Before the Black Keys became one of the most popular contemporary bands, they were just a little ol' twosome out of Akron that dug old Southern blues and were celebrated in the indie scene for their primal rock sound.
With all that hard work leading to a much wider audience and an unlikely leap to arenas, like the show at Consol Energy Center on Saturday, there's obviously been some Black Keys pushback in the indie scene.
The Black Keys
With: Cage The Elephant
Where: Consol Energy Center
When: 8 p.m. Saturday.
Tickets: $35-$75; www.ticketmaster.com
"I sensed pushback in 2004, or something, when we had a song in a Nissan commercial," drummer Patrick Carney says in a phone interview. "There's always going to be pushback. When I was younger it would [tick] me off, but it's just the way certain people like to think, you know."
With each album, the Black Keys, fronted by singer-guitarist Dan Auerbach, have become a more polished unit and starting with the "Brothers" tour have expanded beyond a duo to replicate the more fleshed-out studio sound. The drummer thinks some of the original fans have stayed on board, though.
"There were very few of those people and I see them still coming to the shows. People's taste changes, the type of music people want to make changes, all that kind of stuff. That's the bottom line of the indie-rock thing is a lot of people will get mad at a band for evolving or exploring different type of sounds or becoming popular, or whatever it may be. Those are all things in the natural order of the universe, which is constant flux. There are certain people who want it to be 1987 -- like indie rock, fanzines and mail-order records, or whatever. They romanticize a period of time, but everybody changes, everything is different."
Patrick Carney on fan loyalty:
"When we started the band, we were one of the last bands probably to start touring and stuff without the Internet really playing any kind of a significant role. [It was] still record store clerks and print media. It was the reason we started getting popular. Now, anybody can be a critic. It's much harder to stick with a band and embrace the changes. It can pay dividends if you do it, you know. I know when I first heard Modest Mouse's 'The Moon in Antarctica,' whe0n it came out, when I was 20, it was drastically different than the first two LPs, but I loved the band so much I sat there and stuck with it, and to this day, every single one of their records I love."
The aptly titled new album "Turn Blue" is a whole other shade for the Black Keys, moving at a slower, moodier and more soulful pace, starting with "Weight of Love," which sounds like its launching a new Pink Floyd record.
It was deep into the exhausting "El Camino" tour that they started the process in Benton Harbor, Mich., in January 2013.
"We basically recorded a whole record and we canned it," Mr. Carney says. "We just put everything on hold for a while and went to LA and started another record from scratch, because Dan was going through a divorce and he had some personal stuff going, so he just wanted to take the time to finish our touring, so we ended up going to LA."
Those punchy rockers in the "El Camino" mode were shelved in favor of the more textural approach they hit upon at Sunset Sound studio in Hollywood that July.
"It was the first time we were ever in a legendary studio that hadn't really been touched, gear wise," the drummer says. "We went to Muscle Shoals before, but when we went there, none of the gear was original. This time, the desk that is in Studio 2 has been there for the past like 35 years. There's a certain type of hi-fi sound that I don't think Dan and I ever [had]. I think we had been looking for it, but I don't think we ever found it until we made a record in that room. There's a lot of rich harmonics and it saturates in a way that is not lo fi, but BIG lo fi. That was kind of blowing our minds."
They first worked with producer Brian "Danger Mouse" Burton on 2007's "Attack & Release" -- "he did teach us a lot of stuff and he showed us new methods of working," Mr. Carney says -- but the partnership has intensified with each of the four consecutive records to the point where he is practically a third member.
"It's been more of a super-collaborative effort," he says. "We'll go in with nothing basically and all three of us will write it together and produce it together. The most important thing he's ever taught us is you can't shoot down an idea until you try it. I think it's the most important lesson for any band. Obviously, there's a fine line there because you can have people coming up with just totally idiotic ideas and wanting to execute them all day, which can result in a kind of 'Chinese Democracy'-type of situation."
When he wasn't working on the album, the out-spoken Black Keys drummer found himself in the midst of a few flare-ups with other celebs. Asked outside the Grammys last year what he thought of Justin Bieber being snubbed, he said, "Grammys are for music, not for the money, and he's making a lot of money. He should be happy." It prompted the pop star to tweet that Mr. Carney should be "slapped" it and also inflamed some of his 40 million Beliebers on Twitter.
This spring, Jack White told Rolling Stone, "I'll hear TV commercials where the music's ripping off sounds of mine, to the point I think it's me. Half the time, it's the Black Keys." In the Black Keys' RS feature, Mr. Carney shot back that the former White Stripe "obviously sounds like an [a-hole]."
"I don't really like that kind of attention, but at the same time, I didn't really do anything," Mr. Carney says. "I just spoke my mind.
"It goes deeper than this," he adds. "I mean, you get on a website like Gawker, and a website like that exists because people go online and they will click on [stuff] that is controversial or mean or intimating a deeper conspiracy than exists. I think that's the way humans are. They're nosy, they want to assume [stuff]. I'm like that, everyone's like that. But when you get caught up in one of those controversies and there's nothing at all behind it, just a bunch of [BS], it puts everything in perspective how much [garbage] everyone is consuming every day that is either fabricated or completely boring."
He hopes to keep the focus on the "Turn Blue" tour, which started last week in Columbus. On the last run, when they performed here with Flaming Lips, the Black Keys played on a stylized stage decked out with vintage-looking equipment.
This time, he says, they've had their light designer work up some different things.
"When it comes to the concert experience, we trust the people we work with to run some things by us. We trust them to know what to do, because I've never gone to a concert and really paid attention to the lights. I think Dan and I pay more attention to the way things are sounding, what songs to play and things like that. When we go and play a big arena, we approach it the same way as if we were playing a 1,000-seat room or a 500-seat room. We want it to feel as similar as that as possible for us on stage."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.