Editor’s note, May 5: Tonight’s Replacements concert at Stage AE was postponed. The preview below was written and published before this morning’s postponement announcement.
It's not like there wasn't great music in the early '80s because there was lots, but a certain slickness was setting in.
The energy was draining from the great wave of '70s punk, leaving behind a slew of synth bands and the polished likes of U2 and the Police. Hardcore was starting to rage in small pockets with Black Flag, Bad Brains and that ilk, but what we needed were just some good thrashy punk bands.
The Replacement
With: The Gotobeds.
Where: Stage AE, North Shore.
When: 7 p.m. doors Tuesday.
Tickets: Sold out.
Help was on the way in the form of X, Violent Femmes, R.E.M. (always more raw live), Meat Puppets and The Replacements. None of those bands took more pride in being sloppy than The Replacements, who peaked from 1984 to 1989, split in 1991 and will play their first show here in 24 years tonight at Stage AE.
The 'Mats first reared their heads in 1981 with "Sorry Ma, Forgot to Take Out the Trash," playing fast and loud but a bit too bratty and vulnerable for the rigid hardcore scene. Second album "Hootenanny," following the EP "Stink,“ started with a ramshackle honky-tonk song and jumped around through styles, tempos and emotions, revealing that The Replacements were not going to adhere to any one aesthetic. If they weren't kicked out of the hardcore club yet, the tender "Within Your Reach" was enough to do it.
The Replacements remained somewhat under the radar until 1984's "Let It Be," deemed to be a coming-of-age masterpiece and sitting at No. 239 on the Rolling Stone list of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time. Along with being a sonic upgrade, "Let It Be" was singer Paul Westerberg coming into his own, balancing the old thrashiness ("Tommy Gets his Tonsils Out") with jangly pop ("I Will Dare"), visceral ballads ("Unsatisfied") and a kick-ass Kiss cover ("Black Diamond").
The Replacements — with guitarist Bob Stinson (who died in ’85), brother Tommy on bass and drummer Chris Mars — also built a reputation as a live band teetering on the edge. The band belongs in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, and it was nominated in 2013, but short of that, The Replacements take the prize for Band Most Likely to Start a Song it Couldn't Finish. Alcohol was only partly to blame.
Pittsburgh got its first look on Oct. 10, 1984, at the Syria Mosque Ballroom, a week after "Let It Be” dropped. The 'Mats set was a quick opener for the more accomplished X, but I remember a highlight being the unreleased "Nowhere is My Home." The PG reviewer, for some reason, described it as sounding like “Hank Williams in the Velvet Underground.”
Graffiti was packed on a steamy August night in 1987 for the band's return on the "Pleased to Meet Me" tour where they mixed the best of The Replacements with pieces of "Honky Tonk Woman," "Hello Dolly," Georgia Satellites’ "Battleship Chains" and Emerson Lake & Palmer’s "Lucky Man."
The band's biggest gig here was a shining example of The Replacements as lovable screwups. They opened for Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers at the Palumbo in August 1989 (after playing the Mosque ballroom again in March) and completely tanked it, in part by launching more promises, like “Happy” and "Train Kept A- Rolling," they couldn't keep. They ended up dropping off the Petty tour soon after.
"We just for some reason thought that we could win his fans over easily," Mr. Westerberg told the PG in 1991. "But it was very difficult, and we had to really work hard to get any response."
In 1990, the tepid "All Shook Down" started as a Westerberg solo album, and The Replacements were in fact replaced by various guests on many songs. So the writing was on the wall that the ’91 tour, which played Metropol, might be it for a while. And it was.
The frontman issued numerous solo albums, never turning into Sting or anything, and Tommy Stinson has been slumming it with the Guns 'N Roses cover band led by Axl Rose. When former guitarist Slim Dunlap suffered a stroke in 2012, they recorded the benefit EP "Songs for Slim" in 2012 and then in 2013 reunited at Riot Fest in Toronto with Dave Minehan (The Neighborhoods) and drummer Josh Freese (Vandals, A Perfect Circle, NIN).
The Replacements have been active ever since, playing a Coachella set last year (that didn't pan out so well), touring, recording new material and releasing the boxed set “The Complete Studio Albums 1981-1990.”
“As long as we don’t have any conflicts scheduling-wise and we’re still having fun and not killing each other, it’s totally good,” Mr. Stinson told Gary Graff. “Both Paul and I needed to kind of do this together for the same reasons. It was more an aligning of the planets and sort of needing to get out and have a little fun with it again.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576; Twitter: @scottmervis_pg





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.