Unlike the Oscars, the Grammys have had a pretty extensive credibility problem.
Exhibit A is the list of legendary artists who would ascend to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame — Bob Dylan, Jimi Hendrix, the Rolling Stones, Led Zeppelin, Bob Marley and Elvis Costello, among them — without winning a single Grammy in their prime, while the winner’s circle included the Starland Vocal Band, Christopher Cross, Toto and Milli Vanilli.
Grammy Awards
When: 8 p.m. Sunday on CBS.
That’s just part of the reason the performances, not the actual handing out of awards, came to dominate the three-plus hours of airtime.
On Sunday night, the 57th annual Grammy Awards from Los Angeles will feature performances by AC/DC, Eric Church, Ariana Grande, Miranda Lambert, Madonna, Ed Sheeran, Sam Smith, Usher and Pharrell Williams, plus the following pairings: Rihanna/Paul McCartney/Kanye West, Common/John Legend, Tony Bennett/Lady Gaga, Hozier/Annie Lennox, Jessie J/Tom Jones and Adam Levine/Gwen Stefani.
Read More
That represents a broad age range, but the nominees in the top four categories skew much younger. This time, Beck is the old man in the group at 44 and Pharrell Williams, at 41, is the only other nominee over 40. Within the last decade, Herbie Hancock and Robert Plant both won in their 60s.
Dominating the top categories is a 25-and-under movement of Sam Smith, Ed Sheeran, Meghan Trainor, Iggy Azalea, Hozier and industry veteran Taylor Swift certain to pull in a young demographic. It should make for a pretty poppy night at the Staples Center, and one that will have music geeks and other more seasoned fans doing their fair share of eye rolling.
If you’re tuning in, here are some of the main storylines:
1. BACK IN BLACK
AC/DC never won a Grammy back when the band was a raw nerve in the late ’70s, largely because there was no category for hard rock performance until 1989, and bands like AC/DC just didn’t compete with the Paul Simons and Stevie Wonders of the world for the main categories. AC/DC got its first Grammy nomination in 1989 (for “Blow Up Your Video”) and won in 2010 for hard rock performance for “War Machine.” On Sunday, the band will make its Grammy debut, a few months after releasing “Rock or Bust,” a 15th album that’s coincided with troubled times for the Aussies. Guitarist Malcolm Young, suffering from dementia, left the band in September, replaced by his nephew, Stevie Young. In November, drummer Phil Rudd was arrested on multiple charges, including trying to procure a murder (since dropped) and drug possession. He is expected to be replaced for this show and for the tour, news of which has fans on the edge of their seats.
2. STAY WITH SAM?
British singer Sam Smith claimed he never heard Tom Petty’s “Won’t Back Down” before co-writing his breakout hit “Stay With Me,” and I guess we can believe him based on the fact that he lists his influences as Adele, Amy Winehouse, Lady Gaga, Beyonce, Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey. That’s a lot of ladies. And nothing close to Tom Petty. He’s intimately familiar with Mr. Petty now because 12.5 percent of the royalties from “Stay With Me” are now going to the American rocker in an out-of-court settlement over the songs’ melodic similarities. Mr. Smith is tied with Beyonce and Pharrell for a leading six nominations, including record, song and pop solo performance for “Stay With Me.” The voting closed Jan. 16, nine days before news of the settlement, so presumably it won’t affect the outcome. Mr. Petty and Jeff Lynne (of ELO) would not receive a Grammy, just a certificate, if the song wins. If young Sam wins three Grammys he will have tied Hall of Famer Petty’s career total.
3. ALBUM OF THE YEAR
At the ceremony in 2010, Beyonce had already chalked up five awards for “I Am ... Sasha Fierce” and looked like she would cap off the evening with album of the year until Taylor Swift swooped in with a “Fearless” win. Beyonce has another shot at her first album of the year win with her self-titled record, which was released way back in December 2013 (Grammy eligibility goes from Oct. 1, 2013 to Sept. 30, 2014, just to confuse people).
It will be the first album win for any of the five nominees — Pharrell Williams, Beck, Ed Sheeran and Sam Smith. Using the Metacritic standard, only two of the albums earned stellar reviews: Beyonce an 85, Beck an 81 (out of 100). The other three all ranked in the 60s. On the Village Voice’s Pazz and Jop Poll, a survey of the nation’s critics, Beyonce placed No. 4 in 2014 and Beck No. 16 this year. None of the other albums ranked in the top 75.
Artists who can complain of being snubbed — based on their top 10 P&J rankings —include The War on Drugs (“Lost in the Dream”), St. Vincent (“St. Vincent”), FKA Twigs (“LP1”) and even Taylor Swift (“1989”).
4. TOUCHY RAP DILEMMA
If Iggy Azalea wins best rap album, expect the Internet to explode — even more than last year. If you recall, white guys Macklemore and Ryan Lewis won for “The Heist,” prompting Macklemore to message Kendrick Lamar, “You got robbed. I wanted you to win. You should have.”
This year, we have another racial situation, with poppy white female rapper from Wales and five-time rap album winner Eminem going up against respected elder Common, plus Wiz Khalifa, Childish Gambino and Schoolboy Q. As Billboard noted, the Macklemore win didn’t cause that big of a stir because that album was actually considered to be good. “The same will not be true, however, if Iggy Azalea wins this year. Many in the hip-hop community are outraged with Azalea’s apparent level of tone-deafness regarding criticisms of cultural appropriation.”
The bad news is, the boys are likely to split the vote, giving her the Grammy.
5. MIRANDA VS. ERIC
Eric Church released one of the most acclaimed albums of the year, country or otherwise. And then Miranda Lambert came along and did the same. Now, it’s his gritty “Outsiders” against her sassy “Platinum” for best country album, best country song and best country solo performance. Ms. Lambert took the album award at the CMAs, making her the favorite here as well. Mr. Church should have won for “Springsteen” back in 2013. We’ll see if the expectant dad will be able to show the kids his first Grammy.
6. THE FIRST TIMERS
Sam Smith, Meghan Trainor and Iggy Azalea are among the youngsters vying for first Grammys in the top categories. Dig a little deeper down and you find a number of industry veterans also looking for their first win: Ryan Adams and Arctic Monkeys (in rock), Mastodon and Anthrax (metal), Common (rap), and John Hiatt and Jesse Winchester (roots, Americana). A pair of sentimental choices are Johnny Winter, who died last year (blues album) and Sharon Jones & The Dap-Kings, led by a singer rebounding from cancer (R&B album). Most of these will be handed out in the pre-ceremony, where virtually no one shows up.
7. WIZ AND THE PSO
This is the fourth straight year Wiz Khalifa has been nominated, but so far he has had stiff competition from Jay-Z, Kanye West, Macklemore, etc. This time, his “Blacc Hollywood” meets Iggy and Eminem for rap album, and for rap song, “We Dem Boyz” faces a murderer’s row of Kanye, Kendrick, Drake and Nicki Minaj. Sadly, he’s a long shot to win his first.
Four-time winner Christina Aguilera is another long shot vying for pop duo/group performance (“Say Something” with A Great Big World) against Iggy, Coldplay, Katy Perry, etc.
The Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, which last won a Grammy in 1992, under Manfred Honeck, is up for best orchestral performance for Dvorak Symphony No. 8 and Janacek: Symphonic Suite From Jenufa. Competition is the St. Louis Symphony Orchestra, the Seattle Symphony, the Berlin Philharmonic and Atlanta Symphony Orchestra. No idea here.
8. HIM AGAIN
Good thing the Grammys are in Los Angeles County. Chris Brown’s probation was revoked this month after the temperamental R&B singer traveled without permission to a club show in San Jose, where five people were shot. He has also failed to complete his community service on time, causing the postponement of his tour. Since assaulting his then-girlfriend Rihanna on the way to the 2009 Grammys, he has won one of the seven he has been nominated for (R&B album in 2012). He’s up for three, including urban contemporary album for “X.”
9. WILL PANDORA PICKS PAN OUT?
Streaming service Pandora blogged its Grammy predictions, noting that they were based on listening patterns throughout the year. The idea being that the most popular stuff will win out. Pandora splits the vote in the top categories, giving album to Sam Smith’s “In the Lonely Hour,” record to Sia’s “Chandelier,” song to Megan Trainor’s “All About That Bass” and best new artist to Iggy Azalea. We can consider that the popular vote.
10. REZNOR’S EDGE
Best score soundtrack for visual media is not a thrilling category, but life is always a little dangerous when Trent Reznor is involved. The Mercer native and Nine Inch Nails frontman, along with partner Atticus Ross, won the Grammy in 2012 for “The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo” and the Oscar in 2011 for “The Social Network.”
In November, the NIN singer-guitarist revealed his Oscar/Grammy preference in an interview with the Hollywood Reporter: “When the Oscar [nomination] came up [for ‘The Social Network’], it felt very different. I can’t tell if that’s because I’m older or it felt like it’s coming from a more sincere pedigree.”
This time, Reznor/Atticus got a Grammy nom and an Oscar snub for “Gone Girl.” As part of the final jam that got cut off last year, Mr. Reznor tweeted a “$#&@ you” to the Grammys. On Sunday night, we’ll keep an eye on his feed ...
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.