Earlier this month, Best Buy — “once the most powerful music merchandiser in the U.S.,” according to Billboard — announced that it would discontinue sales of CDs on July 1.
Juke Records is beating them to it.
The Bloomfield store posted on Wednesday that it is selling off its CD collection at 50 percent off and no longer stocking the format.
“I can’t remember the last time a person under 40 bought a CD in this store,” says owner Jeffrey Gallagher. “I hate to say it, but it’s mostly middle-aged guys. Young people are streaming music, and if they buy a product, it’s a vinyl.”
Mr. Gallagher, whose sales are 90 percent vinyl, has watched as CDs have lost their value a little more each day with the rise of streaming sites like Spotify and Apple Music, the comeback of vinyl and the beginning of a trend toward eliminating CD players in new cars.
The Bloomfield shop, which dates back to the late ’70s, has a history that traces the rise and fall of music formats. It began as Jim’s Records with vinyl and cassettes, and transitioned to Paul’s CDs in the ’90s. In recent years, it edged back toward vinyl as Sound Cat Records, and now, like the famed Jerry’s Records in Squirrel Hill, it will go all vinyl with Juke.
So, what is the value of those Green Day, Taylor Swift and Pearl Jam CDs that so many people have?
“Virtually nil,” Mr. Gallagher says. “Just go look at the prices on Discogs,” where many of the popular titles are a dollar or two.
The CDs that have maintained more value are imports, rarities and out-of-print titles like that stock of John Zorn CDs he has stashed away. Those type of CDs are about one in 50 that are offered to him.
The Exchange stores, a Mid-Atlantic chain based in Ohio, continue to stock new and used CDs, with prices of used titles dropping, but it might be among the last outlets for them.
Best Buy plans to pull CDs and carry vinyl for the next two years. Billboard reported that Target, which has scaled down its selection considerably, from about 800 to 100 titles, has notified music suppliers that it wants to sell CDs on a consignment basis” and that “if the majors don’t play ball and give in to the new sale terms, it could considerably hasten the phase down of the CD format.”
CD sales, which peaked at 800 million in 2001, dropped from 104 million in 2016 to 89 million last year. Fifty-four percent of total audio consumption was streamed, and vinyl accounted for 14 percent of physical sales.
At The Attic in Millvale, the percentage is more like 70-30 vinyl and the CD still has some shine to owner Fred Bohn.
“We’re buying them every day,” he says. “I feel that it’s going to be like the vinyl thing in the ’90s. The hype leads everyone to get rid of them, and then they realize they want them again and come back and buy them again.”
Here’s the thing, though: for most titles, he’ll give you about a buck for the CD, and those big platinum blockbusters like Shania Twain or albums by a once-big ’90s bands like, say, Live, aren’t worth a penny.
In terms of contemporary artists on CD, he has no interest in stocking something like the new Lana Del Rey because people are either streaming or they want the vinyl. So, he does still stock new imports of blues and soul CDs, and, used, he’ll gladly take those classics music lovers might be reluctant to part with.
“People still collect like Dylan and Doors and that type of stuff,” he says. “They want the harder format. There is going to be a time when they’re not available. People are still going to want it and that stuffs going to dry up.”
So, what’s a collector to do: Should they hang onto their CDs?
“If they’re going to use them,” Mr. Bohn says. “If it’s just stuff that’s taking up space, get rid of it. If it’s something you think you want, you don’t just sell it because society tells you you’re not going to need it anymore.”
Local musician Joe Tarowsky isn’t taking any chances.
“Nothing on Spotify, YouTube or other streaming platforms is guaranteed,” he says. “Licensing/rights can be mercurial. I’m enough of a fan that I’ve kept most of my CDs.”
Todd Derr, of Squirrel Hill, who has shopped at the Bloomfield spot since it was Jim’s, prefers vinyl these days but also believes in stashing.
“I switched back to buying vinyl when I realized they — mostly — include MP3s, so you get the record and still have the portability. But my CDs are all digitized and stuffed in boxes in my attic, they’re not going anywhere.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.