Train already ran through here with the latest album, “Bulletproof Picasso,” but singer Pat Monahan assures fans that they did not get the full effect at the Star 100.7 holiday show in December.
“Those Christmas shows aren’t indicators of what you would do at a concert,” he says. “It’s a different animal, a different environment. You’re playing in front of people who just want to hear your five radio songs, and when you play an amphitheater, you’re surrounded by … half of them will be deeply involved with you, and half are peripherally involved, so you have to play your radio songs but you can dig a little deeper.”
Train
With: The Fray, Matt Nathanson.
Where: First Niagara Pavilion, Burgettstown.
When: 7 p.m. Tuesday.
Tickets: $25-$79.50; www.ticketmaster.com.
Yes, the peripherally involved concertgoer has become a more common animal, especially with people streaming music more these days rather than buying it and taking it home to a stereo system.
“When I think about music now, I feel sad for young people because they missed that part,” the singer says. “Like, kids watch YouTube to see new music. One of the arguments that musicians make about Spotify is they don’t make enough money from Spotify, but no one complains about YouTube. The youth of the world is watching YouTube for new music and YouTube doesn’t pay us [expletive]. But I don’t have a beef with anybody. Any way you get the music to people is what you should be trying to do, but I feel bad for young artists. If there won’t be money for them to make, they may not choose music. Even though it chooses you, you might fight it.”
The 46-year-old Erie native chose music when he was a teenager, singing in the Led Zeppelin cover band Rogues Gallery. In 1993, he moved to San Francisco and formed Train, a band that’s 1998 indie debut was very much in the Counting Crows/Wallflowers vein, and had a Top 20 hit with “Meet Virginia.”
“We had our first successful song when I was 28, so that’s a pretty late start, really, and it was kind of like an alternative song. ‘Meet Virginia’ was being played in dorms around the country, and that was cool. You wanted to be in dorms.”
Three years later, Train upped the ante with “Drops of Jupiter,” a major label record that scored a No. 5 hit with the title track. It took Train to a new level of popularity while wiping out whatever “alternative” cred it may have had.
“When ‘Drops of Jupiter’ came out, all those kids were like ‘[Expletive] these guys, they’re a pop band now,’” Mr. Monahan says. “We gained a lot of global respect, but the indie thing was gone. Immediately. Then, having to compete with that, it was like, ‘Oh boy, now I’m playing a different game. It’s not about “just make art.” It’s about “stay in the game.” ’ And so struggling with that and navigating is very brutal. You get your feelings hurt quite a lot.”
Train managed to stay in the game with the next album, producing a Top 20 hit on “My Private Nation” with “Calling All Angels,” but the fourth record, “For Me, It’s You,” didn’t have much interest for radio. After a three-year hiatus, which included a Monahan solo record, Train bounced back in a big way in 2009 with the No. 3 “Hey, Soul Sister,” a simple, poppy, blue-eyed soul single from “Save Me, San Francisco” written with Norwegian production duo Espionage. That success continued on the next album, “California 37,” with the clever hits “Drive By” and “50 Ways to Say Goodbye.”
Train was looking like a band that could churn out singles, but the Train frontman is still married to the album concept.
“A lot of people, they just wouldn’t bother making an album. It just doesn’t make sense really. Because we are the band we are and doing this for 20 years, we have to make albums because that’s what we do. Now, I realize, even though we wouldn’t do it, you could make a pretty [crappy] album as long as it has three good singles on it. But that’s like the worst thing we could do to our fans, who trust us to at least use every means we can to make the best work we can.”
On last year’s “Bulletproof Picasso,” Train worked with the Norwegian team again, along with writer-producer Butch Walker and others on the songs, which, lyrically, aim to be more direct and personal.
“I’ve been writing these words and melodies my whole career for Train, and I don’t want that to stop. If I have nothing to say, then we should probably stop saying things. So, what I wanted to do was get to the heart of my songwriting on this record, and I think I was able to do that, but it was brutally difficult, because I usually rely on like kitschy lyrics to overcome simple, meaningful lyrics, because those are really hard to do. This time I didn’t want to do that. This was a shift record for me, which was difficult, but I feel like I broke through something in myself so that now I can freely write the next record and I think it will be pretty powerful and have those hits on it that weren’t on this one.”
As for the odd phrase “Bulletproof Picasso,” he says it describes the frame of mind he believes an artist has to have.
“I was just writing that song about leaving Erie and going to San Francisco. You have to feel at some point that you are an indestructible artist, or you can’t make it.”
Over the years, Train has had several members depart, and with drummer Scott Underwood leaving last year, Mr. Monahan and guitarist Jimmy Stafford are the only ones who go back to 1994.
“It makes the dynamic better,” he says, “because when you start a band it’s like, ‘Who’s willing to get in the van with me — because we have no money and there’s a chance we’re wasting our time.’ And then as time goes on, there’s one alternative to people leaving the band: You END the band. But people wanted to keep being in the band and people kept wanting to see us, so we decided to keep the band going. It’s really up to fans to decide if we’re who they want, and I think this band sounds better than ever. When you get to choose musicians, then it’s like really a higher level.”
If the crowds do start to thin out, having had six Top 20 hits, Train has a guaranteed spot on nostalgia tours.
When I mention this to the singer, he says, “You sound like a manager because that’s what we talk about. If that happens, then you have to say, ‘Am I really willing to do this?’ Because, being a heritage band is really my worst nightmare. And it’s not that I don’t respect heritage bands. Journey and Foreigner and Styx all being out on a tour together sounds like a really fun night, but I don’t want to be any of those three bands. I’d rather sit in the crowd and watch them, but I don’t want to be them. Chris Martin is still doing great work, Adam Levine’s still on pop radio — all these people I feel like I want to compete with. I still want to be in that world. But if that stops, I’ll call you and you can manage me.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.