It’s hard to click on Spotify or Apple Music without feeling a little bad for the artists, who once upon a time could make a living actually selling records.
They could even do that staying home.
This is nothing new but the demise of the physical product means they have to visit us in person even more frequently. It’s a win-win for fans. Our concert schedule is more crowded than ever, with young-and-hungry bands and rappers, and beloved rockers showing that it can still be done all the way into their 70s (anyone wanna mess with Neil Young?).
The most stunning concert of the year, maybe a lifetime, came from an artist we hadn’t seen since 1994. Here’s a look back on a wild, wonderful 2017:
CONCERT OF THE YEAR
Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds (Carnegie Music Hall)
This went beyond performance into the realm of ritual or religious experience. The Australian goth icon, playing his first show here since Lollapalooza in 1994, was touring behind “Skeleton Tree,” an album written in the aftermath of his son’s death, and he made a connection with the crowd unlike any I’ve seen before. He spent a good bit of the show off the stage, becoming one with the fans in a performance, backed by a band painting like Picasso, that was raw, emotional, explosive and practically tear-jerking.
BEST PRODUCTION (AND SECOND BEST CONCERT)
Rogers Waters (PPG Paints Arena)
Pink Floyd was blowing people’s minds with sound and lights long before fans who sport their T-shirts were born, making it astonishing that Roger Waters is still pushing that envelope. No two ways about it, this was a screed against Trump and authoritarianism with the smoking “Animals” factory descending upon us in the second half and running the length of the arena floor. As always the music was flawless, timeless and immensely beautiful and powerful.
SECOND BEST PRODUCTION
Lady Gaga (PPG Paints Arena)
She’s not the provocateur she once was, but Gaga still has it. Her talent transcends that of every other dance-pop performer, and she left it all on the stage in an emotionally turbulent show. That stage was tricked out, with floating lighting pods that dropped down to create a bridge across the arena floor like something out of “Alice in Wonderland.”
BEST CONCERT PACKAGE
Farm Aid (KeyBank Pavilion)
During the daylight hours, our region’s first Farm Aid in 15 years gave us a bounty of roots artists from Valerie June to the Avett Brothers to Jamey Johnson to Sheryl Crow. And then the esteemed board members took over, with John Mellencamp filled with righteous fire, and Neil Young, in his first show of 2017, appearing in Godfather of Grunge mode with Promise of the Real. Willie Nelson closed it in grand, family style.
BEST OLD-SCHOOL JAM
Earth, Wind & Fire (PPG Paints Arena)
These shining stars from the ’70s had the arena bouncing like a game 7 Crosby goal. At the forefront was Philip Bailey, whose voice is nothing short of a national treasure. Runner-up is The O’Jays, who were down one member but powered by the great Eddie Levert.
BEST METAL SHOW
Queens of the Stone Age (Stage AE)
Josh Homme ended the year with the jerk move of kicking a photographer, sending her to the ER. At Stage AE in September, he seemed a little unbalanced. Said he had a rough day. Said he was drunk. But the performance was tight and powerful. Maybe the best show Queens ever played here.
SECOND BEST METAL SHOW
Gojira/Deafheaven/Code Orange (Stage AE)
This was one of two gigs Code Orange played in Pittsburgh, the other being the Rex Theater in January. Their set had the intensity of a cage match, on the stage and down in the pit where fans mimicked the high kicks of bassist Joe Goldman. The set climaxed with Randy Blythe jumping on stage. Lamb of God wasn’t even on the bill. It was Deafheaven, unleashing a white-hot blizzard of black metal, and Gojira roaring like rock-solid veterans.
BEST OLD PUNK
Patti Smith (Carnegie Music Hall)
The 70-year-old punk poetess came to celebrate the 40th anniversary of “Horses,” which she scattered through a set that was as joyful as it was fierce.
WORST OLD PUNK
Elvis Costello (Heinz Hall)
Something was very, very wrong with the sound mix of this show, to the point where it sounded like Elvis and his Imposters were on different pages. He took the review personally with an angry Facebook post that advocated for live music being a little sloppy. OK, sure. But for the exquisite, intricate “Imperial Bedroom”? Nah. Still love him though.
BEST PUNK BILL
Rancid/Dropkick Murphys (Stage AE)
A hearty blast of old-school Warped from two of the ’90s finest, who climaxed the night on stage together burning through Ramones, Clash and Johnny Cash.
BEST RAP SHOWS
Chance the Rapper (PPG Paints Arena)
Travis Scott (Stage AE)
Chance, taking a huge leap to the arena, “shook the building and touched the hearts of thousands of people, reminding them that their dreams and aspirations are real and attainable.” (Fitale Wari, PG review).
“In a genre marred by lackluster live performances, [Travis] Scott's energy and swagger is refreshing, and his discography — though not the deepest — translated spectacularly through the microphone.” (Julian Routh, PG review)
LAMEST RAP SHOW
Future (KeyBank Pavilion)
According to Mr. Routh, Future just sort of seemed like he needed a nap.
BEST COUNTRY SHOWS
The two Chrises (KeyBank Pavilion)
Unlike the bro-country hitmakers, Chris Stapleton trudged in slow, dirty country blues with a smoky growl and guitar firepower. In the opening slot for Sam Hunt, who was also good, Chris Janson gave us a peek into “Redneck Life” with punk-rock energy.
MOST CHATTY SHOW
Stevie Nicks (PPG Paints Arena)
The Fleetwood Mac legend, filming for a documentary, seemed to do more talking than singing at the Arena, which was not the best venue for an intimate heart-to-heart with the audience.
LEAST CHATTY SHOW
Bob Dylan (Heinz Hall)
So, what else is new? We know that from Dylan we’re going to get the songs not a whole lot of warmth. My contrarian take on this one is that he and the band seemed like they wanted to be somewhere else.
MOST ABRUPT ENDINGS
What was up with the sudden endings this year? Bryan Ferry had the soundboard crash at Heinz Hall, The Mavericks got caught in a storm at Hartwood Acres, and new Rock and Roll Hall of Famer Bon Jovi, struggling all night with a cold, threw in the towel after 90 minutes.
BIGGEST NO-SHOW
Lauryn Hill (Heinz Hall)
With a few band members delayed due to weather, the diva was on serious hip-hop time, hitting the stage at around 11:15 on a Monday night to a crowd — that had mostly cleared out. She apologized on Facebook and booked a makeup show for late February. Canceled due to “a scheduling conflict.” Then, another in June. Canceled due to “a scheduling conflict.” At this point, how can she ever book another show here
WORST SCHEDULING CONFLICTS
Speaking of which: There was Wilco and Nick Cave on the same night. Dead and Co. vs. Sigur Ros; Red Hot Chili Peppers vs. The 1975; Elvis Costello vs. Hall & Oates.
BEST EVIDENCE PEOPLE LOVE FREE CONCERTS
Boz Scaggs (Hartwood Acres)
The “Lowdown” singer had been doing gigs at the 900-capacity Carnegie of Homestead Music Hall. Booked as part of the Allegheny County Concert Series at Hartwood Acres, well over 25,000 tried to get there, causing people to abandon their cars on Middle Road like it was Woodstock.
GOOD SHOWS WITH BAD TURNOUTS
U2 doing “The Joshua Tree” at Heinz Field; The Deep Purple/Alice Cooper and Boston/Joan Jett and the Blackhearts bills at KeyBank Pavilion; Japandroids/Cloud Nothings on Halloween at Stage AE (Cloud Nothings had an interesting year in Pittsburgh. For the Schenley Plaza show in August, the bassist hurt his back and couldn’t play, and at the Stage AE show, frontman Dylan Baldi spent a good bit of stagetime dealing with a broken amp).
OTHER GREAT SHOWS
The National (hipster spectacular), The Pixies (amazing set list), Valerie June (otherworldly voice), Spoon/The New Pornographers (great indie package), Sigur Ros (stunning production), Brian Setzer (best rock ’n’ roll show of the year), Blind Boys of Alabama/Irma Thomas (soulful to the core), Run the Jewels (great start to the year), Twenty One Pilots (a new paradigm for arena-rock), Bob Seger (classic), Echo and the Bunnymen/Violent Femmes (post-punk brilliance), Randy Baumann Rambles (awesome showcases of local talent), David Crosby (one of folk-rock’s greatest voices still intact). From Dan Gigler: Gov’t Mule/Galactic, Turquaz, Marcus King Band, Lettuce. (I can’t get over the fact that there’s a band called Lettuce).
A LAST DANCE
There was no reason to think that the 40th anniversary tour stop by Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers at the PPG Paints Arena would be the last dance. Mr. Petty’s death in October was heartbreaking indeed. His music will be celebrated by Pittsburghers in two upcoming shows at Mr. Smalls in Millvale.
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.