The 2023-24 Oscars cycle has been oddly boring, even for someone who likely cares about film awards more than the average pop culture consumer.
Those who pay even relatively close attention to this stuff have probably clocked how increasingly easy it has become over the past decade to predict Academy Awards results. It helps that prognosticators now have almost a century of Oscars history to draw from, seemingly endless precursor awards shows to glean where voters are leaning and awards prediction sites like GoldDerby that usually have their fingers on Hollywood’s pulse.
All those tools make the act of forecasting who the winners will be during Sunday’s telecast less exciting than it should be. That said, there are a few categories that have garnered genuine intrigue over the last few weeks — especially best actress.
Just about every field is stacked with worthy nominees from what was an exceptional year at the movies. Here’s what this critic thinks will (and should) win at the 2024 Academy Awards:
Best picture
What will win: “Oppenheimer”
Read More
What should win: “Killers of the Flower Moon”
“Oppenheimer” has felt like an unstoppable freight train as it continues to dominate awards season. For my money, this expansive and visually impressive biopic of atomic bomb architect J. Robert Oppenheimer is the best thing Christopher Nolan has ever made and a perfectly fine best picture winner.
I would be remiss, however, if I didn’t advocate for my No. 1 movie of 2023 that still feels just a tick above “Oppenheimer” in terms of scale, striking imagery and emotional resonance. It would be a shame if “Killers of the Flower Moon” didn’t win a single trophy on Sunday, which may very well happen unless ...
Actress in a leading role
Who will win: Lily Gladstone, “Killers of the Flower Moon,” or Emma Stone, “Poor Things”
Who should win: Emma Stone, “Poor Things”
This will be my only copout, as best actress is way too close to call. Both Gladstone and Stone absolutely deserve all the accolades they’ve picked up over the last few months that have secured their dual status as this category’s frontrunners. A Gladstone win for her subtle yet devastating turn in “Killers of the Flower Moon” would be both unquestionably earned and a historic moment for Native American representation at the Oscars.
My heart, though, screams for Stone’s breathlessly brave performance in “Poor Things.” It’s truly unlike anything the 2017 best actress winner has ever done before. Stone’s mesmerizing work as a blank slate discovering all of life’s pleasures and evils in real time gives her a slight edge in my estimation.
Actor in a leading role
Who will win: Cillian Murphy, “Oppenheimer”
Who should win: Jeffrey Wright, “American Fiction”
For a while, best actor was a two-man race between Murphy’s portrayal of his film’s titular theoretical physicist and Paul Giamatti’s hilarious and heartbreaking work as a grumpy teacher in “The Holdovers.” Murphy appears to have the inside track at this point, though I would love to see Wright surprise everyone with a win for how effortlessly he brought surly writer Thelonious "Monk" Ellison to life in “American Fiction.”
Sorry, Colman Domingo. You were great in the Pittsburgh-shot Netflix biopic “Rustin,” but I don’t think this is your year.
Actress in a supporting role
Who will win: Da'Vine Joy Randolph, “The Holdovers”
Who should win: Da'Vine Joy Randolph, “The Holdovers”
Randolph was wonderful as a grieving mother in “The Holdovers” and has already won pretty much every pre-Oscars award for which she was nominated. Don’t overthink this one.
Actor in a supporting role
Who will win: Robert Downey Jr., “Oppenheimer”
Who should win: Ryan Gosling, “Barbie”
Like Randolph, Downey has spent the last several months taking home award after award for his magnetically smarmy embodiment of former Atomic Energy Commission chair Lewis Strauss in “Oppenheimer.” Chances are good he’ll nab his first Oscar on Sunday as well.
Gosling’s charm offensive as Ken in “Barbie,” though, was one of 2023’s most culturally ubiquitous (and memeable) performances. Oscar voters may not still be feeling the Kenergy, but I sure am.
Director
Who will win: Christopher Nolan, “Oppenheimer”
Who should win: Christopher Nolan, “Oppenheimer”
With apologies to Martin Scorsese and Yorgos Lanthimos, this is Nolan’s moment. With “Oppenheimer,” he finally found a way to seamlessly blend story and spectacle after a decade of making movies that I’d generally describe as technically dazzling but emotionally vacant. Give this man his Oscar.
Writing (original screenplay)
What will win: “Anatomy of a Fall”
What should win: “Past Lives”
To be clear, “Anatomy of a Fall” absolutely rules and made me say out loud multiple times, “That was such smart writing!” But I still can’t get that final “Past Lives” conversation between Greta Lee’s Nora and Teo Yoo’s Hae Sung out of my head that’s expertly punctuated with a simple, “See you then.” Chills!!!
Writing (adapted screenplay)
What will win: “Oppenheimer”
What should win: “American Fiction”
Nolan gets a ton of credit for transforming Kai Bird and Martin J. Sherwin’s 2005 Oppenheimer biography “American Prometheus” into both an engaging depiction of the Manhattan Project and gripping courtroom drama. Cord Jefferson pulled off an arguably more impressive trick with his “American Fiction” screenplay that adapted Percival Everett’s 2001 novel “Erasure” into a poignant family drama and biting publishing industry satire.
Animated feature
What will win: “Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse”
What should win: “Elemental”
Pixar’s “Elemental” is still 2023’s best rom-com and remains a more memorable cinematic experience for me than category frontrunners “Across the Spider-Verse” and “The Boy and the Heron” proved to be. It won’t win, but one can dream!
International film
What will win: “The Zone of Interest”
What should win: “The Zone of Interest”
Since “Anatomy of a Fall” inexplicably didn’t even end up as France’s selection for best international film, it’s safe to assume that fellow best picture nominee “The Zone of Interest” will be recognized here for its unrelenting examination of the folks who benefited from unimaginable atrocities.
Documentary feature film
What will win: “20 Days in Mariupol”
What should win: “20 Days in Mariupol”
A documentary that vividly chronicles Russia’s 2022 siege of Mariupol, Ukraine, should be a no-brainer choice for Academy voters. It’s tough to imagine anything else breaking through.
Short film (live action), Short film (animated) and Documentary (short subject)
While I have no thoughts on the animated shorts field, I did want to shout out the current favorites in those other two categories.
Documentary short “The ABCs of Book Banning” explores the dangers of restricting access to literature in schools and could earn co-director (and North Hills native) Trish Adlesic her first Academy Award. Wes Anderson’s hypnotically flat adaptation of Roald Doahl’s 1977 short story “The Wonderful Life of Henry Sugar” should catapult the famed director to best live-action short glory.
Cinematography
What will win: “Oppenheimer”
What should win: “Oppenheimer,” but...
The Trinity Test sequence in “Oppenheimer” alone should be more than enough to sway most voters. However, don’t sleep on the gorgeous Oklahoma vistas captured in “Killers of the Flower Moon” or the textural splendor of every “Poor Things” locale.
Visual effects
What will win: “Godzilla Minus One”
What should win: “Godzilla Minus One”
Pour one out for the animators who made Rocket Raccoon and his fellow animal experiments feel like fully realized characters in “Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3.” What the VFX team on “Godzilla Minus One” was able to accomplish on a reportedly sub-$15 million budget is why it will and should be recognized here.
Sound
What will win: “Oppenheimer”
What should win: “Oppenheimer”
“The Zone of Interest” has a real shot for the way it manipulates sound to heighten the contradiction between its central figures and the horror happening next door. No one should be mad at this semi-inevitable “Oppenheimer” win, though, given how that film’s sound department always knew exactly when to raise, mute or totally drain the volume for maximum dramatic effect.
Production design
What will win: “Poor Things”
What should win: “Barbie”
The way “Poor Things” constructed era-appropriate facsimiles of Lisbon, Alexandria, Paris and Victorian London could reasonably beguile Academy voters. But so could “Barbie,” whose production designers literally built Barbieland out of thin air. They will hopefully be rewarded for their creativity and commitment to that bright but plastic aesthetic.
Makeup and hairstyling
What will win: “Maestro”
What should win: Anything but “Maestro”
Very little could make me angrier on Oscars note than the “Maestro” makeup and hairstyling team winning for their work on a film that featured a wildly problematic nose prosthetic. Maybe common sense will prevail and “Poor Things” will take this category for the incredible makeup effects that turned Willem Dafoe into deformed scientist Godwin Baxter.
Music (original score)
What will win: “Oppenheimer”
What should win: “Oppenheimer”
Honestly, none of these nominees had particularly memorable scores. “Oppenheimer” is the favorite on GoldDerby and composer Ludwig Göransson already has an Oscar for his “Black Panther” score. He can have another one, as a treat.
Music (original song)
What will win: “What Was I Made For?,” “Barbie”
What should win: “I’m Just Ken,” “Barbie”
He’s just Ken. Anywhere else he’d be a 10. What will it take for Oscar voters to see the incredible artistry behind “I’m Just Ken” and fight for its Oscar bona fides?!
Costume design
What will win: “Barbie”
What should win: “Barbie”
Barbie loves a costume change, and her movie didn’t disappoint with live-action re-creations of the character’s many outfits. No other film in this field inspired millions of moviegoers to dress up for the occasion, and they all took inspiration from each Barbie and Kens’ instantly iconic looks.
Film editing
What will win: “Oppenheimer”
What should win: “Oppenheimer”
Slick editing is what allowed “Oppenheimer” to so adeptly jump between timelines and color grades. Emerging victorious from this category will almost certainly increase the odds of “Oppenheimer” becoming the eighth film since 2004 to be honored for its editing prowess before going on to win best picture.
Plan your own Oscar ballots accordingly.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and X @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.