The Baseball Project managed to release two albums without an ode to Dock Ellis, but the "3rd" time is a charm.

The baseball-themed rock supergroup sings the praises of the late Pirates pitcher on its third album, titled "3rd," focusing not on his infamous LSD no-hitter but the 1974 game when he set out to hit as many Reds as possible.

The Baseball Project

Where: Club Cafe, South Side.

Advertise with us

When: 8 tonight.

Tickets: $25; www.clubcafelive.com.

"The Day Dock Went Hunting Heads" will most certainly be on the set list when indie-rock/power-pop all-stars return to Club Cafe tonight.

The Baseball Project, which debuted in 2008, consists of singer-guitarists Steve Wynn (Dream Syndicate, Steve Wynn and the Miracle Three) and Scott McCaughey (Young Fresh Fellows, Minus 5, R.E.M. touring member), bassist Mike Mills (R.E.M.), drummer Linda Pitmon (Mr. Wynn's wife and Miracle Three member), and R.E.M. guitarist Peter Buck, who will not be with them on this trip.

Along with the Dock song, 18-song "3rd" touches on the inner game of Hank Aaron ("They Don't Know Henry"); the rise and fall of Lenny Dykstra ("From Nails to Thumbtacks"); the sanctity of stats ("Box Scores"); the glory of the underdog ("They Are the Oakland A's"); and the older brother of Hall of Famer Robin Yount, Larry, whose MLB career ended the day it started with a bullpen injury ("Larry Yount"). There's also a Ramones-style version of "Take Me Out to the Ballgame."

Advertise with us

Mr. McCaughey, who has multiple baseball allegiances having grown up in the Bay Area as a Giants and A's fans and then also embracing the Mariners after many years in Seattle, talked to us about the project.

First of all, I saw that Young Fresh Fellows recently opened for The Replacements in Seattle and Portland. It was really a bummer they had to cancel here.

Yeah, I heard that. The shows were awesome. It was like old times but different. Not quite as insane. But the shows were amazing. They did a lot of different songs each night and it was just the right combination of super rocking and tight and fun and loose. It was really great. Not to make you feel bad or anything.

I saw that you're playing the Baseball Hall of Fame. Is that a first time?

We've played in Cooperstown a couple times at a brewery there, and we've done a tour of the Hall of the Fame, a behind the scenes tour. But this is the first time we'll play in the Hall of Fame. The mayor of Cooperstown is the one who made this happen. The last time we were there, he declared it The Baseball Project Day.

Advertise with us

Is this like the ultimate gig for The Baseball Project, or would it be playing a stadium?

I'll tell you next Sunday after it happens. It seems like it would be the ultimate gig, but you never know. It will be different for us because it will be more family- and all-ages oriented. We do a fair amount of that stuff, but, typically, we're in stinky rock clubs, or nice ones, like Club Cafe in Pittsburgh. It's hard to fit on that stage, and we have Josh Kantor with us playing keyboards. He's the organist from Fenway Park, so it will be even tighter than usual. One of us might be sitting in someone's lap at one of the front tables.

When you're playing to that family crowd, is there any censoring of the material?

We have to make a decision of whether "Ted [Expletive] Williams" is appropriate to play. We've played it a few times, censoring it, and we've left it out at other times, for a nice thing to do. We've also played it at free outdoor shows, just said the hell with it. We might not do it at the Hall of Fame. We played it last night and there was a 10-year-old kid up front. His dad was like, "Don't worry about it." We'll be sensitive to it, or the people at the Hall of Fame will just be like, "Do not play that song."

What is the challenge as a songwriter of telling these baseball stories?

Advertise with us

I would say that you don't want to get too geeky about it, but that actually doesn't apply to us because we get completely geeky. We try to make sure they're enjoyable to listen to, but we can do ones that are more intelligible to your typical fan and ones where you have to be a real hardcore maniac to get some of the stuff. And it is about storytelling and baseball, but we also feel like the songs are just good songs and even if you're not a big baseball fan, you can rock out to them.

Do you get people who come who aren't aware of your other bands?

There are people who come because they've heard about it and they're coming from the baseball side of things. We do get a lot of people showing up at the shows wearing their gear. Last night there was someone wearing a Minus 5 and Young Fresh Fellows shirt, but a lot of people wear the jerseys of their team. It's really cool actually to look out and see that.

So, the Dock Ellis song. How did you stumble upon that story?

Obviously, I had hear the LSD story. We were all well aware of that and how amazing it was, and we were fans of the animated thing on YouTube. People would say, "You have to write about the LSD thing." We were like, "We know, but we know three people who have written songs about that already." I was doing research on him and read about the game where he went out and tried to bean all the Reds. And that was just as amazing. That couldn't happen now. There's just no way. He would have been kicked out of the game by the second pitch. He was really trying to fire up his team, and it seemed to have worked, because they were having a weak year and they ended up winning the division. Maybe the rest of the Pirates were just scared watching that: "We better get off our asses and win some games!"

Advertise with us

What kind of reaction to the project has been the most rewarding to you?

When we heard from people who the songs were about, or the songs were about their loved ones. Like Harvey Haddix's widow got in touch with us and told us how much the song meant to her and that Harvey would have loved it. That's another Pirates connection. We heard from the wife of Larry Yount and they invited us to have dinner with them any time we're in Arizona. They sent out a Christmas card that uses the song. A lot of little bits of feedback that have been gratifying.

When you write about real people you never know what kind of reaction you'll get.

That's true, and some of the songs we've written we probably don't want to hear from the people. There are certain ones we'd be better off if they don't ever hear them. We write what we write. Some songs are flattering, some are more close to scathing. We try to balance it. Hopefully, it's obvious that it's all about how much we love the game and we love baseball and we love rock 'n' roll. That's the whole story of this band.