Pittsburgh was the first city in the U.S. to broadcast classical music in its subway stations.
It wasn’t to combat crime. That isn’t a non sequitur.
Since 1986, Port Authority has piped classical music into the Downtown T subway stations (Steel Plaza, Wood Street and Gateway Center) used by thousands of commuters every day. North Side and Allegheny stations also carry the tunes, and as of 2013, the Pittsburgh International Airport broadcasts the same selections to more than 8 million travelers each year.
Just a year before, 7-Eleven stores in British Columbia, Canada started broadcasting classical music as part of an effort to curb loitering. Combined with other initiatives, the chain reported success in driving away idlers at more than 100 stores, sparking an international trend in using classical music to drive down crime.
There are dozens of news articles proclaiming the effectiveness of classical music as a crime deterrent in cities around the globe. The idea makes for a great story. But there are no published studies that indicate that classical music alone deters loitering and crime, and even the anecdotal evidence is conflicting.
“Crime wasn’t part of the equation here,” said George Hazimanolis, senior director of corporate communications at WQED. “This was part of a public art initiative back in the ’80s when the Cultural District was coming into being.”
Port Authority employees distributed more than 2,000 surveys in January 1986 after a rider suggested piping in music to make waits at the stations more pleasant. More than 80 percent of responses favored classical music.
The piped-in recordings are almost exclusively from Pittsburgh-based ensembles ranging from the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, the Pittsburgh New Music Ensemble and River City Brass to the Mendelssohn Choir, the Pittsburgh Chamber Orchestra and more.
“It absolutely shows the city in a positive light,” said Matthew Mehaffey, music director of The Mendelssohn Choir. “Pittsburgh is world renowned for its symphony. The Mendelssohn Choir is also nationally recognized as a top chorus. People should be proud of our arts economy!”
Micah Howard, a bassist in the PSO, agreed. “I think the musicians are happy that they do this — it’s really wonderful. When we come back to the city after touring it’s a nice welcome home.”
WQED Multimedia curates and provides the music, a 24-hour online streaming service now called “Q the Music.” Pittsburgh International Airport and Consol Energy co-sponsor the initiative for about $19,000 yearly, which covers playlist creation and input, technical support and equipment costs.
WQED’s programming director, Bryan Sejvar, creates two 7-hour playlists a month — everything from Mozart and Beethoven to Copland and Rimsky-Korsakov — and shuffles them to keep things fresh. During December, WQED pipes in holiday-themed music, also performed by local ensembles.
Commuter Janet Strahosky of Avalon said she didn’t know that the recordings are of Pittsburgh ensembles.
“Oh that’s the Pittsburgh Symphony? That’s wonderful,” she said. “I don’t have [classical music] on my radio at home but I find this a refreshing change.”
While Aaron White of Penn Hills, a commuter at Gateway Station, said that he appreciates that the music is performed by local groups, he believes that Port Authority should mix it up once in a while. “I think there should be a variety of artists that they play, not just one type. I would say anything from rock to hip-hop to pop — especially local artists.”
Subway Symphony
So, does it deter crime?
Today, numerous other cities play classical music in the subways. Some, like in Pittsburgh, do this simply to make commuters’ time in the stations more enjoyable. Many believe that the music deters loitering and crime.
Lily Hirsch, musicologist and writer, literally wrote the book on the subject and published “Music in American Crime Prevention and Punishment” in 2007.
“When people say using classical music works to deter crime, you have to ask what they mean by ‘works,’ ” she said in a phone conversation. “What works and what doesn’t work is changing. Cultural understanding of music and genre is constantly changing, and quickly.”
Ms. Hirsch expanded on this idea in her book, explaining that those who don’t want to be associated with this music (primarily teenagers) are less likely to congregate in areas marked by Mendelssohn or Mussorgsky. This is similar to the way that some retail spaces use classical music to seem more upscale.
But this doesn’t mean that the music ennobles anyone or actually “deters” crime at all. It simply encourages the rapscallions to congregate elsewhere. Furthermore, many in the music field believe that this casual use of classical music only reinforces those negative stereotypes associated with classical music.
London, Seattle, Dallas, Atlanta, New York, Toronto, West Palm Beach, Fla. and many other cities have experimented with this sort of sonic crime prevention in spaces ranging from subway stations to grocery stores to public parks. In many cases, local news publications reported a decrease in loitering and petty crime with the advent of classical music.
Most of these cities’ efforts were not confined to music alone, however. One such push in the London Tube in 2003 was reported to have cut robberies by 33 percent, staff assaults by 25 percent and vandalism by 37 percent. Those figures are still regularly cited today.

Often overlooked is the fact that classical music has been a small part of a larger crime-fighting strategy in the London Tube, which also involved improved lighting, greater staff visibility, more reassurance policing and other physical changes such as additional security cameras.
Another much publicized endeavor: The Tacoma Mall Transit Center in Washington state reported a nearly 50 percent drop in spending ($3,000 to $1,600) annually on vandalism-related repairs from 2006 to 2008 once authorities began piping in classical and country music, though once again the music was paired with heightened security efforts.
Minneapolis’s foray into crime fighting with Beethoven included additional lights, security cameras and police officers posted after school hours and at night. An EZ Trip convenience store in Dallas started using classical music along with other security measures. Toronto’s bid for increased safety included better lighting, additional uniformed patrols, more security cameras, installing emergency buttons and more.
Lack of evidence
The Toronto Transit Commission discontinued playing classical music as a crime stopper earlier this year.
“It was never proven to have the effect intended,” said TTC spokesman Brad Ross. “Licensing was costing us about $15,000 a year, and no one could say whether it was the extra security or the Chopin that was having an effect.”
The Pittsburgh Police declined to comment on Mozart’s efficacy as a sonic vintage vigilante, citing a lack of research. Port Authority’s records don’t extend far enough back to determine whether T station crime decreased once the stations started piping in classical music.
Over the years, the Downtown Wood Street T station, which also is a spot for a busy bus stop along Liberty Avenue, has been the site of several confrontations. On Wednesday, there was a fight at the station that involved about 40 teenagers. Police broke up the fight.
“Some people think the music can make people better, but that seems ridiculous,” said Ms. Hirsch, the musicologist.
The idea that classical music can act as a moralizing force or crime deterrent persists around the world, even though there’s been no formal statistical analysis in the 30 years since 7-Eleven established the trend.
And that seems like the real crime.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, the Getty Foundation, and the Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.