Much like its main protagonist, “Turning Red” is caught between two identities.
On the one hand, Pixar’s latest film out on Disney+ Friday is a beautifully rendered work of animation featuring a mostly endearing assortment of characters and enough heart and humor to amuse children and their parents. But the film is also thematically incoherent to the point that it’s hard to glean exactly what it’s trying to say about family, growing up and even bodily autonomy.
‘‘TURNING RED’’

Starring: Rosalie Chiang, Sandra Oh, Ava Morse, Maitreyi Ramakrishnan, Hyein Park.
Rating: PG for thematic material, suggestive content and language.
Read More
Streaming: Disney+
To be fair, kids aren’t going to care about any of that and will almost certainly be entertained just by the film’s bright colors and the mere fact that red pandas might be the most adorable creatures on the planet. But Pixar has built its brand on crafting animated films that resonate with both children and adults. “Turning Red” may leave the folks who grew up on the studio’s movies wondering exactly what this one was going for.
Mei Lee (voiced by Rosalie Chiang) is a 13-year-old with a tight-knit group of friends, two loving parents and a tremendous amount of pressure on her to excel in everything. That nagging need to always be the best at everything stems from her mother, Ming (Sandra Oh), who means well but seems willfully ignorant of her daughter’s changing priorities as she develops into a young woman.
In an unpleasant surprise for Mei, it turns out there is a generations-spanning history of the woman in her family being possessed by a red panda spirit and transforming into giant red pandas when they can’t keep their emotions in check. Mei slowly comes to the realization that the red panda inside her may be more of a blessing than a curse as it helps her gain the confidence necessary to be her most authentic self.
“Turning Red” has more in common with last year’s Pixar offering “Luca” than 2020’s “Soul” in terms of not being quite as high-minded with how it tackles weighty subjects in ways palatable for young minds. This one isn’t a meditation on the human condition as much as it is a singular story of one girl’s quest for both internal and external acceptance of who she is and wants to be.
The film lives up to Pixar’s high animation standards, especially when it comes to bringing the red panda herself to life. Mei’s humanoid panda is expressive, and both Chiang and the animators do a great job of making sure there’s never a question about what she is feeling at any given time. “Turning Red” also lovingly re-creates quite a bit of Chinese culture in a way that bursts off the screen with its sumptuous attention to detail.
It’s worth noting that “Turning Red” is set in 2002 Toronto, and boy does it make the most of that decision. Folks who came of age around that time will appreciate touches like Mei and her friends obsessing over that era’s boy-band craze, all the flip phones and the surprisingly important role a Tamagotchi plays in the proceedings. Kids might wonder what some of those things are, which is an excellent opportunity to teach them about your favorite early 2000s fads.
Pixar mines the biggest feels in “Turning Red” from Mei’s relationship with her friends Miriam (Ava Morse), Priya (Maitreyi Ramakrishnan) and Abby (Hyein Park). They all have each other’s back through thick and thin, and their bond forms the backbone for the film’s most genuine emotional beats. It will definitely make some adults nostalgic for the purity of teenage friendships.
Where the film stumbles a bit in that same arena is Mei’s fraught relationship with her mother. Ming seems almost unbelievably oblivious to Mei needing more from life than academic success as she enters her adolescent years. “Turning Red” peels back the layers on Ming and why she’s so overprotective of her daughter, but those revelations don’t totally negate some of her more toxic actions that could have scarred Mei for life.
There also seems to be some confusion in the film’s ultimate messaging for kids. “Turning Red” mostly appears to be championing body positivity and providing a roadmap for families to navigate the problems inherent in children seeking independence from their parents. But a few character decisions toward the film’s climax muddle those ideas and make it unclear where the film actually landed on them.
At least the voice-acting is excellent across the board, particularly from Chiang and her trio of loyal friends. They all do a great job of capturing teenage angst and the tunnel vision of wanting nothing more in life than to see their favorite boy band live on stage. Ming’s characterization aside, Oh at least imbues her with enough maternal love to make her eventual redemption ring true.
Again, kids are going to find a lot to love in “Turning Red” and burgeoning young adults will probably latch onto some familiar feelings they’ve been experiencing as they watch Mei and her inner circle play them out on screen. They probably won’t notice that certain themes and characterizations aren’t as tightly executed as they are in other Pixar films.
Neither will most adults, honestly. Those elements may put off some older viewers, but the lush animation and moving ode to teenage friendship will most likely obscure those enough to make for an entertaining 100 minutes of Pixar-induced fun.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.