The last time I talked to Johnny Rotten he hung up on me.
This time it didn’t go as well.
The 2010 interview went downhill toward the end of a good 22-minute conversation when it was suggested to John Lydon, his given name and the one he uses in Public Image Ltd., that, short of a label deal, he should just make an album independently.
“I see me and you are not on the same page. … It’s clear that you talk like a child!” he huffed and then hung up.
Public Image Ltd.
Where: Altar Bar, Strip.
When: 9 tonight.
Tickets: $33; www.ticketfly.com.
The punk icon ended up making that first PiL record in a decade, on its own label, in 2012 with “This Is PiL.” Now, Mr. Lydon and company have made another one, “What the World Needs Now …,” which has all the energy and aggression that the band had when he launched it in the early ’80s after the bloody demise of the Sex Pistols.
PiL is coming back to Pittsburgh for the first time in five years, playing Altar Bar tonight, so the 59-year-old Lydon is trying to play nice with the dreaded media to promote the tour. On pins and needles when talking to Mr. Lydon, I didn’t open up by asking him about doing a butter commercial, or why he was going to do that “Jesus Christ Superstar” tour, or whether the Pistols were more punk than Crass or whether Sid really killed Nancy.
None of that stuff. Instead, I said that “What the World Needs Now...” sounds like a vintage PiL album, which isn’t all that different from telling a 60-year-old woman that she still looks as good as she did when she was 30. You don’t expect her to smack you over the head with her purse.
It went like this.
I really like the new album. Much of it sounds like it could be an early PiL record. Do you take that as a good thing?
I disagree with you entirely, and of course that’s not a good thing! Hmmph.
I mean in the sense of it sounding young, hungry, crossing the line between punk and post-punk.
If you mean it’s high energy, yes, that’s exactly right. The way I run my life, I don’t take the easy way out. With me, it’s always 100 percent commitment. Even going to sleep requires a 100 percent commitment.
[No idea what that means, and I don’t care to explore it.] Maybe what I hear are certain chord progressions and guitar and bass sounds that were prevalent in that era.
God. I think you wasted your time and forgot to actually listen to what it is you’re supposed to be paying attention to. What is this: Are you trying to give me a music lesson or something? You’re way [expletive] off the mark, fella. You’re talking daft [expletive] to me. Chord progressions ... What?!
[Because there are moments where he actually croons like Bowie on this record … ] Would you say you’re more confident now as a singer than you’ve ever been?
Is there any point to me answering questions like that? I mean, you’ve predetermined what your assumptions are. Really, do you want me to just back you up or something? Really, [expletive]-O. What a nice time this is as an interview. You’re not going anywhere with me here, are you? … You might be the problem with the music business as it is today. These predetermined nonsenses and assumptions, I can’t be [expletive]-ed with ya.
Let me ask you this …
No, I know you’re wasting my time and I certainly don’t want to waste yours. You’re just down a dead end there. Dull as dishwater … [click! Dial tone...]
Hmm. Knowing from Facebook that a friend from another Pittsburgh outlet had gotten through the interview, I asked the publicist to try to get him back on the phone. He didn’t pick up, so that seemed like the end of the story. She suggested emailing a few more questions. Nothing came of that, not surprising. Then, a week later, she emailed at 9:30 p.m. asking about talking to him the next morning. Sure! But, would he remember the last one? “Just don’t remind him!” she said.
Because disguising my voice for 20 minutes was out of the question, I hoped he’d either forget, pretend it never happened or not care either way. She suggested not asking about the past, although everyone knows his past is far more interesting. The goal would be complete assumption/nonsense avoidance.
This time he was in Florida. Dull as dishwater, I asked him how things were in Florida. “Uh, the same as usual,” he said, dramatically. He says everything dramatically. Like he’s doing “Macbeth.” Punk “Macbeth.” Does he ever step out on the beach? (No idea why I was asking that and I cringed as the words came out.) “O-ccAsionally.”
On the more standard question of how the show’s going, he praised the race, creed, color and “sexual beliefs” of the crowds, saying, “It’s quite an achievement to see that combination of human possibility all in one hole and not hating each other.”
On how the new songs were being worked into the set, “It’s all PiL,” he said, “so it’s all very different from each other and all jolly good fun. Some songs are sadder than others, but they’re all poignant and relative to human experience. That might be the difference. We don’t just write songs for songs’ sake. They’re part of my life. I can only write from what I experience, and that I try to do as accurately as possible. And I think the audience knows that and respects that. Certainly, many of them know every single word. Sometimes better than I do.”
“Part of my life” ... “experience.” That opened the door for something meatier, like whether anger is still a driving force for him.
“It always was, emotionally, and it was the very substance I needed to use to regain my memories when I came out of a coma when I was young,” he said, addressing his near-fatal bout with spinal meningitis at 7. “It’s all in the last book, for anyone who’s interested. It took me four years to recover my memories fully, but anger is what the hospital recommended my parents use to not make my life spoiled or comfortable but to keep me on a constant edge so things would return. So, yeah, anger’s always there, but it’s a positive force. I never used it in violence or hate. I don’t have violence or hate in me.”
His memoirs describe a working-class upbringing that involved getting a job at 10 to help the struggling family, getting bullied at school and clashing with teachers — the things that would prime a kid for a career in punk rock, the things that punk rock singers have to go through, right?
“I don’t care what punk rock singers want,” he sneered. “I care for my life and doing things as accurately and as best as I possibly can. Why on Earth would I give a damn about an idiocy like a genre when I’ve spent my whole life avoiding categories?”
Talking about “Bettie Page,” a tribute to the “Queen of Pinups” on the new PiL record, his response was emblematic of the way he wraps positives in negatives, and vice versa. “She brought forth that the human body is nothing to be ashamed of, and that’s quite some time before we know it today, when the way most people treat their bodies they’ve got a lot to be ashamed of.”
The album’s lead track, “Double Trouble,” is some pure punk rock bliss that’s as much Pistols as PiL and was inspired by some bad plumbing, he revealed.
“[It’s] about an argument I had with my wife over the repair of a toilet. Quite literally, and I translated it into a song. It was quite a full-on argument at the time, and now my wife and I, when we listen to that song, we both burst out with laughter.
“What a knife’s edge a relationship can be,” he added, “and if taken too far, you can insult each other to the point of no return. That is what the song is trying to deal with: double trouble. You take it so far, but you must be able to recover from the brink, and Nora and I are very much like that. We’re very volatile,” he laughed. “There is always a resolve and there’s always a possibility, which we both love, of being able to laugh at ourselves and realize that it’s not worth being so serious over something so silly. And I should have just repaired the toilet in the first place, because, as you know, a woman is always right.”
Because it’s always fun to hear him rip on the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and some of the classic rock bands within it, I started to say that he was inducted into the hall, reluctantly, and ...
“I didn’t go a-tall!” he interrupted. “In my case this is a record industry that created nothing but problems for me, from my first band onward. And even as Public Image, I had to spend nearly two decades out there struggling to raise enough money to buy myself off those record labels. How on Earth am I gonna go cap in hand and say thanks to you, for anything?! And it’s all so corrupt. It’s a secret ballot and it doesn’t do anything for anybody in any way other than stroke their ego. And then they ask you to pay for privilege! You have to buy your own ticket to get in. What kind of craziness is that? That’s an insult.”
He holds the industry responsible for the blandness of ’80s rock, presumably at the major-label level (because the indie stuff was great), saying, “They handed everything over to the accounts department and creativity just ceased to exist. From there on in, it was just a cold indifference and a lack of investment in the future. So we ended up with very bland bands and anyone who had any creative idea was pushed to the side and passed off as too expensive or difficult to work with. And these were the monikers that applied to people like me.”
At the mention of Deep Purple being up for nomination, he said, “I know Sid liked ‘Fire on the Water’ or whatever that song was, but that’s about as far as it goes. That was before he became Vicious, ha ha.”
Mr. Lydon doesn’t have much use for bands of that ilk. “A lot of those bands were coming from a rhythm ’n’ blues background and there was a bit of ethnic forgery going on in all them. And, us, we did not like that too much. We formed our own sense of rhythm and tune and based it basically on English working-class music, rather than these progressive rock bands that were really fiddling around with Bo Diddley and the like and disguising it with volume. So we were seeing them as fake. That’s what punk was” — he said punk! — “a refreshing retake of our own culture and not trying to rip off something from the Deltas or the Mississippis.
“I never wanted to look like anyone else or sound like anyone else,” he added.
Thanked for his time after a more pleasant 20-minute interview with no acknowledgment of the first one, he said sweetly, “Please, may the road rise [referencing the classic 1986 PiL song “Rise”]. And let’s get as many people to come along and experience something truly good in music as opposed to all the hatred and bias and nonsense that seems to be very prevalent these days, as indeed they were way, way back in my early past.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg.
The full Q&A, with much more, can be found at www.post-gazette.com/popnoise.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.