Evan Stephens Hall has a new green guitar pick.

The lead singer and songwriter of Pinegrove showed it off Thursday during the band’s sold-out show at Cattivo in Lawrenceville, though there isn’t anything physically special about it.

Hall, 27, got the pick as part of a bet with bandmate and longtime friend Josh Marre. For the duration of the group’s tour, Marre says, Hall has to keep tabs on it.

The tour began Thursday night in Pittsburgh and has the five- or six-piece band spanning the country through October. But as Hall explained the wager, it unraveled into less of a competition and more of an opportunity for self-examination of how he values the little things in a friendship. If he loses the pick, he owes Marre a “big beer.” If the pick makes it to the other side of the next three months, then, well, Hall is simply proud of himself — “the best gift of all” — certainly for cherishing a keepsake from a close pal.

Advertise with us

He used that pick Thursday — alongside fellow guitarists Marre and Sam Skinner, bassist Adan Carlo and drummer Zack Levine — to deliver a powerful message that friendships are often unwitting riders on the rollercoaster of finding an identity. The bonds that make it out on the other side, then, are the ones we should take pride in, no matter how seemingly small or mundane.

The Montclair, N.J., band’s music is powerful in part because it’s ubiquitous. Seconds into Thursday’s opener, “Problems,” the crowd was singing along word for word. And they kept pace with Hall throughout, tracing the elastic twang of his vocals at times when it’s vulnerable and others when it’s an unfiltered high.

Setlist

Problems

Size of the Moon

Advertise with us

Cadmium

Old Friends

Aphasia

Visiting

“Pat” (unreleased song)

Advertise with us

Waveform

Then Again

Easy Enough

Angelina

The Metronome

Advertise with us

Recycling (encore)

New Friends (encore)

The only time Pinegrove played on its own Thursday was during two songs from an upcoming unfinished album. (They're about "walking around in your hometown — like most of our other songs," Hall said.)

At one point during “Aphasia,” Hall stopped singing — “I forgot where I was, let alone what song we were playing,” he joked — but the crowd sung through the silence. The line between the entertainer and the entertained was blurred between songs, too, the crowd lobbing wisecracks at Hall and Hall volleying them back.

“I’m feelin’ alright,” yelled one audience member early in the set.

Advertise with us

“Good. I was just about to ask,” Hall said, beaming. “But it’s better when you just tell me.”

The night’s lineup featured Vagabon, a New York artist who poured out starkly biographical songs about coming to the U.S. from Cameroon as a child. Even if Laetitia Tamko’s stories weren’t immediately clear to the many who were still mingling with friends near the bar, her gripping tenor and a booming electric guitar quickly commanded their attention.

Before Vagabon came Half Waif, a project through which Pinegrove’s Nandi Rose Plunkett creates pensive electronic music working with Levine and Carlo. She later reunited with Pinegrove toward the end of its performance, hopping on stage to wild applause and the recognition that Half Waif’s marathon tour is just beginning another leg. (The group toured with Land of Talk and Mitski earlier this summer.)

“I missed you,” she said in a genuinely warming moment absent of any theatrics. “These guys are my best friends.”

Together the best friends performed “Angelina” and encore songs “Recycling” and “New Friends,” all still accompanied by a crowd that clearly had also missed Pinegrove dearly — even if its last show at that exact venue was just in December.

Advertise with us

“These are songs that have helped me tremendously,” Hall said in a brief interview after the show, leaving his hand out as nearly everyone offered a parting high-five or handshake. “ … When other people jump in there, that suggests that it’s helpful to them too, and it also feels supportive to me. It’s like they’re backing me up.”

Tyler Pecyna: tpecyna@post-gazette.com or Twitter @tyler_pecyna.