Brooke Smith made it out of Buffalo Bill’s House alive once, and she’s pretty sure she can do it again.
Anyone who has seen “The Silence of the Lambs” will remember Smith as kidnapping victim Catherine Martin, aka the girl in the well who Jodie Foster’s Clarice Starling liberated in the Western Pennsylvania-filmed horror classic. She’ll be returning to the scene of that cinematic crime Friday-Sunday for a weekend of photo ops and meet-and-greets with patrons of Buffalo Bill’s House, the Perryopolis residence in which serial killer Jame “Buffalo Bill” Gumb (Ted Levine) kept Martin that’s now operating as an intentionally creepy bed-and-breakfast.
Tickets for tours, overnight stays and special VIP experiences with Smith are available via buffalobillshouse.com. It will be Smith’s first time in this region since 1989, and she’s just hoping Buffalo Bill’s House owner Chris Rowan hasn’t roped her into an even more meta experience than the one she already signed up for.
“This is an elaborate setup for a horror movie!” Smith told the Post-Gazette with a laugh. “Get the actress from a horror movie from a long time ago, get her to come. I’m a little anxious about that.”
She first met Rowan in March at Monster-Mania Con in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. A few months later, while at “Days of the Dead” in Indianapolis, they solidified plans for her to visit Buffalo Bill’s House sometime in fall 2023.
“As a huge film enthusiast since childhood, it’s incredible to have Brooke Smith ... return to Buffalo Bill’s House for the very first time since shooting the film on location over 30 years ago,” Rowan said via email. “After recently meeting Brooke, I never could have anticipated that she would soon be coming to Buffalo Bill’s House to sign fan autographs and actually get in our custom-built recreation of the well with our guests.”
For the record, Smith has kept plenty busy since “The Silence of the Lambs” became a cultural phenomenon upon its release in 1991. Her most notable non-”Silence” role is probably Dr. Erica Hahn across multiple seasons of the ABC medical drama “Grey’s Anatomy,” and she recently appeared in the FX miniseries “Class of ‘09.”
There’s also last year’s “Sunday Matinee,” a book of photographs Smith took during the 1980s while immersed in New York City’s punk scene. She’s currently developing a documentary project that would allow her to see “what became of all my punk sisters back in the day.” In Smith’s experience, horror fans and punks have a lot in common in the sense that many of them seem to know each other and have formed a “community around this thing they love.”
It’s not lost on Smith that she can’t seem to escape the allure of pits, including the many concert mosh pits that predated her ”Silence of the Lambs” fame and her enduring connection to the Pittsburgh area.
“To go from that pit to this Pitt, there are all kinds of pits!” she quipped.
Her main memories of the approximately two weeks she spent in this region involve Iron City Beer and Primanti Bros., which she said “was helpful when I was gaining 25 pounds” to play Martin. She has heard that “Pittsburgh’s really happening right now” and is excited to rediscover the Steel City more than three decades after her first excursion here.

Most of Smith’s “Silence of the Lambs” scenes were filmed on a local sound stage, and she recalled spending about a day in total at that 113-year-old home in Perryopolis. Though she isn’t a staple on the convention circuit, the two she did this year were serendipitous in terms of establishing a relationship with Rowan and Buffalo Bill’s House.
“He was eager to get me there,” Smith said. “I was kind of intrigued myself. We just started talking about doing this. ... I want to go on a tour!”
Folks who attend the first few Buffalo Bill’s House tours this weekend can expect to be joined by Smith. After that, she’ll be on hand to sign autographs and copies of her book, take photos both in and outside of the house’s replica well, and just generally hang out. Smith is a self-described “hoarder” who also plans to bring along some behind-the-scenes photos from the set of “The Silence of the Lambs.”
She’s confident that “enough time has passed that I should be OK” returning to the house in which her character was terrorized by a psychopath who kept imploring her to rub lotion onto her skin — “or else it gets the hose again.” Smith is genuinely looking forward to being back at Buffalo Bill’s House and thinks “it’ll be a trip to check that all out again.”
“I’m sure it’s great to go there when I’m not there,” Smith said. “But when I am there? Come on, it’ll be fantastic!”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.