Warning: Walking into D and E Collectibles in Sharpsburg may cause serious nostalgia.

Open the door to the shop, and you’re greeted by rows upon rows of G.I. Joes, Hot Wheels and other childhood staples.

“The thing that happens at least once a day here is someone walks in and says, ‘I remember I had this when I was a kid,’ ” said store Manager Hunter Johnston. “It’s a little bit like memory lane in here.”

Take a left on memory lane into the collectible toy shop’s second room, and you’ll find shelves dedicated to “Star Wars” — with action figures depicting characters ranging from Darth Vader to those only the most serious fan could identify — WWE, Marvel and more.

Advertise with us

“If you’re into anything to do with pop culture, we will find an item for you,” Johnston said.

The store is just one of many local options for holiday shoppers to buy unique, collectible gifts that can carry meaning beyond the run-of-the-mill Amazon order. From sports memorabilia to antiques to all things pop culture, these gifts tap into whatever your loved ones love.

Just up the road, about six minutes north of D and E, is Pop Culture Comics, a collectibles shop that places a greater focus on comic books.

“What makes this place unique for people shopping is that they can find something that ties you to your childhood, to your passion,” said Pop Culture Comics owner Ken Rudisill III.

Perusing the aisles of these stores is an experience in and of itself.

Advertise with us

Wexford General Store Antiques, with its eclectic collection of all things old, is a popular first date spot, Manager Josh Marino said.

“You can easily spend several hours there,” he said, and it’s easy to see why: Every turn uncovers new treasures, from art to antique furniture, vintage clothes to knickknacks of every sort.

As the world becomes increasingly digital, tangible gifts can take on even more value. Steel City Collectibles has seen a boom of interest in its trading cards, for sports, video games and more.

“Anything physical is making a comeback,” said Sam Smerkol, the manager for Steel City’s retail store in White Oak.

People are even clamoring to buy old ticket stubs, a relic of the past in the age of digital admissions.

Advertise with us

“That’s something that, just five years ago, you couldn’t imagine not existing,” Smerkol said. “If you want to remember that concert you went to with your dad 12 years ago, you might pay as much as you paid for that ticket to buy just a stub from that event.”

If worn pieces of paper don’t pique your interest, there are plenty of other collectible options that might. Here are some potential holiday gift ideas from each of these four local stores. But don’t forget there are others in the region, including Sports World Specialties in Downtown, Eide’s Entertainment in the Strip District and more.

(Note: The Post-Gazette visited these stores in early October. Prices and selection are subject to change).

D and E Collectibles

D and E likes to say it’s a collectible toy shop that specializes in action figures, but the assorted figurines are not your typical big-box store fare. 

Employees scour the internet and even people’s basements to find vintage items, many dating back to the 1960s and ’70s.

Advertise with us

Possible gifts at D and E range from expensive jawdroppers to low-cost stocking stuffers. On a sunny October morning, a wrestling fan could buy signed WWE belts ranging from about $250 to $550, depending on the wrestler. Or they could purchase one of the many action figures for around $10 to $20.

For “Star Wars” fans of all generations, a fancy Darth Vader helmet for about $150 sat alongside simple action figures starting at around $5.

Gifts don’t have to be so genre-specific. D and E has a wall full of Funko Pops depicting characters of every sort.

To peruse the pricier items, look up: Many of the larger collectibles are in boxes on the upper shelves. But not all — there was a Godzilla figure priced at about $600 just sitting out in the store.

Although it’s not a large building and contains plenty of fragile items, D and E could be a fun place to bring kids. The store has a massive bin of $2 action figures just inside the front door, which a couple of kids were poring through during the Post-Gazette visit.

Advertise with us

Even those cheaper options can carry lots of meaning.

“You’re getting something that isn’t an item that you can just walk into Target and buy off a shelf,” Johnston, the store manager, said. “You took the time to find something that they really care about and didn’t just buy something you can get everywhere.”

700 Main St., Sharpsburg; open 11 a.m.-7 p.m. Wednesday-Sunday; dandecollectibles.com 

Pop Culture Comics

Walking into Pop Culture Comics in Shaler is a similarly overwhelming experience, as you’re greeted by movie posters of every era. The narrow aisles are packed with entertainment memorabilia of every sort — from original movie posters to action figures and magazines to a massive comic book collection.

Many of those comics cost only $2 or $3. Others are listed for several hundred dollars, including a Marvel comic depicting the first named appearance of Kang the Conqueror, for about $700.

Advertise with us

The store’s movie poster collection is robust. Many hang from the ceiling, while others are rolled up in bins throughout the store. Some are in the $10 to $15 range and could make for fun dorm or office decoration. Other vintage items are pricier, like an old “Star Wars” poster listed for more than $100.

If you want to really indulge in nostalgia, Pop Culture has a corner dedicated to VHS tapes (10 for $10, if you still have a device to play them) and old board games.

Despite the high value of many items, most of the store’s inventory is set out for shoppers to touch. Only a few areas are behind glass cases — an intentional choice by business owner Rudisill, who opened the store in 2016.

“The big reason is, I have three daughters who grew up coming to this store. So, as you can see when you walk through here, this stuff is all accessible for kids to run through, grab things, play with things,” he said. “Now, do I take on damage, broken product? Absolutely, but I’m never going to not make this place kid-friendly, because kids are what built this place.”

A number of boxes sit on the floor of one aisle, full of miscellaneous, cheap action figures for kids to explore.

Advertise with us

Pop Culture has a second location off Sussex Avenue in Baldwin Township. Like D and E, the store offers a wide variety of pricing options.

“I’m not scared to put something on the shelf for two bucks,” Rudisill said. “And I’m not scared to put something on the shelf for $2,000.”

1105 Mt. Royal Blvd., Shaler; open 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Monday-Friday, 10 a.m. to 7 p.m. Saturday and noon to 5 p.m. Sunday; buypopculture.com
3049 Sussex Ave., Baldwin; open 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Wednesday-Friday, 10 a.m. to 7 p.m. Saturday and noon to 5 p.m. Sunday

Wexford General Store Antiques

A visit to Wexford General Store Antiques is a step back in time, in more ways than one. True to its name, the shop in Pine sits in a former 19th-century general store. 

Its packed shelves don’t need much decoration, but the owners have left relics of its former life in certain spots. Behind the front counter is a shelf full of old containers, like coffee tins and tobacco boxes. It’s almost a makeshift museum exhibit.

Advertise with us

The shop is a co-op, run by about 20 antique dealers, and their varying tastes drive the store’s eclectic offerings. You really never know what you’re going to see around each corner.

In cases near the cash register, there were specialty pipes for about $80. A few steps over, myriad paintings hung on the walls, ranging from under $50 to more than $2,000.

You can find vintage license plates for cheap. Or a beautiful vintage sewing machine for … not cheap. (This reporter spotted one for about $400.) 

The store is filled with traditional gifts — jewelry, china and a sprawling collection of used books. It also has many distinctly nontraditional options that can play to loved ones’ passions as well. 

For the writing enthusiast, the antique shop had a typewriter. For the hunter or bird-watcher, it had a set of vintage duck decoys, which appeared to include real feathers. For photographers, it had a number of old cameras.

Advertise with us

The antique furniture selection robust, from a stunning walnut rolltop desk to cabinets and bookshelves of many sorts. But the store has evolved to meet the tastes of a modern audience.

“The younger crowd today, they don’t want grandma’s antiques anymore. They don’t want primitives,” said Marino, whose parents own the antique store and started it in 1966. “They don’t want old, dusty things that just don’t do anything. They have to have some historical significance. They have to be functional. They have to appeal to their aesthetic.”

The wide variety of items on sale across the price spectrum mean holiday shoppers might be able to find something for several people in one trip.

“My mom likes to call the place ‘a fun place to shop,’ ” Marino said. “The fact that it has such an eclectic variety of things that really appeals to a wider audience, that’s why we are getting a lot of young people in [and] we are getting the good old-timers that are just staples.”

Wexford General Store Antiques will host a Christmas open house from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Nov. 30.

Advertise with us

150 Church Road, Pine; open 10 a.m.-5 p.m. daily; wexfordantiques.com

Steel City Collectibles

Pittsburgh has no shortage of sports fanatics, and Steel City Collectibles has no shortage of unique gifts for them.

The sports trading card and memorabilia company has a retail store in White Oak and a large online presence, including a vibrant “breaking” business — in which a store representative opens a pack of cards while streaming live, with people buying into the “break” so they can take home the cards from a certain team (assuming it’s sports, as there are gaming and other entertainment card breaks as well).

Ringing the store are autographed jerseys from players in Pittsburgh and across the sports world. There was a Paul Skenes signed jersey listed for about $330 and a Doug Drabek jersey for about $60. Steelers fans could take home a signed helmet from Ben Roethlisberger for around $700 or a Dermontti Dawson jersey for about $70.

The sports memorabilia collection goes beyond black and gold, with signed jerseys from Saquon Barkley (about $260), Larry Bird (about $270), Anthony Edwards (about $330) and more. 

Advertise with us

The store’s warehouse contains far more treasures. Merkol, the retail store manager, estimated that Steel City has autographed memorabilia from 1,500 different athletes.

“If they have a favorite athlete that’s not run of the mill, there’s a good chance we have something available from them,” Smerkol said.

There also were copious boxes of sports cards on the shelves, ranging from around $10 to more than $600. These gifts might turn out to be even more valuable than the original sticker price.

“You open a $10 pack, and you could hit a card worth 40 or 50 grand out of it,” Smerkol said.

There’s something for the non-sports crowd as well — from Pokemon and other gaming cards to the freaky-looking but wildly popular Labubu dolls (the retail store had some boxes for about $30 and another for around $450).

Advertise with us

“We’re one of the few stores in the area that have authentic Labubus for sale,” Smerkol said. “That has been a driver that’s brought in new faces to the shop.”

1931 Lincoln Way, White Oak; open 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Monday-Thursday, 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. Friday-Saturday and 1-6 p.m. Sunday; steelcitycollectibles.com