Western Pennsylvania has long attracted visitors interested in checking out landmarks associated with horror movie history. Most of that tourism is connected to George Romero’s “Living Dead” franchise and includes locales like the Evans City Cemetery from 1968’s “Night of the Living Dead” and Monroeville Mall from 1978’s “Dawn of the Dead.”

Here’s another destination that horror enthusiasts may want to consider checking out: Buffalo Bill’s House, the 113-year-old home in Perryopolis where serial killer Jame “Buffalo Bill” Gumb (Ted Levine) kept Catherine Martin (Brooke Smith) hostage in a well and ended up facing off against FBI agent-in-training Clarice Starling (Jodie Foster) in the 1991 horror-thriller “The Silence of the Lambs.”

The house was recently refurbished and decked out with “Silence”-related goodies ranging from a 6-foot animatronic Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins) in the front foyer to a “Buffalo Bill’s Workshop of Horror” in the basement to a replica well dug into the house’s former coal cellar. Buffalo Bill’s House is currently operating as a bed-and-breakfast for overnight stays and will also be holding guided tours over the next few months from June 16-18, July 7-9, Sept. 22-24 and Oct. 28-29.

Owner Chris Rowan said that Buffalo Bill’s House has welcomed guests from 35 states and seven countries since officially opening in September 2021, with some folks coming all the way from places like Austria, Germany and Denmark.

Advertise with us

“It really warms my dark heart to know that our unique, small family business resonates with people, even 32 years after the release of ‘The Silence of the Lambs,’” Rowan told the Post-Gazette. “As a lifelong film enthusiast, it is an honor to share our iconic home with those who love cinema as much as we do!”

Buffalo Bill's House, a Perryopolis home that was used during the filming of 1991's "The Silence of the Lambs," has been renovated to reflect the house's cinematic history. (Alexis Fatalsky Photography)

Cross-state trip

It turns out that visiting the house where Buffalo Bill insisted that Catherine “rub the lotion on its skin” can make for a surprisingly rewarding couple’s activity. Just ask Christina Puff, 39, and her fiancé, Michael Gallagher, both of Coatesville in Eastern Pennsylvania. They stayed at Buffalo Bill’s House for two nights during the weekend of May 19-21 and had a blast.

Puff is an Ellwood City native and 2006 graduate of famed makeup artist Tom Savini’s Special Make-Up Effects Program based out of Monessen’s Douglas Education Center. She and Gallagher are both horror movie buffs, with “The Silence of the Lambs” being a particular favorite. Gallagher said the film “was kind of mind-blowing” when he first watched it at 11 years old and Puff recalled Foster’s Clarice Starling inspiring her to think about becoming an FBI agent.

The couple now own a construction company in Chester County and only found out about Buffalo Bill’s House after meeting Rowan at a horror convention in New Jersey.

Advertise with us

“When you see opportunities like that, especially that are in Pennsylvania, you kind of jump on them,” Gallagher said.

He appreciated how the house was “recaptured with authenticity inside,” right down to the original wallpaper. As a carpenter, Puff was taken with the craftsmanship that went into renovating this early 20th-century structure and loved that Rowan chose not to strip away the “ugly green color paint” on the door jamb leading into the basement as seen in the movie.

“As a horror person, you had to do it,” Puff said of their visit. “If you’re a film buff, even a location buff, it’s definitely a fun experience to do something like that as a couple.”

Michael Gallagher, left, Christina Puff, Whitney Stedman and Steve Tarozzi pose for a photo during their stay at Buffalo Bill's House in Perryopolis. (Christina Puff)

‘So many fine details’

It wasn’t just Puff and Gallagher on this Buffalo Bill’s House excursion, though. They were joined by Whitney Stedman, 34, and Steve Tarozzi, 37, both of Broomall in Delaware County, who they had met at a Halloween ball in Salem, Massachusetts.

Advertise with us

Tarozzi, an emergency services worker, and Stedman, a physical therapist, also both love horror movies and have been known to dabble in cosplay, particularly as Beetlejuice and Lydia Deetz from the 1988 Tim Burton film. They also discovered Buffalo Bill’s House at a local convention and even helped Rowan hold his tent down as a monsoon passed through the area.

Both couples got to watch “The Silence of the Lambs” there, partake in some fava beans and a nice Chianti, and take advantage of other amenities like an on-site fire pit. Stedman and Tarozzi expected to explore more Fayette County attractions, but as Stedman put it, “You could be snowed in all weekend and never get bored.”

Tarozzi suggested that anyone thinking of booking a stay at Buffalo Bill’s House do so for at least two nights because “there was just so much to do in the house.”

“Take the time to relax into the house and explore the nooks and crannies,” Stedman added. “There are so many fine details that are hidden that you’ll find eventually if you stop and look.”

David Blahut and his daughter, Anna Blahut, pose with the animatronic Hannibal Lector in the front foyer of Buffalo Bill's House in Perryopolis. (David Blahut)

‘You’re in a movie’

Advertise with us

Buffalo Bill’s House can also apparently be a fun place for parents and their children to hang out as well. Exhibit A: Munhall resident David Blahut, 54, his wife Jennifer and their 14-year-old daughter Anna did a tour of the approximately 2,500-square-foot house on 2 acres of land. Anna is a rising freshman at Serra Catholic High School, while her father is a Pittsburgh Police officer who just last week testified as part of the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting trial.

He was just breaking into law enforcement when he stumbled across Foster shooting some scenes for “The Silence of the Lambs” Downtown. He has been into horror movies ever since and is now sharing his affection for that genre with his daughter. Anna said that she doesn’t typically indulge in horror, but “‘The Silence of the Lambs’ is an exception for me” and she had no qualms about experiencing Buffalo Bill’s House with her family.

“I just thought it would be a good way to bond with my parents,” she said. “It may seem weird, but it’s something we have in common, is enjoyable and makes it feel like you’re in the movie.”

When David first stepped foot into Buffalo Bill’s House, he found himself “thinking the cameras are going to be there” based on how much it still looks like it did in the early 1990s. Both father and daughter got a kick out of all the movie memorabilia placed around the house and snapping photos in the well. They would both definitely go there again, and David has been singing its praises to his coworkers ever since that trip.

“The atmosphere of the house, the way they play out scenes in the house from the actual movie, it’s amazing what they put on for you,” he said. “You just get so immersed in the movie. If you’re any bit of a fan, this would be the place to go.”

Advertise with us

That’s the sort of evangelism Rowan loves to hear from previous Buffalo Bill’s House patrons.

“Be sure to come visit us this summer,” he said in a message to prospective guests, before facetiously threatening: “Or else you’ll get the hose again!”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.