The sophomore album looms as a big mountain to climb for a young band, particularly when the first one exceeded expectations, and that goes double when people are throwing around labels like “the new Radiohead.”

That was the scenario for Alt-J, the British quartet that won the prestigious Mercury Prize in England and earned a Grammy nomination for “An Awesome Wave,” a 2012 debut that was a delightfully out-there collection of genre-mashing electro-rock with a quirky singer who would not be confused with Adam Levine.

Alt-J

With: Tycho.

Advertise with us

Where: Benedum Center, Downtown.

When: 8 tonight.

Tickets: Sold out.

“It’s very flattering to be compared to a band like that,” keyboardist Gus Unger-Hamilton says of the Radiohead comparison. “At the same time, it got around so much that I think people were thinking we were going around saying, ‘We’re the new Radiohead,’ which obviously we never did. I guess it makes people more comfortable if they can make a comparison like that. People find it hard to talk about music without making comparisons so it makes it happy and fine, but we never courted that hype.”

“An Awesome Wave,” which had a slow build to success, was conceived in their Leeds University dorm rooms and recorded at Iguana Studio in London. For “This Is All Yours” they wanted a similar approach, minus the dorm rooms, of course.

Advertise with us

“It was important to us that we felt like the same people making another album,” the keyboardist says. “We didn’t want to go the route of making it in a big fancy studio. We decided to do it in the same studio in London which is kind of small, unfancy studio and we found a room, a place to write as well, in London which felt like an apartment that we could hang out in and have all our gear there. So we wanted to make it relaxed and kind of DIY like the first album.”

They emerged with a satisfying sophomore album that All Music described as being “somewhere in between the autumnal and apocalyptic” for all its sonic shifts between ambient and thumping.

In its evisceration of the album, Pitchfork seized upon the “facepalm rhyming” of singer Joe Newman, pinpointing lyrics from “Every Other Freckle: “Turn you inside out and lick you like a crisp packet” and “I’m gonna bed you like a cat beds into a beanbag.”

“I thought they were really good,” Mr. Hamilton-Unger says. “I think they’re really funny. He comes up with some really smart lyrics.”

And Alt-J supplemented those with a much-talked-about Miley Cyrus sample that has her singing “I’m a female rebel” on “Hunger of the Pine.”

Advertise with us

Oasis guitarist Noel Gallagher, whose pastime is slagging on other bands, can be counted as a fan of the new song “Left Hand Free.” But that might be the extent of it.

“Alt-J can [expletive] right off as far as I’m concerned,” he told NME recently. “It’s a great tune, and I paid 79 pence for it, but I am in no way a fan of Alt-J.” Asked why, he said, “One of them’s got a moustache, and that’s unacceptable.”

The moustached one is Mr. Hamilton-Unger, who doesn’t want to talk about it.

“I don’t want to further any of that crap,” he says. “I’m not interested in flinging mud back and forth between some old guy and us. I don’t find it very interesting.”

He prefers to focus on this tour that stops at the sold-out Benedum tonight and heads toward Coachella next weekend, where he’s excited to be playing on the same day as Jack White. Alt-J’s debut here, at Mr. Smalls in 2013, was solid musically but static as a performance. There should be some relief for the shy band in the bigger budget theater show.

Advertise with us

“We have a bigger production now in terms of lights, which is nice, because we never felt confident with our live show,” the keyboardist says. “We’ve always seen our albums as backing our live show, if you see what I mean. Now that we have really good lights and production, I think we feel more like the live show is kind of living up to the album.”

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg.