Jews are just like everybody else only more so, my father liked to say. Orthodox Jewish British lesbians — even more so.

“Disobedience” begins, in stunning fashion, with Rabbi Krushka speaking to his London congregation about the Creation — namely the sixth day, when Hashem created humankind. Prior to that, the only living creatures He had fashioned were the angels and the beasts, neither of which had the faculty of choice. Humans would occupy a special place: Only man and woman would be granted the power to disobey God — “an afterthought or His crowning achievement?” the frail old rabbi asks.

'Disobedience'

Ratings explained

Advertise with us
  • Starring: Rachel Weisz, Rachel McAdams, Alessandro Nivola.
  • Rating: R for strong sexuality and some nudity.

Immediately after which, he drops dead.

Chilean director Sebastian Lelio takes us straight from there to New York City, where we meet Rav Krushka’s taciturn daughter Ronit (Rachel Weisz), a successful financial analyst and cutting-edge photographer, who is having an affair with her married boss. Long out of touch and estranged from her father, she feels obliged to return for his services in England, where, upon arrival, she is greeted with a chilly, “We weren’t expecting you” from her beloved cousin Dovid (Alessandro Nivola).

Dovid is the rabbi’s adopted son, spiritual protege and anointed successor. Behind him — and equally unnerved to see her — is beautiful Esti (Rachel McAdams), her closest childhood friend. Dovid and Esti, deeply devout and devoted to each other, have been married for years.

That’s a shock. But why does Ronit seem so cowed and so shunned by her mourning family, old friends and neighbors? Because the community has never forgotten or forgiven her for an affair, decades earlier, with Esti.

Dovid reluctantly agrees to let Ronit stay in the house, tucking her away in an attic room. But the situation is awkward in the extreme. One reason she returned was to claim and liquidate her father’s property. But the rabbi’s obituary said, “he left no children.” As Dovid was his surrogate son, Esti became his surrogate daughter. Turns out, he left the house and everything in it to his synagogue.

Advertise with us

Bitterness and discomfort all around. Ronit further upsets everyone during a dinner table argument about marriage. But that’s nothing, compared with the upset about sexual preference.

“I had to sleep with a man,” Esti confides to Ronit, “ — so why not our best friend?”

With sudden proximity, their passions reignite. The boundaries of faith and sexuality will be explored — along with the effects of scandal and infidelity, obedience and defiance — when the women are inevitably seen together, caught and fraught with the shame of discovery.

Based on a semiautobiographical novel by Naomi Alderman, the story is in good hands with Mr. Lelio, a leading light in the new wave of South American directors. He won the 2017 best foreign film Oscar for “A Fantastic Woman,” a potent tale of transgender grief. Also much acclaimed was “Gloria” (2013), his mesmerizing character study of an aging, lonely divorcee.

This is his first film in English, atmospherically shot in the claustrophobic neighborhoods of Hendon and Cricklewood — London’s Squirrel Hill, of sorts. “Let’s just go somewhere else,” one woman begs the other. They can only be alone, ironically, in the crowded Underground.

Advertise with us

This is a riveting lesbian-thespian duel of the Rachels: Ms. Weisz is smoldering, Ms. McAdams fragile and frightened. The complexities of two very different characters make for complementary chemistry in their magnetic game of attraction and repulsion. It’s in the play of their eyes more than their words, and in the dissimilar sadness on their faces.

Expect one very passionate, steamy love scene — with post-orgasmic rumination and illumination on a subject as troubling to traditional Judaism as to Christianity and Islam: not so much homosexuality as sexuality itself.

Also expect some tremendously beautiful music, including “Im Eshkakhekh” (If I Forget You Jerusalem) and “Keil Molei Rakhamim” for male voices, in the memorial services.

This fine “Disobedience,” opening today at the Manor Theater only, is unorthodox, in more ways than one, yet eminently reverent: “May you live a long life.” You are free to choose it — however agonizing your freedom, however enslaving or liberating your choice.

Post-Gazette film critic emeritus Barry Paris: parispg48@aol.com.