Sometimes it’s best to get the hit out of the way, and indie folk band Fleet Foxes did just that during what frontman Robin Pecknold called the band’s first Pittsburgh performance.

Fans in the city have been waiting a decade to hear the breakout hit “White Winter Hymnal” in the flesh, the first single from the band’s self-titled album in 2008, which much of the crowd probably first heard in high school. The delivery was reassuring.

Six songs into the 90-minute performance, an orange strip of lights lined the bottom edge of the stage at the Benedum Thursday night before a marbled backdrop of black and white. The packed auditorium, with a median age of perhaps 30, was feverish for the song, screaming as soon as they heard the opening notes.

To watch a Fleet Foxes performance is to watch a dance — of vocals, guitars and percussion fluctuating between a cacophony of sound and a near-whisper of acoustic melody; of brilliantly colored lights and psychedelic images morphing into a minimalist spotlight; of a crowd caterwauling with anticipation and then mellowing into a lull.

Advertise with us

But not a dance of musicians. Mr. Pecknold of the Seattle-based group known for its genteel lyricism, and the other five members of the full touring band, flexed their vocal cords and musical chops while their stage presence remained as subdued as you might imagine, laying on your bed listening to one of their critically acclaimed albums.

The music was unadulterated, unfiltered, devoid of the overproduction many live shows boast. Fleet Foxes accomplished a sound on stage that was not only reminiscent but true to their studio recordings. There was an emphasis on instrumentals and harmonizing throughout the set that felt cathartic and dreamy.

The focus was on their first and third studio albums, with “Fleet Foxes” and the 2017 album “Crack Up” encompassing 15 of the 22 songs they played.

Though Mr. Pecknold’s gentle swaying through softer songs like “Your Protector” and “Ragged Wood” from the group’s first album was only mildly visually stimulating, it was tender in a way that felt suitable for the set. It would have been awkward to see a mic swing or a really any flourish of movement in those instances.

Most seated shows feel stifling, like there’s no room to get up and dance or push to the front or interact with the artist, but a Fleet Foxes show doesn’t require that bustle. It was therapeutic to let the songs wash over your head in a theater with acoustics that could actually do the music justice.

Advertise with us

And that’s pivotal for a group that switches out instruments between nearly each song — from not only guitars, keyboards and your typical percussion, but also the upright bass, clarinet, vibraphone and the tambourine. The latter, of course, was saved for upbeat songs like “Fool’s Errand,” “He Doesn’t Know Why” and  “Cassius,” interspersed throughout the set. Each exchange of instrument was done quickly while the lights dimmed, near effortlessly.

Mr. Pecknold didn’t do much talking, but when he did it was largely reactionary, a response to the crowd. That felt authentic, like he was a bit shy but willing to have a one-on-one with anyone he could hear shouting from the back.

After playing “Battery Kinzie,” a fan yelled out “Stay in Pittsburgh!” to which Mr. Peckhold sort of chucked and said that his sister comes here all the time. Another member of the audience said they were from Seattle and he joked that he recognized them.

Then he asked if this was a big Carnegie family reunion. And he pronounced the late industrialist’s last name the Pittsburgh way, with the middle syllable pronounced like “neg,” which of course, everyone ate up like candy.

Maybe he’ll get the band to come back more often.

Courtney Linder: clinder@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1707. Twitter: @LinderPG.