Early in his set Tuesday night at the Petersen Events Center, Chris Daughtry addressed the crowd, saying, "As Matt Nathanson noted, we usually carry pyro and rocket ships. Tonight it's just [us] givin' it to y'all raw."

To which a guy near me yelled, "We want the pyro!"

Really, it could have only helped.

Most concerts presented by pop radio stations are high-production tours that come loaded not only with pyro but eye-popping light shows, costume changes, video screens, dancers and tricked-out stages.

Advertise with us

Star 100.7's "O Starry Night 2," being a holiday radio gig, had none of the above, putting all the emphasis, for better or worse. on the songs and the stars.

Last year, it was the Backstreet Boys and Avril Lavigne (who would later tour together), The Fray, Gavin DeGraw, etc. This time, taking the headlining slots on an overly long four-plus-hour bill, to a mostly un-energized crowd, were well-traveled mainstream rockers Train and Daughtry.

Mr. Nathanson, whom we've seen on country bills in Burgettstown, opened in promising fashion with a spunky duo set that accented his witty songwriting, like the one about having a crush on the girl in the "Kinks Shirt." Loved it!

Christina Perri, just in this building to open for Demi Lovato, offered the kind of nice singer-songwriter set perfectly suited for Sarah McLachlan and the gang at Lilith Fair. The big-voiced singer soared to the rafters sitting solo at the piano of "Jar of Hearts" and "Human" and got the full band treatment for the dream-pop of "A Thousand Years."

Things bogged down big time in the middle slot, where Stage AE summer regulars O.A.R. suffered from a muddy, bass-heavy sound mix and also from being a rather generic-sounding and visually unexciting pop-rock band. Most of the ones that make it pop radio are. A lot of the songs -- "Love and Memories," "Peace," "Favorite Song," among them -- never rose much above the level of pleasant, and the white-funk jam ones were just annoying.

Advertise with us

Daughtry had the benefit of better sound and a more formidable frontman with big pipes, that being Chris Daughtry, who proved his mettle on Season 5 of "American Idol." His sit-down unplugged set (with two band members) stood out and hit more of an emotional chord with the crowd with the post-grunge catchiness of "Over You," "It's Not Over," troop-tribute anthem "Home" and the newer, Train-like "Waiting for Superman." He also made the wise choice of actually playing a Christmas song, and it was a good one in Elvis' "Blue Christmas" with twangy vocals and slide guitar.

Erie native Pat Monahan is going to have his hands full when he gets older because those Train songs are way high, a challenge even now for his 45-year-old voice. He got up there on most of them, after warming up with "Cadillac, Cadillac" and "50 Ways to Say Goodbye."

With back lighting, more sonic oomph and sing-songy hits, Train made "O Starry Night 2" feel more like a big concert. The veteran band mixed songs from its new album, "Bulletproof Picasso," with recent poppy hits "Hey, Soul Sister" and "Drive By" (sparking sing-alongs) and old fave "Drops of Jupiter" as the finale. It added some of its own holiday cheer with the peppy "Shake Up Christmas."

Some of the biggest cheers of the night came from the Star team's announcements of Chris Jamison making it to the finals of "The Voice" and thanking Pittsburgh for its support.