The other night at the Petersen Events Center, pop tart Ariana Grande brought a chandelier -- a flying one that she rode above the stage.

"I brought my living room with me," Sarah McLachlan said brightly, a few songs into her show at the Benedum Center on Wednesday night. Her fluffy red couch never went up in the air. It was there to make Ms. McLachlan and her fans -- especially a chosen few -- feel more at home.

This was a full, long evening with Sarah, the Canadian folk-pop diva whose soul-baring music touches her listeners in deeper places than most. It only makes sense that this theater tour be the ultimate touchy-feely experience, and so fans who took to social media to describe how they "shine" -- her new album is "Shine On" -- were invited on stage for hugs, selfies, to chit-chat with the 47-year-old singer and sort of un-build the mystery. The rest of us were able to scribble down our questions at the merch table.

She was asked what she did in Pittsburgh all afternoon (went to the Andy Warhol Museum with her daughters), her dream duet (Billie Holiday), her first concert (Twisted Sister and Iron Maiden!) and what color does she radiate (after much thought, she said chartreuse -- I side with the woman who hollered purple).

Advertise with us

Because it was a long, pack-a-snack kind of show, there was still time to do 24 songs before 11 o'clock.

From the first notes of the first song, the new-album opener "In Your Shoes," it was evident that her years of musical inactivity -- she's been a busy mom -- have done no harm to her gorgeous instrument and, in fact, it may have helped. It is a wonder. "The depressing love song," she said at one point, is her "happy place," and there was no shortage of those throughout the evening with "Heart Broken," "Fallen," "Adia," "I Will Remember You," on and on.

Even the one about finding new love, "Brink of Destruction," seemed pretty melancholy. Emphasis here is on pretty because everything she does is pretty. The stage, with all its rich colors and dangling lights, was pretty too. And she looked as pretty as ever in a black tank top and tight faux leather pants.

Along with putting the "art" in heartbreak, she can strap on Telecaster and rock those songs that go boldly into love: "Fumbling Towards Ecstasy," "Sweet Surrender" and breathtaking favorite "Possession," with a held note that was like fireworks. Her four-piece band had just the right tender touch for her songs and only a few times did it flash elements of Twisted Sister (Peter Stroud's solo on "Witness").

Bringing up more couch sitters for the second set may have tried the patience of some fans (raises hand), but she regained the lost momentum with the last eight songs, which included the stunning and potentially chandelier-shattering "Fear" (yes, she could sing opera), the moving "Angel" (interrupted by a weird disturbance in the theater) and "Ice Cream," a cool sensual treat that was coming whether or not that annoying woman screamed for it all night. Also in the encore was the motherly "Beautiful Girl," a touching companion piece to the earlier loving tribute "Song for My Father."

Advertise with us

Believe me when I say I don't want to hear another bittersweet piano ballad for at least a week, but trust me that Sarah McLachlan's return to Pittsburgh was -- no surprise -- a beauty.

​Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette​.com; 412-263-2576; Twitter: @scottmervis_pg

​Set 1​

​In Your Shoes

Building a Mystery

Advertise with us

Adia

Answer

Broken Heart

Fallen

World on Fire

Advertise with us

Loving You Is Easy

Monsters

Stupid

Set 2:

Song for My Father

Advertise with us

I Will Remember You

Brink of Destruction

Elsewhere

Hold On

Fumbling Towards Ecstasy

Advertise with us

Witness

Fear

Sweet Surrender

Possession

Encore:

Advertise with us

Angel

Beautiful Girl

Ice Cream

The Sound That Love Makes​