The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame loves its superstars, so you can bet on Pearl Jam to follow Nirvana and Green Day as the third ‘90s band to be inducted into the hall in 2017.
The Seattle band, which stoked the grunge scene with its 1991 debut “Ten” and launched a thousand Eddie Vedder-soundalikes, was nominated today in its first year of eligibility, as was the late rap icon Tupac Shakur, who released “2Pacalypse Now” that same year.
The nominees
(listed alphabetically)
■ Bad Brains
■ Chaka Khan
■ Chic
■ Depeche Mode
■ Electric Light Orchestra (ELO)
■ J. Geils Band
■ Jane’s Addiction
■ Janet Jackson
■ Joan Baez
■ Joe Tex
■ Journey
■ Kraftwerk
■ MC5
■ Pearl Jam
■ Steppenwolf
■ The Cars
■ The Zombies
■ Tupac Shakur
■ Yes
Joining Pearl Jam and Tupac as first-time nominees are D.C. hardcore band Bad Brains, LA alt-rock pioneers Jane's Addiction, British synth-pop band Depeche Mode, classic rockers Electric Light Orchestra, Steppenwolf and Journey, and folk legend Joan Baez.
Back once again in a wildly diverse list of nominees are Chaka Khan, Chic, the J. Geils Band, Janet Jackson, Joe Tex, Kraftwerk, MC5, The Cars, The Zombies and Yes.
Last year, the hall inducted five and it was six the three years before that. So, who should get in?
Yes, the J. Geils Band, ELO, the Zombies and MC5 are popular selections on the many who-should-be-in lists to be found on the web. The Rock Hall, always slow to consider progressive rock bands, inducted Pink Floyd in 1996 and had rappers and punk bands streaming in before before it got around to Genesis in 2010 and Rush in 2013. Yes, receiving its third nomination in 22 eligible years, was ambitious, virtuosic, massively popular and is still active (currently split into the factions of Yes and ARW), so it would be the next logical step in addressing the progressive oversight.
There were plenty of blues-rock bands around before the J. Geils Band debuted in 1970 so they don’t win a lot of points for innovation. But listen to “Full House” and “Blow Your Face Out” from the ’70s and tell me they weren’t one of the great arena rock bands of the era or that Peter Wolf wasn’t one of rock’s fiercest frontmen. When the New Wave/MTV era rolled around in the early ’80s, the Boston band adapted with a slicker sound on “Love Stinks” and “Freeze Frame.”
MC5 had one of shorter runs of any of the nominees and stayed somewhat under the radar — peaking at No. 30 on the album charts with its 1969 debut live album “Kick Out of the Jams” — but even before fellow Detroit band the Stooges (inducted in 2010), MC5 set the stage for the punk revolution of the mid-’70s.
Journey, which debuted in 1975, would break the ice for the so-called “corporate rock” bands that ruled the airwaves in the late ‘70s while never getting much love from critics. Kansas, Boston, Styx and Foreigner are all part of that crew, but Journey has the edge for its popular rebirth with the hit “Don’t Stop Believin’” after its use on “The Sopranos” finale.
Jane’s Addiction, while not necessarily being a better band, has a stronger claim for induction than Pearl Jam. Along with the snubbed Nine Inch Nails, Jane’s sparked the alt-rock/alt-metal movement of the late ‘80s as its visionary leader Perry Farrell was simultaneously launching the cultural explosion known as Lollapalooza.
Bad Brains makes a surprise appearance on the list, prompting the question: What does Jann Wenner and the RRHOF committee have against Black Flag? The LA band ignited the hardcore genre with its first show in December 1977, before Bad Brains emerged as a punk band. Black Flag and Sonic Youth are among the biggest snubs (Rage Against the Machine is not yet eligible, by the way), but let me also make a pitch for Gang of Four, X, Husker Du, The Replacements, the Smiths and the Pixies as bands I would roll with before Pearl Jam.
The synth-rockers pose an interesting dilemma because there wouldn’t be a Depeche Mode if the four-times-nominated Kraftwerk, pioneers of “Krautrock,” hadn’t paved the way for that style of electronic rock a half-decade earlier with “Autobahn.”
Speaking of the Autobahn, The Cars came along two years before DM in 1978 sounding pretty sleek and modern with an enticing New Wave blend of synth-rock and power-pop.
The trickiest nominees to evaluate are the ones that fall under the “but that’s not rock ’n’ roll!” banner, starting with beloved folk legend Joan Baez and moving on to dance-pop divas Khan and Ms. Jackson, 11-time nominees Chic and highly respected rapper Tupac. He will likely be the fifth rap act to enter, joining Grandmaster Flash and The Furious Five (2007), Run-D.M.C. (2009), the Beastie Boys (2012) and N.W.A. (2016).
Narrowing it down to six is the usual headache as it requires pitting genres against each other under the banner of “rock ’n’ roll” while also juggling pioneers versus flat-out great bands. We can circle back to some of the others, but trying to cover various bases, I would vote like this:
■ J. Geils Band for being the essence of rock ’n’ roll.
■ Yes for being a prog-rock behemoth.
■ MC5 for being punk before punk.
■ Jane’s Addiction for giving us the ’90s.
■ Tupac for his rap flow and cultural importance.
■ Pearl Jam because they’re the 500-pound gorilla.
The induction ceremony will take place in April at the Barclays Center in Brooklyn. Fans can cast a vote at rockhall.com.
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg.
For concert news and listings in Pittsburgh, visit www.post-gazette.com/concerts.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.