Tens of thousands of Kenny Chesney fans brought the party — and their reputation as a rowdy, messy group — as they descended on the North Shore for the country music superstar’s concert Saturday.

But city officials, who implemented tight restrictions for tailgating in the wake of past problems, said the concertgoers acted responsibly in the lead-up to the show, a welcome change from other years.

“They came into the city and trashed the North Shore and left,” Guy Costa, the city’s chief operations officer, said of fans at previous Chesney concerts at Heinz Field.

This time around, two dozen people were taken to hospitals for various reasons, and arrests were minimal, Mr. Costa said.

Advertise with us

There was trash, but even that was considered less than in previous years.

Laurie Lipniskis, 52, a patient advocate for a pharmacy who lives in North Huntingdon, said she never understood why people would leave the parking lots such a mess.

“Look at us?” she said, motioning to her group of six who were eating and drinking together by their truck in a parking lot before the concert. “We’re here. We’re drinking. But we’re just here to have fun and not make a mess.”

Kenny Chesney

Why do others do it, though?

“Well, we’re not going to leave garbage behind. But the people who just passed us will,” Ms. Lipniskis said, motioning to a group of four 20-somethings walking through the parking lot.

Advertise with us

What is it about that group?

“Morals. Not having proper upbringing,” she said.

The millennials-cause-the-problems-cause-they-weren’t-raised-right was a popular theme among both boaters and parking lot tailgaters.

Zak Kriechbaum, 21, was at the concert with friends, and he wasn’t buying the millennial argument.

It was his first Chesney concert, but he has seen the videos and heard the stories about what happened in the past.

Advertise with us

“I’m trying to be respectful,” he said. “Not everyone cleans up though.”

Parking lot tailgaters were well aware of the numerous restrictions that have been put in place since the mess left in 2013, including new ones like needing a ticket to even get into the parking lot and later parking lot opening times. And they all thought they helped cut down on the rowdiness.

The city’s mounted patrol was also making the rounds, and officials for the first time were observing the crowd from a borrowed tower mounted with five cameras.

Pittsburgh public safety spokesman Chris Togneri said by 10:30 p.m., police had made four arrests and cited 15 people; EMS had evaluated 71 people and took 24 of them to hospitals; and public works hauled away 25 tons of trash. All of those numbers were lower than in previous years, he said.

Officers from the state police bureau of liquor control cited 22 minors for underage drinking in Heinz Field parking lots. State police also cited three minors for possession of a false identification card and one other for disorderly conduct. Two people were charged for making sales without a license.

Advertise with us

Mandi Haun, 30, a teacher from Hubbard, Ohio, pointed out something else inevitable that may be working in recent years to cut down on the violence and mess fans left behind.

“I think things here have gotten better” with the crowd, she said. “But I also think Kenny’s following has gotten a bit older. That has probably helped.”

And the two largest groups of fans — those who partied on or near boats docked on the Allegheny River, and those who partied in the parking lots near the stadium — generally agreed with the city that past behavior has been embarrassing.

“I call it disrespectful the way some people act here,” said Doug Kriechabaum, 53, who has been to at least three Chesney concerts at Heinz Field, and tailgated in the parking lots at every one, including Saturday’s. “It’s just a change in the way people act. Back in the day, we knew how to clean up after ourselves.”

“I guarantee you, you won’t see any trash here when we leave today,” he said, noting the organizers gave out one large black plastic garbage bag and one blue recycles bag when each vehicle entered the parking lots near the stadium.

Advertise with us

One of the restrictions the city has been imposing since 2013 is to delay members of his so-called No Shoes Nation – a slogan adopted by fans from the lyrics of one of Mr. Chesney’s many hit songs – from parking and tailgating near Heinz Field until 1 p.m.

That seems to have played a role in cutting down on drunken and violent incidents in the parking lot that resulted from a day’s worth of drinking, although when concertgoers went into the show, a significant amount of trash was left behind and not all of it in bags.

But there has never been a similar rule imposed on boaters parking — and partying — on or near the North Shore. In many cases, boaters have been mooring their boats on the North Shore by the stadium for weeks to ensure they’ve had a choice spot — all with nary a problem.

By 11 a.m. Saturday, there were already more than 150 boats moored on the North Shore of the Allegheny River between the Clemente Bridge and Heinz Field, and dozens more arrived every hour until concert time.

That there have been so few issues with boaters is a point of pride for the impromptu flotilla, happily dubbed either “Chesney’s Navy,” or “Kenny’s Navy,” depending on who you talk to.

Advertise with us

“All the boaters are definitely better partiers. There’s good vibes out here,” said Cory Mueller, 21, a college student from Ambridge who was hanging out with seven of his friends on one of their friend’s boats that had been parked by PNC Park since Monday.

“I’m completely against trashing the place,” he said. “We’re not like those folks up there.”

By “up there,” he meant the parking lot tailgate area.

After talking to several dozen boaters Saturday morning, it’s clear the Chesney Navy wants people to know that there is a big difference between them and the parking lot revelers who were on those viral videos from 2013.

“No, no, no. I never go to the parking lot,” said Derek Macko, 32, a city of Pittsburgh firefighting recruit who lives on Mount Washington and was hanging out with boater friends Saturday morning on the North Shore.

Advertise with us

His friend, Jim Nelson, 43, a restaurant employee who lives in Bellevue chimed in: “It gets crazy in the parking lot.”

But why? What is the difference between Chesney fans who get up early and drink on or near a boat tailgate – every boater interviewed for this story between 9 and 11 a.m. was drinking a beer or wine cooler — versus a Chesney fan who gets up early and wants to drink in a parking lot?

Boaters soak up the sun while waiting for Kenny Chesney concert

The Chesney Navy has several theories.

“It’s definitely wilder up there [in the parking lot] because it’s younger,” said Kathy Quealy, 49, a homecare nurse from Derry who parked her boat with her husband, Joe, near the Bettis Grill on the North Shore on April 28 because their dock on the South Side was destroyed by ice.

The age difference was a common refrain from boaters, who did generally seem to be older, but not exclusively.

Advertise with us

Another common belief was put best by Sean Kowalsky, 27, a software engineer from Ambridge who owns the boat Mr. Mueller was partying on: “We’re chill.”

The boat-culture-leads-to-cooler-heads belief was widespread among boaters – every one of whom said they stay away from the parking lots on purpose.

Mr. Mueller had a related belief that others said might actually be true: “It’s the boat owners’ property — the boats — so they don’t want to trash it.”

Do the tailgaters agree?

Surprisingly, yes.

Advertise with us

None of the 20 parking lot tailgaters — they don’t seem to yet have a catchy nickname like “Chesney’s Navy” — interviewed for this story said they were part of the problem in years past. But they all recall how bad it was.

“It was a mess” in 2013, Ms. Haun said. “I remember driving out [of the parking lot in 2013] worried that my tires were going to pop because there was so much glass on the ground.”

But why? What is the difference between the thousands of people who hang out near the boating area and those who tailgate in the parking lot?

“It’s in the air,” said Cheryl Tilker, 54, of Greensburg, who was partying with six friends in the parking lot outside Heinz Field. “You just get caught up in the moment” in the parking lot where everyone is really squeezed in.

Andrew Goldstein contributed. Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill