"Get a secondhand guitar, chances are you'll go far/If you get in with the right bunch of fellows."

That was the rock 'n' roll dream of working at nothing all day as celebrated by Bachman Turner Overdrive in 1974. Rock was still relatively young, and the idea was that with the right bunch of fellows you could catch the eye of a major record label that could make you rich and famous.

Upcoming album release shows

The Scratch n' Sniffs (The Fallout Shelter, Aliquippa, Feb. 19): Debut album "Scraping by.." with The Cheats and Children of October.

Advertise with us

The Granati Brothers (Lincoln Park Performing Arts Center, Midland, Feb. 19): Release of "The Show."

Meeting of Important People (Thunderbird Cafe, Lawrenceville, Feb. 26-27): Third full-length "Troika."

Arlo Aldo (Commonwealth Press warehouse, South Side, Feb. 27): Release party with Pandemic, Mariage Blanc.

Nathan Zoob (Pittsburgh Winery, Strip District, March 5): Nathan Zoob debut EP "Curriculum Vitae" release, joined by Morgan Erina, Guy Alexander Russo, Mark Dignam and Max Somerville.

Rachel B (Atria's, PNC Park, North Shore, March 10): New album released on March 1.

Advertise with us

Jim Donovan and The Sun King Warriors (Mr. Smalls, Millvale, March 12): First band album since the drummer left Rusted Root.

Delicious Pastries (Spirit, Lawrenceville, March 18): Second EP release.

Joe Grushecky (Club Cafe, South Side, March 19): Release of solo CD "It's in My Song."

Morgan Erina (Pittsburgh Winery, May 13): New album release.

A generation of artists from Pittsburgh — Diamond Rio, Iron City Houserockers, Silencers, Granati Brothers and Billy Price, included — managed to at least accomplish the record label part back in the '70s.

Advertise with us

"But of course the vast majority of artists who were signed to those deals wound up disappointed," Price says. "So it's always been a raw deal for the artists, it's just that the raw deal today is different from the raw deal of the '70s."

These days, when that record company advance that the Boss boasted of in "Rosalita" is almost unthinkable, anyone can make a record -- and then what? In the DIY era that started in the '80s, people at least still coveted physical product. Now, artists are on their own, trying to sell music during the Spotify era when streaming will earn them pennies.

Album sales have declined drastically, from a peak of 763 million U.S. sales in 2001 to 241 million last year. There was another 6 percent decline last year that would have been much worse without Adele and Taylor Swift. The good news is that vinyl sales are up -- 30 percent! -- but they still account for less than 5 percent of sales.

While physical and digital sales continue to decline, streaming on-demand jumped 92.8 percent last year.

What has not declined is the number of local bands celebrating their new material with album release shows in the clubs. Just about every week, there's another band willing to go into the red to make its statement and put a product on the merch table.

Advertise with us

The economics are tough. Hard rocker Chip DiMonick recently released the six-song EP "Uncaged." The production costs came to $3,568.90, followed by nearly $4,000 in additional funds for video production, merch and other promotional costs.

"After sales and our crowdfunding campaign, we ended up incurring a loss of over $2,000," DiMonick says. "It was absolutely worth it! We could have easily lost $2,000 on a $7,500 investment in the stock market. But recorded music lives forever, making it more fun to play guitars and drums than to play the stock market!"

It's the musical version of publish or perish for people like Jeff Betten, who has built a roster of Pittsburgh artists (Grand Piano, Harlan Twins, Chet Vincent and the Big Bend, Host Skull, etc.) on his growing label, Wild Kindness.

"Every band should try to release an album as soon as they're able," he says. "Not only can they sell copies for profit, but it will help lead to more and better gigs. It's hard for venues to book an act that doesn't at least have an EP they can listen to. You don't have to spend a lot of money either; you just have to get your point across."

While taking much away, the digital era has brought us crowdfunding sites like Kickstarter and gofundme, where bands can finance an album through the fans. The Clarks, one of the popular bands in town, did it on their last two albums, "Feathers & Bones" and "Rewind."

Advertise with us

"Love it or hate it, crowdfunding helps to determine supply and demand for an artist," says Clarks bassist Greg Joseph. "In the days of ordering a whole basement full of albums or CDs, it was always an educated guess as to how many to order, especially when the duplication company offers quantity discounts. As the joke goes, I produced a CD that was a million-seller -- I have a million of them sitting in my cellar."

Singer-songwriter Paul Tabachneck turned to crowdfunding, having learned that recording on the cheap is not the way to go.

"I've found that when I've tried to skirt the economics of it all, I end up with shoddy product," he says. "Crowdfunding has eased the pain somewhat. My latest album, 'Two People Made This Mess,' didn't set the world on fire, but it had the benefit of 200 advance customers who funded a large chunk of the process."

Meeting of Important People, about to drop a new album this month, plans to bundle a free CD with a slightly raised $10 cover charge. The band also managed to save on production by setting a strict deadline. "Let's record in December and then mix in January and THAT'S the record," says MOIP frontman Josh Verbanets. "That way we come all practiced up and can keep recording costs down. We even booked our release events in advance to make sure we had to stick to the timeline -- otherwise you can go forever and do the Pittsburgh version of 'Chinese Democracy.' "

Some artists opt for creative packaging, none more so than Paul Luc who released his last album, "Tried & True," with a $40 special edition wooden box "survival kit" with collectibles like vintage playing cards, dice and postcards, antique photos and more.

Advertise with us

"I think the real draw to those kits was that they were personal and included hand-picked items from travels and thrifting," he says. "A lot of little items were from the 1950s and 1960s, and many with ties to Pittsburgh: old maps, bottle openers from local companies, playing cards. Those were the unique things -- along with the fact that you're getting a real CD."

The Red Western chose to split its new album into two $5 EPs, partly for stylistic reasons but also because of listening patterns.

"Through all the crazy streaming services, you can really see how folks listen to your records," says bassist Jay Leon. "We noticed that the songs at the end get a little short shrift in the streaming world. If you're just listening to something on the way from the bus stop to your office, it keeps it more digestible."

Jesse Mader, straddling rock and hip-hop, took a dual approach on his last record, landing an investor for production while also treating it in part as a "glorified flyer."

"I was able to hand them out at will, without the anxiety of 'Oh my God, I'm losing money,' whether it was in traffic, at Starbucks, on the streets or at gigs."

Advertise with us

He sold them in bulk to members of a street team to distribute them, "so it's a mix of the old and the new marketing tactics," he says.

The Spacepimps, a Pittsburgh band challenged to stand out in the crowded field of pop-punk, have the benefit of a guy with a doctorate in marketing fronting the band. For "Eternal Boy," they spent $12,000 to produce 5,000 copies and broke even at 1,200. Only 500 copies are left. It helps to have a young audience that comes to the shows with disposable income to buy music, not beer.

Spacepimps singer Rishi Bahl, who teaches at La Roche College, says, "We are always thinking of ways to maximize profitability given the economics of scale for an indie band: packaging deals (shirt, CD, vinyl, etc.), diversifying our revenue stream (digital return, merch, CD sales, shows, publishing, etc.), and constantly staying active. One thing I do NOT believe in is giving music away for free. Not because it will make it impossible to break even, but because it devalues the product. What if I got my iPhone for free, or my Starbucks? It loses the value to the consumer and therefore becomes less important to them."

Price, with a tougher challenge of working in the blues/soul genre, earned international acclaim for "This Time for Real," his collaboration with the late Otis Clay, produced by Duke Robillard of Roomful of Blues. It was not a cheap proposition and more of a labor of love, as most of these things are.

"I now think of CDs exclusively as marketing tools and no longer have any expectation that they will break even," he says. "The small blues record companies that I've worked with all will now say the same thing: They never encourage artists to expect that they will make any money, and they tend to lament the current state of the music business and look back on the pre-Internet days with nostalgia. Most deals are financed by the artists, and the record company functions as a distributor and marketing channel. That's what my deal with Vizztone is."

Advertise with us

He has a fan base that grew up on the physical product and still cherishes it, but they're often content with what they have already.

"There's a large number of people who listen only to their old Jethro Tull albums and never investigate anything that is new, and then they will tell you, 'This music today isn't as good as our music was.' People forget that at any point in time, today is somebody's Golden Age."

Of the musicians polled for this story -- and that did not include international stars Wiz Khalifa and Mac Miller, by the way -- just about all agreed that this was not a get-rich-quick scheme.

"If your end goal for being in a band is financial gain you might as well go get an office job now," says Mike Rock of Barons and Teddy Duchamp's Army. "The odds are almost lottery-esque of being able to make a living playing in a band full time these days. I hate that making art in our society has been pretty much reduced to being seen as just a hobby, but I have come to accept the fact that it is our reality as musicians."

That said, making a record is "a chapter in your life," he says, that must be chronicled.

Advertise with us

Mike Shanley of Love Letters agrees. "Anyone can play a show, for the most part, but releasing a physical set of songs means that this is more than just some weekend hobby. It represents an effort because studio work is a huge expense of energy, emotion and, of course, money."

"If you go into the act of making art wondering if it's worthwhile from a financial standpoint then you've already defeated yourself," says Nathan Zoob of Wreck Loose. "The document HAS to exist or all you are is frustrated potential. Work that exists wholly or partially in your mind isn't worth anything until it's dragged into the real world."

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576.  Twitter: @scottmervis_pg.