Once again, Carnegie Mellon University’s School of Drama is living up to its reputation as Pittsburgh’s star factory.

Last year, it was then-CMU student Lola Tung starring in the Amazon Prime Video series “The Summer I Turned Pretty.” She returned as Isabel “Belly” Conklin in the show’s second season that aired, naturally, over the summer.

The Tartan generating quite a bit of attention for his acting prowess this fall is Dominic Sessa, a sophomore currently on a leave of absence from CMU’s School of Drama as he navigates the rollout of his big-screen debut in director Alexander Payne’s new dramedy “The Holdovers.” Sessa plays Angus Tully, a troubled student forced to stay at his elite New England boarding school during the 1970s holiday season.

“The Holdovers” is screening Wednesday night at Downtown’s Harris Theater as part of the 2023 Three Rivers Film Festival before it opens wide in theaters Friday. It has already been shortlisted as a strong Academy Awards contender on multiple fronts — including’s Sessa’s work as a smart teenager with abandonment issues searching for guidance wherever he can find it.

Advertise with us

Paul Giamatti stars in “The Holdovers” as Paul Hunham, a largely reviled Barton Academy teacher who becomes Angus’ Christmas-break caretaker. Paul and Angus slowly begin to form a real bond with the help of Mary Lamb (Da’Vine Joy Randolph), the school’s head cook whose son recently died in combat.

Sessa was unable to speak with the Post-Gazette due to SAG-AFTRA’s ongoing strike against the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers. Most actors still not being allowed to promote work they did for struck companies is “heartbreaking to all of us,” Payne said during a recent virtual press conference with a few members of his film’s production team.

Not much is known about Sessa given that he hasn’t been allowed to give any interviews about his experiences making “The Holdovers.” He’s reportedly a 2022 graduate of Deerfield Academy in Massachusetts, which happens to be one of the locations used to create the film’s fictional Barton Academy.

“The very first time that Dominic walked into an audition for a show we knew immediately, the moment he opened his mouth, that he was a deeply gifted actor,” Catriona Hynds, Deerfield’s visual and performing arts chair and theater director, told The Deerfield Scroll in June 2022.

Payne said that casting director Susan Shopmaker fielded “probably 800 submissions” for the role of Angus Tully before expanding her search to high school drama students. Sessa, in Payne’s estimation, felt “a little too old for the part” and not exactly what he had envisioned for Angus based on David Hemingson’s script.

Advertise with us

“He had the right hair,” Payne quipped. “If he didn’t have the right hair, he might not have gotten the part as easily.”

It still took multiple auditions and a Zoom read-through with Giamatti to convince Payne that Sessa had both the “emotional intelligence” and “life experience” necessary to play Angus.

Sessa said in that same Deerfield Scroll article that he was “very nervous going in” to making “The Holdovers” because he had never done any film acting before. No one would ever guess that was the case, though, based on the way Payne raved about his young star.

“Dominic kind of didn’t need much help,” Payne said. “He took to it like a duck to water. I’ve never seen such an innate talent, not just for acting but for film acting.”

“The Holdovers” is largely based on Hemingson’s days at a private boarding school. He was struck by how “totally comfortable” Sessa looked conveying the words and ideas from his screenplay.

Advertise with us

“He’s got this sort of natural grace to him. ...,” Hemingson said. “He looks like this Caravaggio angel, but slightly broken. There’s an intensity and beauty to him.”

Those qualities have clearly resonated with enough cinephiles to vault Sessa into the Oscars race. Awards predictions site GoldDerby lists him as a top 10 candidate for a best supporting actor nomination. GoldDerby is also giving “The Holdovers” solid odds of being nominated for best picture, best director, best actor (Giamatti), best supporting actress (Randolph), original screenplay and film editing.

Whatever happens this awards season, it’s pretty clearly that “The Holdovers” has totally altered the trajectory of this CMUers’ career prospects.

As Hynds said to The Deerfield Scroll: “His life will be forever changed by this extraordinary opportunity.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.