Pittsburgh finally has itself another Academy Awards contender. And wouldn’t you know it, it came from the same filmmaker who helmed the Steel City’s most recent dalliance with Oscars glory.
The last locally shot film to pique the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences’ interest was director George C. Wolfe’s 2020 adaptation of the 1982 August Wilson play “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom,” which earned two trophies at the 2021 Oscars. Star Chadwick Boseman was heavily expected to win a posthumous best actor Oscar for his mesmerizingly chaotic “Ma Rainey” performance, though that honor ultimately went to Anthony Hopkins for his work in “The Father.”
‘‘RUSTIN’

Starring: Colman Domingo, Glynn Turman, Michael Potts, Johnny Ramey, CCH Pounder, Chris Rock, Jeffrey Wright, Aml Ameen.
Rating: Rated PG-13 for thematic material, some violence, sexual material, language including racial slurs, brief drug use and smoking.
Streaming: Netflix (on Nov. 17)
Wolfe returned to Western Pennsylvania in late 2021 to direct “Rustin,” a biopic of March on Washington architect Bayard Rustin debuting in theaters Friday before it hits Netflix on Nov. 17. The film brought Wolfe back to Pittsburgh alongside “Ma Rainey” cast members Colman Domingo (Rustin), Glynn Turman (labor leader A. Philip Randolph) and Michael Potts (civil rights activist Cleveland Robinson).
“Rustin” is a fairly standard biopic bolstered by its own weighty subject matter and excellent across-the-board acting. Its biggest draw, though, is Domingo’s captivating turn as the titular Rustin, which has a fantastic chance of once again vaulting a Wolfe-directed performance into the best actor race.
By 1963, Bayard Rustin has established himself as a well-known but down-on-his-luck veteran of the Civil Rights Movement. He begins obsessing over the concept of getting 100,000 people to march on the National Mall in Washington, D.C., in peaceful pursuit of increased civil and economic liberties for Black Americans. Rustin’s ambitious idea gains the support of Randolph, Robinson, Martin Luther King Jr. (Aml Ameen) and a group of young volunteers who believe in his vision.
He also encounters folks like NAACP leader Roy Wilkins (Chris Rock) and Rep. Adam Clayton Powell (Jeffrey Wright) who either don’t think Rustin can pull off such a massive undertaking or think his flamboyant nature (and sexual orientation) could potentially undermine its goals. If all that wasn’t stressful enough, Rustin also ends up catching feelings for Elias Taylor (Johnny Ramey), a fellow civil rights champion who’s terrified to live his full truth.
It’s dismissive to slap an “Oscars bait” label on any film, but “Rustin” certainly contains both positive and negative elements associated with that term. All the ingredients are present for the type of movie that practically shouts, “Look at how important I am!” Though somewhat guilty in that regard, “Rustin” mostly mitigates that cynicism by spotlighting a legitimately under-discussed historical figure and his painstaking efforts to put together what ended up being a seminal day for both the Civil Rights Movement and the county at large.
Pittsburghers may find it amusing that many local facades seemingly matched the film’s mid-1960s aesthetic well enough that they were either barely changed or left entirely alone. The “Rustin” production team deserves a ton of credit for its many spectacularly rendered period trappings and costumes. The film also immerses audiences in Rustin’s world by thickly laying on the perils of living in that era as a person of color, member of the LGBTQ+ community or, as was the case for its main character, both.
“Rustin” squeezes in many allusions to and short scenes featuring quite a few famous Americans involved in planning the March on Washington and the overall fight for civil rights. It’s clear who the film is most focused on, though seeing the likes of Ella Baker (Audra McDonald) and a young John Lewis (Maxwell Whittington-Cooper) relegated to cameo status is a bit jarring.
Those sorts of decisions are emblematic of the general sense that “Rustin” could have gone further and deeper in its explorations of that singular moment in American history. It unquestionably does justice to Rustin and a few other key figures, but the fact it also makes no obvious attempts to connect his tribulations with similar struggles that many still face today may be disappointing for some moviegoers hoping for a little more oomph in its overall messaging.
That said, Julian Breece and Dustin Lance Black’s generally sharp screenplay does deliver a series of fascinating ideological debates between civil rights heavyweights. Anyone familiar with the film’s first trailer has already witnessed Rustin challenging King on how all-encompassing the notion of “freedom and justice for all” really is. Those free-flowing idea exchanges peppered throughout “Rustin” are when the film is at its most gripping and thought-provoking.
With “Ma Rainey,” Wolfe proved that all it takes is a steady hand when you have actors like Boseman and Viola Davis chewing up the scenery. He smartly employs the same techniques on “Rustin” that similarly allow actors like Domingo to cook without any directorial flourishes distracting from their performance. There are definitely scenes that Wolfe could’ve imbued with a little more panache, but no one can accuse “Rustin” of being incompetently made.
Domingo clearly relished the chance to portray every facet of Rustin’s jubilant but tortured existence. His Rustin may be endlessly charming and quick with a big laugh, but that outward joy masks a lot of anger and sadness stemming from the racist and homophobic adversity he’s constantly experiencing.
Showy but vulnerable is a tricky balancing act, especially while playing a real person. It would be surprising if Domingo’s full-scale embodiment of Bayard Rustin doesn’t resonate with a majority of Oscars voters.
Turman’s Randolph exudes quiet intensity that he’s not afraid to unleash when necessary. Potts’ Robinson is amusingly bombastic, and Ameen plays a measured King who thrives in front of a microphone. Wright dials it up to great affect as Powell brings up rumors and past transgressions to derail Rustin’s ascent.
Shoutouts are also in order for Ramey as the deeply confused Taylor, Gus Halper as fellow Rustin paramour Tom and CCH Pounder as strong-willed organizer Anna Hedgeman. Rock is the only cast member who noticeably has trouble fitting into “Rustin” due to his instantly recognizable voice and incongruous acting choices.
As straight-down-the-middle biopics go, “Rustin” stands out just enough thanks to some genuinely compelling material and a truly special central performance.
Though it’s way too early for concrete awards-season predictions, most viewers will likely agree that Domingo’s must-see work in “Rustin” is worthy of catapulting yet another Wolfe-helmed project — and Pittsburgh — back to the Oscars.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.