Charity is the greatest of the three great theological virtues. Faith is the most important to one’s personal belief system. Hope is — well, a fine thing, but it always struck me as a kind of watered-down version of (and already contained in) faith. If you have faith, you automatically have hope, don’t you?
Not necessarily, as we discover in Paul Schrader’s “First Reformed,” whose hero Rev. Toller (Ethan Hawke) heads a small, stark Dutch colonial church congregation in an upstate New York village founded in 1767. Rev. Toller is many things — many good things — but “charismatic” isn’t one of them. There are exactly seven people in attendance at the first service we witness.
Perhaps it’s his sad, troubled face. Yes and no — it’s more than that. He’s grappling with the mounting weight of past tragedy and present torment. Did I say troubled? The look in his eyes is better described as stricken, and he is reticent to the point of paralysis.
One of those seven parishioners at the service is devout Mary (Amanda Seyfried). She asks him afterward to speak with her disgruntled husband Mike (Philip Ettinger), who wants to abort their forthcoming baby. Rev. Toller tries to dodge the request, referring her to an outside counselor. But she insists, and he reluctantly makes an awkward house call, where Mike rambles on and on about the impending disasters of climate change and irreversible environmental collapse.
'First Reformed'

- Starring: Ethan Hawke, Amanda Seyfried, Cedric Kyles.
- Rating: R for some disturbing violent images.
How could anyone sanction bringing a child into such a world? Mike wants to know.
“The situation is new but the blackness is ancient,” Toller later confides to his journal. “The all-consuming knowledge of the emptiness of all things can only be filled by the presence of our lord.”
Or the presence of a suicide vest, hidden in Mary’s garage.
Director-writer Schrader belongs chronologically to the Spielberg-Scorsese-Coppola-Lucas generation, but his cinematic and religious background was much more restrictive than theirs. His own strict Dutch Calvinist parents refused to let him see a movie until he was 17. After a stint as a film critic-protege of Pauline Kael, he began writing screenplays with the hugely successful “Taxi Driver” (1976), based on his experiences in Los Angeles, struggling with suicidal depression. That, and subsequent big Scorsese film scripts (including “Raging Bull” and “The Last Temptation of Christ”) led to directing his own risky films — typically, stories of desperate men whose worlds are crumbling around them, like “Affliction” (1997) and “Dog Eat Dog” (2016).
The desperate clergyman in “First Reformed” — aside from Mary and Mike’s problems — is ailing, and drinking heavily on the eve of presiding at his little church’s 250th anniversary reconsecration event. Its benefactor (Michael Gaston), who contributes big bucks to church charities to cover for his crimes as an industrial polluter, insists the ceremony not be “political” — no mention of a late activist’s ashes being scattered at a toxic waste site.
Rev. Toller’s superior (cleverly played by Cedric “the Entertainer” Kyles) tries to mediate: “Do you have any idea what it takes to run a system this size?” he asks Toller. “Even Jesus wasn’t always in the garden, suffering and sweating blood!”
Shot in just 20 days on a tiny (these days) $3.5 million budget, this film is different from all of Mr. Schrader’s previous ones.
“It’s a kind of reworking of Ingmar Bergman’s ‘Winter Light’ (1963), with a little bit of Robert Bresson’s ‘Diary of a Country Priest’ (1951) and a little bit of Andrei Tarkovsky,” he told an interviewer, adding that he was surprised to notice, while editing, how many similarities its hero shared with the self-imposed loneliness of “Taxi Driver’s” Travis Bickle.
The trouble with a spiritual story, says Mr. Schrader, is that “everything in cinema rebels against spirituality. Cinema is based on action and empathy. These are not elements in the transcendental toolkit. In many ways, people who try to do spiritual or contemplative films are working against the grain of the medium itself.”
Nevertheless, this picture is so visually striking — with a Magical Mystery Tour sequence of magic realism — and so measured in its deliberate pacing, as befits its brooding nature and sober themes. (“What is one’s last thought as one pulls the trigger — ‘There goes my head,’ or ‘Jesus, watch over me’? Or neither?”) It is more quietly mesmerizing than anything Mr. Schrader has previously written or directed, and it is perfectly performed. Mr. Hawke gives perhaps his most moving, mature performance to date. Ms. Seyfried is excellent.
This is a tremendously thoughtful, tormented work. There are many tales, in and out of film, of conflicted ministers losing their faith. But this one is about losing hope.
Hope vs. despair. Can you hold two contradictory truths in your mind at the same time?
Post-Gazette film critic emeritus Barry Paris can be reached at parispg48@aol.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.