To Dave Matthews, having his band play an acoustic set to open the show last night at First Niagara Pavilion was a chance for fans to settle in.
“You still have time to get your hot dogs, and your pizza, and your beer,” he said to a half-empty amphitheater.
But as fans were shuffling to their seats, Dave Matthews Band was giving a dazzling stripped-down performance with more voltage than the electric set that followed.
The “Two Sets” tour kicked off again this May after a full slate of shows last summer. There are no openers; just quiet, authentic Dave followed by classic, rock n’ roll Dave.
At first, it wasn’t clear if the acoustic was the right fit for the venue. When the 48-year-old Matthews took the stage alone with just a guitar, he was met with quite the ovation, but his solo renditions of John Denver’s “Take Me To Tomorrow” and DMB’s “Butterfly” were met with distracting chatter.
He quickly overcame the bar atmosphere, though, with help from esteemed guitarist Tim Reynolds, who joined him for “Oh,” a cynical tribute to love from Matthews’ 2003 solo debut, “Some Devil.” Reynolds’ vibrant riffs high on the fret board accompanied Matthews’ soft chords and echoes of “The world is blowing up, the world is caving in.”
The rest of the band picked up their acoustic instruments – including an upright bass, which isn’t standard for DMB – for eight more songs, rounding out the hour-long opening set with some of the group’s biggest hits.
The fans, starting to fill in, roared at the first notes of “Two Step” and “Tripping Billies,” a pair of drum-heavy funk songs from DMB’s best selling album to date, “Crash.” The crowd happily chanted one of the band’s most cynical lines, “Drink and be merry, for tomorrow we die,” alerting everyone within a 10-mile radius that there was a Dave show at the Pavilion.
After a short intermission, the band returned for a 90-minute electric set that had plenty of potential from the start. In “Ants Marching,” a fan favorite from debut album “Under the Table and Dreaming” Matthews took the atmosphere from jazz club to rodeo, delivering an old-fashioned line dance to the tune of Boyd Tinsley’s violin.
But then, in an odd change of pace, Matthews serenaded his fans with “Black and Blue Bird,” a new tune the band debuted on Letterman in May, followed by a trio of slow songs that put him behind the piano.
For the first time, it was starting to feel like a marathon set. As DMB finished their 17-song electric set – which touched on nearly every album from their extensive catalog – the hits were few and far between, and so were the full-crowd chants that were frequent early in the evening.
That doesn’t mean the set was poorly performed, or that Dave and his gang are losing steam as the years go on. The performance was simply too long, and didn’t cater to the casual fan.
And as the show neared its third hour, the jazz improvisations that sounded so pulsating acoustically weren’t as special anymore.
Thankfully, Matthews loves Pittsburgh – “It’s a wonderful day in the neighborhood” were his first words to the crowd – so he’ll be back.
But next time, he should stick with one set.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1488. Twitter @julianrouth.
SETLIST
ACOUSTIC
“Take Me To Tomorrow” (John Denver cover)
“Butterfly”
“Oh”
“Snow Outside”
“Two Step”
“Satellite”
“So Damn Lucky”
“Where Are You Going”
“The Song That Jane Likes”
“Raven”
“Tripping Billies”
ELECTRIC
“#41”
“So Much To Say”
“Anyone Seen the Bridge”
“Too Much”
“Ants Marching”
“Black and Blue Bird”
“So Right”
“Mercy”
“Out of My Hands”
“Everyday”
“Squirm”
“Rooftop”
“Write a Song”
“Shake Me Like a Monkey”
Encore
“The Best of What’s Around”
“Pantala Naga Pampa”
“Rapunzel”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.