Pittsburgh Plays Petty did Petty proud Friday night at Mr. Smalls in Millvale.

Josh Bakaitus, brand manager at Mr. Smalls Presents, and Punchline drummer Cory Muro came up with the concept to honor the beloved rocker who died in October, and a talented array of Pittsburgh musicians, along with a charged-up sold-out crowd, pulled it off with much heart and spirit.

There’s not a lot of room for interpretation in Tom Petty songs — which is probably why there aren’t a lot of Tom Petty covers — so there’s a risk of a show like this being too paint by numbers. The musicians played them straight, but it was the energy and joy they brought to them that made them special. From the start, with Harrison Wargo doing “You Don’t Know How It Feels” and Josh Verbanets burning through “You Wreck Me,” the crowd was jumping in loudly on the choruses.

The format had some of the city’s best young rock singers fronting six different mix-and-match lineups. The bands each did four songs, which created five breaks for changeovers of about five or 10 minutes each. For the sake of flow, four backing bands doing six songs may have been ideal. They filled some of that space with Petty videos and words from our illustrious emcee, Mayor Bill Peduto, who introduced the artists, kept us updated on the Penguins game and told us about his own hazy experience with seeing Petty (1986 with the Grateful Dead). He drew a cheer when he mentioned the city looking for a way help reopen James Street Gastropub and Speakeasy.

Advertise with us

It was definitely a more crowd-pleasing setlist than the average Petty show — particularly this last one in June at the arena — because they played the entire Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers “Greatest Hits” album. They added the deeper tracks “Walls,” sung by Billy Schneider (of Pearl Jam tribute band Ten) and “Nightwatchmen,” delivered by Giuseppe Capolupo, with some funky, synced guitar work from Byron Nash and Michael Lindner.

(Scott Mervis / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

They also added the Petty solo song “Wildflowers,” sung sweetly by Jim Donovan with his two daughters, and, of course, one of the greatest rock duets ever, “Stop Draggin’ My Heart Around,” that had Kayla Schureman and Nathan Zoob capturing that special Nicks-Petty chemistry.

For sheer rock thrills, it was hard to beat Band II — with Chris Fafalios (Punchline), Joshua Fiedler (Juliana Theory), Scott Mellinger (Zao), Drew Donegan and Jon Belan (Gene the Werewolf), Justin Niedzwecki and Jordan Tomb — bringing bouncy pop-punk energy to “I Need to Know” (with another great Verbanets vocal) and “Runnin’ Down a Dream,” powered by Punchline’s Steve Soboslai and a big guitar jam. Belan and Zoob were spot on with “The Waiting” and “Here Comes My Girl,” respectively.

Among the other standouts: Bobby Garver stepping up with a strong vocal on “Refugee”; Quinn Wirth, of Nevada Color, taking the sounds-the-most-like-Petty prize on “American Girl”; Soboslai returning for a sing-along on “I Won’t Back Down”; Todd Porter on “Listen to Her Heart,” Andre Costello on “Even the Losers,” Chet Vincent on “Breakdown,” the “Mary Jane’s Last Dance” set-closer with Costello, Vincent and Tim Vitullo, the list goes on. It ended with the whole cast on stage for a grand finale of “Free Fallin’.”

The emotional highlight came from the evening’s most seasoned performer. Bill Deasy, of the Gathering Field, took the stage saying that his father had been taken to the hospital earlier in the day and that “it’s hard to sing when you’re sad.” He asked the crowd for help on “Learning to Fly,” and while he would have pulled it off just fine by himself, the sing-along on that anthem became the night’s most cathartic moment, putting us in touch with the fragility of life and the power and transcendence of the human spirit.

Advertise with us

All the best wishes to Mr. Deasy, and long live the music of Tom Petty! We know it will always be with us.

Petty Plays Pittsburgh will get an encore on Jan. 6. It is also sold out.