what was going on in 1970. We put our heart and souls into these compositions.”

They resequenced it a little so that it began with “Make Me Smile” and ended triumphantly on a “25 or 6 to 4” jam that delivered in weaving the iconic guitar riff and brass with fiery energy. That alone was worth the price of admission and the hassle to get out there, and was probably better than anything Buffett had to offer. (I don’t know — I was at Blue Oyster Cult.) In between, there was plenty to like from the second album, from the blues-rock/jazz fusion of “In the Country” and “Movin’ In” (two songs originally sung by the late Terry Kath) to the bubblegum pop of “Wake Up Sunshine” (with ‘60s daisies all over the screens) to the anti-war jam “It Better End Soon.”

Chicago horn players James Pankow, Ray Herrmann and Lee Loughnane (Scott Mervis / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Lamm, sporting the weightier baritone heard on “Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?” and many other hits, shared the bulk of the vocals with keyboardist Lou Pardini and new member Neil Donell, a tenor from a Chicago tribute band who sounds enough like Cetera. Leading the charge up front was guitarist Keith Howland with original members James Pankow (trombone) and Lee Loughnane (trumpet) and saxophonist Ray Herrmann.

The people who came for the hits, which was probably most of the crowd of about 10 or 11,000, were rewarded with a second hour that covered both funked-up jams like “Beginnings” and “Dialogue (Part I & II)” (delivered with images from presidents to Martin Luther King) to such pretty ballads as “If You Leave Me Now” and “You’re the Inspiration.” Pankow said of the latter that while they were in the studio, in the early ‘80s, “We heard that Kenny Rogers was looking for a song. Well, we offered him this song and he turned it down. Big mistake.” Given the way it turned out, it seems like everyone made the right choice.

Late in the set, we got a lovely soprano sax solo from Herrmann on “Just You 'n' Me,” a Santana-style drum workout from Walfredo Reyes Jr. and percussionist Ramon Yslas on “I'm a Man” and the joyful finale of “Saturday in the Park” into “Feelin' Stronger Every Day,” which, at their age, might not be true but was convincing enough.

Advertise with us

REO Speedwagon, launched in the same year of 1967, has a different sound but a similar history of going from a heavier rock band to a middle-of-the-road ballad band in the ‘80s.

Chicago/REO drew a wide range of fans. (Scott Mervis / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Singer Kevin Cronin offered a brief explanation, saying they were about to get dropped from their label around 1980 unless they came up with a hit. “I was kinda stressing,” he said, “and then at 4 a.m. I woke up from a dead sleep” and he ran to his Sony Walkman. “I recorded the idea real quickly and it’s a good thing I did, because our lives have not been quite the same since.”

That was “Keep on Loving You,” the 1980 power ballad that launched the second phase of the band’s career. In its hit-filled 75-minute set, REO did a good job of covering both ends of the spectrum, from that and “Can't Fight This Feeling” to the hard rockers like “Keep Pushin' ” and “Ridin’ the Storm Out.”

The 66-year-old Cronin, who harbors a lot of nostalgia for the Stanley Theater, hasn’t lost much off the top of his range, and the band, intact since ‘89, is obviously a tight unit with some firepower in guitarist Dave Amato. (Like Howland, he had big shoes to fill taking over for Gary Richrath.) The only downside to the set was a mix that, to me, sounded a little tinny on the high end. Even with all the horns, Chicago didn’t have that issue.

REO ended on a sentimental but rockin’ note with a tribute to what Cronin called his favorite American rock ’n’ roll band, Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers, on “Listen to Her Heart.”

Advertise with us

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.

REO SPEEDWAGON SETLIST

Don't Let Him Go

In Your Letter

Keep Pushin'

Advertise with us

Can't Fight This Feeling

Tough Guys

Take It on the Run

Time for Me to Fly

Back on the Road Again

Advertise with us

Ridin' the Storm Out

Encore:

Keep On Loving You

Roll With The Changes

Listen to Her Heart (Tom Petty cover)

Advertise with us

CHICAGO SETLIST

Make Me Smile

So Much to Say, So Much to Give

Anxiety's Moment

West Virginia Fantasies

Advertise with us

Colour My World

To Be Free

Now More Than Ever

Movin' In

Poem for the People

Advertise with us

In the Country

Wake Up Sunshine

Fancy Colours

Memories of Love

Where Do We Go From Here

Advertise with us

It Better End Soon

25 or 6 to 4

Beginnings

Dialogue (Part I & II)

Call on Me

Advertise with us

If You Leave Me Now

Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?

You're the Inspiration

I'm a Man

(Spencer Davis Group cover)

Advertise with us

Just You 'n' Me

Hard to Say I'm Sorry / Get Away

Saturday in the Park

Feelin' Stronger Every Day