February 27, 2011. A Sunday unlike any other: the night James Franco and Anne Hathaway hosted the 83rd Academy Awards.

Right up front, the two film stars jokingly made it clear why ABC had broken the tradition of more mature hosts.

“Anne, I must say you look so beautiful, and so hip!” Mr. Franco said.

“Oh thank you, James,” she replied. “You look very appealing to a younger demographic as well.”

Advertise with us

It was a disaster. There was little chemistry between the two. Yet this opening didn’t reach quite the jaw-dropping horror of 1989, when Rob Lowe and “Snow White” Eileen Bowman pranced through an overlong, campy Marvin Hamlisch/Allan Carr arrangement of tunes, such as “Proud Mary,” “I’ve Got a Lovely Bunch of Coconuts” and “I Only Have Eyes for You,” before host Lily Tomlin arrived to salvage the broadcast.

But James and Anne, they were up there.

In light of this year’s controversy over who — if anyone — should host the Feb. 24 broadcast, it’s helpful to recall what not to do (roll tape, or, more accurately, go to the YouTube video). Nominations for this year’s Oscars ceremony on ABC will be announced Jan. 22.

A disproportionate number of comedians has hosted the Oscars. Bob Hope is tops, having hosted 19 times, followed by Billy Crystal, with nine. Others include Johnny Carson, Chris Rock, Whoopi Goldberg, Jon Stewart. But there’s nothing funny about the back-and-forth will-he/won’t-he Kevin Hart debacle.

Mr. Hart was chosen to host the 91st Academy Awards ceremony before protests over previous anti-LGBTQ comments Mr. Hart has made forced him to step down. And then his friend, another former Oscars host, Ellen DeGeneres, appeared to broker his return. And that fell through.

Advertise with us

That was enough for the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences to state it would go without a host for only the second time in Oscars history.

But next year? No one asked us, but here are a few suggestions.

• Ditch the monologue and bring in a Broadway producer for a boffo opening number featuring the host (or not) and just let the celeb do the requisite introductions of the presenters. Simple.

And of course, some host ideas follow. Clip and save. You’re welcome, Hollywood.

• Idris Elba is People’s “sexiest man alive” and a star both on television (“Luther,” “The Wire”) and film (“The Dark Tower,” the upcoming “Fast & Furious” spinoff). Long touted as possibly the next James Bond, he would bring a certain British gravitas and deejay experience to the proceedings.

Advertise with us

• Melissa McCarthy will likely be nominated Tuesday for “Can You Ever Forgive Me?” It’s a dramatic role but of course the woman is also hilarious (watch her “Saturday Night Live” appearances, or the outtakes from “Bridesmaids” some time).

• A couple of Billys: Porter and Eichner. They sing, they can be funny or dramatic and their respective stars are on the rise. Mr. Porter has a Tony for “Kinky Boots” and has been an awards season staple with nominations for his role as Pray Tell on FX’s “Pose.” Mr. Eichner, as anyone who has ever watched “Billy On The Street,” brings a lightning-fast wit to his interviews.

• Hugh Jackman (2009 host). Not a comedian, but funny and self-effacing, he is a, well, Jack of all trades. He can sing, dance, banter with the best of them and also has hosted — and won — Tony Awards.

He’s widely considered a really nice guy and one of HIS over-the-top opening numbers at the Oscars was charmingly goofy, ending with the actor belting “I’M WOLVERINE!” He received a standing ovation.

• Anna Kendrick is another song/dance/drama/comedy pro. She has an Oscar nomination (for 2009’s “Up In The Air”) and a Tony nom (1998’s “High Society.”). She’s done the popular “Pitch Perfect” franchise, earning her light comedy cred, and was Cinderella in the movie version of “Into The Woods.” No Snow White, thank goodness.

Advertise with us

• Comedian Patton Oswalt has hosting experience and a huge engagement on social media. He recently posted on Facebook that while he would love the gig, perhaps a few years from now: “It’s not the time for a plump, comfy cis white male to host the Oscars.”

• Would Meryl Streep host? She’s won three Oscars, been nominated 21 times and even though she doesn’t have a dog in the hunt this year, you know she’ll show up. Meryl sings and dances (“Stuck on You”) and simply everybody loves and respects her. Add a reunion with Cher and you’ve got TV (and movie) magic. Or, bring in Tom Hanks, who starred in “The Post” with her last year.

Wouldn’t that be a headline?

One last thing: no pizza deliveries during the Oscars ceremony, no free flu shots, no tours of people from Kansas or whatever. If you wouldn’t want your dinner party interrupted by this stuff, don’t subject the rest of America to anything this lame.

Singing and dancing, that’s cool. Open the show with Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper. Just saying.

Advertise with us

Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or @MariaSciulloPG.